5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
Good story but read carefully,
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Death on the Don: The Destruction of Germany's Allies on the Eastern Front 194144 (Hardcover)
There are very few books on the subject of the "other" axis forces on the Eastern Front during WWII. There are a lot on the two Finnish wars but for the rest of the axis forces you have to look for a very long time to find anything. Jonathan Trigg has written a book about the Romanian, Hungarian, Italian, Slovak and Croatian forces that participated in the struggle on the Eastern Front and by doing so he fills a gap that has been neglected for a long time.
He writes a good story with a clear and a well flowing text. It is written with the intent to set the record straight about what these forces did and how they did it. The Often written view that they were no good and that they collapsed under the Soviet onslaught is in his book shown to be far from correct. These forces did their best with what they had.
This part of the book is well worth reading and brings new information or a different view to the readers.
But, there is a structural problem with the book. There are no footnotes! There is almost no information on where all these facts came from and as a reader you might sometimes want to check his facts when they appears to be to strange. This would not have been a huge problem if everything in the book was correct but there are mistakes that makes you wonder.
A few examples. Mr Trigg writes about how the soldiers felt when Soviet T-34 tanks tried to crush them in their dugouts. They felt the smell of gasoline. How was that possible when the T-34 ran on diesel?
He tells us of close combat with T-34 were the defenders only chance of knocking them out was to force hand-grenades through the vision ports of the tank. The Problem is that it is impossible to get a hand-grenade through a vision port on a T-34. It is to narrow.
There are other things like the statement that in the spring of 1942 the Germans had only 160 operational tanks on the entire Eastern Front. Source? In 1942 the SSSR had 190 million inhabitants of whom 16 million were of military age? Really? Since the military age is between 18 and 55 where did this figure of 16 million come from?
The Problem with these facts is that when you read a number of very interesting combat memories that he has put into the book, you get a feeling that without any source presented, maybe it is not all correct?
There is a Bibliography at the end of the book but it is not very extensive and most of it is not about the forces he writes about but instead of the war on the Eastern Front in general.
But if you want to know more about the struggle the axis forces had on the Eastern Front this is a book to read. If you know your Eastern Front you also know how to interpret some of the text presented.