3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
A really terrific piece of work..,
This review is from: The German High Command At War: Hindenburg and Ludendorff and the First World War (Paperback)
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, which I found to easily move from the minutiae of great detail to the broad brush strokes of sometimes crushing characterisation. Difficult to read in long sittings due to its intensity, would be my only criticism - this is a read on holiday, not read on the train type book. It is interesting to contrast the characterisation with David Sinclair's "Hall of Mirrors" (more respectful), Robert Massie's "Dreadnought" (more sympathetic on a human level) or John Keegan's "First World War" (less cutting, more "objective"). The impression given is that the two are war-mongers. Whether they had more blood on their hands than the politicians of the age is of course a good question. This book suggests they were much more than misguided patriots, but authority usurpers who wanted nothing less than to takeover the reich. I suspect the pursuit of the war led them to demand (and take) more power, rather than that being their central objective. I would be very interesting in other's opinions of the harshness of the charges laid against the two.