1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Jim Murray's Whisky Bilble 2013,
This review is from: Jim Murray's Whisky Bible 2013 (Paperback)
First of all, I don't want to come across as a malt snob here, I can happily drink cheap blends, however, I do think Jim gives the big cheap blends ridiculously high scores. For example he gives Grant's Family Reserve 94/100 and Ballantine's Finest 96/100, don't get me wrong I like both those whiskies, in fact I often find myself defending Grant's and singing its praises but to score it that highly is just ridiculous, especially when he gives much better blends (in my opinion) like WHYTE AND MACKAY Supreme 22 Year Old Blended Whisky 70cl Bottle a measly 84.5/100. I could almost understand if he took price into consideration but he says in the beginning that he doesn't. It's all subjective I know, no one's going to agree with everything but I just think he doesn't do his credibility any good being so generous to the big cheap blends. Another criticism I have to mention is the varying amount of detail he goes into for individual whiskies, some can take up half a page yet for some there are as little as 3 words. Where's the consistency?
This Whisky Bible however is unrivalled as a whisky guide, Jim's love of the spirit and enthusiasm about the industry comes across on every page offering unbiased (well sort of) ratings and views on just about any whisky you've ever had or want to have. So if you have even the slightest interest in whisky, Jim Murray's Whisky Bible's is a great book to own.