Customer Review

13 of 19 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A Vespri for the Ages, 5 April 2013
This review is from: Verdi: I Vespri Siciliani [Parma 2010] [Nucci, Armiliato, Prestia, Dessí] [C Major: 723904] [Blu-ray] [2013] (Blu-ray)
This production was a big success when mounted in Parma in 2010. The blu-ray is superbly done and should disperse any doubts about this work. Stage director Pier Luigi Pizzi uses an approach he has used before but never so successfully: he updates the action to the 19th century, to the period of the battles over the unification of Italy, and uses the theater's auditorium as an extension of the stage. This idea is far from new, but I never saw it done so effectively. The "breaking of the fourth wall" enables Pizzi to achieve a miracle of sorts: a minimalist staging with some of the Grand Opera effects that Verdi had in mind when he wrote this work for what was the largest opera theatre in the world at the time.

For example, in the opening scene there are only three boats on an otherwise empty stage, and French soldiers make fun of and provoke the local Sicilians. Then Daniela Dessì (Elena) makes an electrifying grand entrance from the back of the auditorium. Clad in black and veiled she creates a charged dramatic field that spans the entire house, with one pole being the stage and the other the back of the auditorium. She glares eloquently at the unseemly pranks of the French on stage with a dignified, aristocratic disapproval and slowly approaches them, her imposing demeanor dramatizing her grief and subdued rage. The fantastic video direction by Tiziano Mancini shows us her grand entrance as perceived from the stage by the leering French; the shameful behavior of the French as perceived by the disapproving Elena, and Elena's slow, subtly menacing progress towards the stage as perceived by the audience. The combination of dynamic camera work, imaginative staging and Dessì's impressive charisma and acting skills create a thrilling theatrical effect. Add the sound engineers who created a sonic marvel that gives us a soundstage and ambiance that correspond exactly to where we see the singers/chorus in the house (with a realistic projection), and you get a gripping experience. There isn't a single moment that is less than completely riveting in this production for its entire duration.

I had my doubts when I saw the cast list (regarding the tenor and soprano), but overall they all give superlative performances. Dessì gives a commanding performance with her unique, rich timbre, a total artist, a modern Grand Tragedienne. The score has a lot of dynamic markings that call for soft singing ("mezza voce", "dolce", "dolcissimo", "p"; "pp", etc.) and she has a full command of a superb mezza voce (light singing). The forte side of the piano-forte spectrum is subdued - the Diva economizes her vocal resources, which is understandable, considering the challenges ahead. The role's more than two octave range is a walk in the park for her, as is the coloratura agility that reaches its first-half peak in the short cadenza of her act II duet with Arrigo "Presso alla tomba ch'apresi", with its long trill. Now for the nitpicking: the role's demands gradually increase in the second half. Her act IV "Arrigo! Ah parli a un core" is overall superb; she manages the first two of the cadenza's descending scales, but they are just a warm up for the third, which she glides over rather than really touch the notes (but she does the trill). Caballè (and many others) did the same thing and no one complained (but no none glides like Caballè). So how is her act V bolero? How do you think? It's no better than it was in 1996 in Rome, so it's far from perfect, but if you consult the score you see that her only difficulty is to sing long lines composed entirely of sixteenth notes figurations à-la-Rossini fast enough (no, she does not interpolate a final high E...Jeezus!). But it's a big show and her elegant style and artistry are of the highest caliber. With Pizzi's help it's also a scene of simple, aching beauty and with the sound engineers' help it's almost a miracle, the way they capture the back and forth between Elena on the stage and the chorus in the auditorium. When it ended the audience paused for three endless seconds that made my blood curdle ("are they really going to boo her?...") before a "brava" ushered in the applause.

Armiliato usually sounds like he constantly sings on all his capital and forces, probably because if he didn't we'd hear just a generic voice without a distinctive timbre. I always think he wouldn't last when I hear the pushing, but last he does and he knows exactly what he's doing. You need to forget all his previous performances, he is a huge surprise - it's the best I've ever heard him, I did not dream he has it in him. His tone is beautiful in a way I never heard before, his high Bb's and B's ring securely, he doesn't fudge a single note including rapid coloratura figurations, his phrasing is elegant and his soft singing seductive. Act V "La brezza aleggia intorno" (after the bolero) is cut, so no high D for the tenor (IIRC, some of the repetitions of the concluding act IV concertante are mercifully cut as well, and no ballet). On opening night he got into vocal problems in the second half and was announced indisposed before the second performance, from which most of the material for this blu-ray was taken. He bowed out from his last scheduled performance, so we are lucky to have this Vespri at all, because the replacement was not up to snuff. To be honest, I don't think Dessì and particularly Armiliato could have pulled it off in a bigger house, Vespri is truly scary for the tenor and soprano. It took a lot of courage for them to take on these roles.

Giacomo Prestia also offers his best performance so far in the Tutto Verdi series (he also sings in Ernani and in I Masnadieri). Nucci offers great finesse, style and power - he is a reference in many Verdi roles. I don't think there is a better Monforte on record, other than his earlier assumptions of the role. I heard him in this role at the MET when he last sang at the house in 2004. I pulled out a souvenir from that run and realized in retrospect that this may have been the greatest operatic performance I had the good fortune to attend.

The chorus is more than first rate. The musical direction of Massimo Zanetti (who also conducts Rigoletto in these series) overcomes the difficulties of singers and chorus scattered throughout the house with superb detail, precision and attentive accompaniment. The entire cast (particularly Dessì) seems giddy at the curtain calls - they overcame a supreme challenge and the audience is vocal in its gratitude (there is even a final cry for an encore!). The recording engineers deserve a standing ovation: Paolo Berti, Michele Ruggiero, Alessandro Marsico.

This is a Vespri for the ages and if you are still not convinced about the place this work deserves in the canon you are totally doomed and there is no point even talking about it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

[Add comment]
Post a comment
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Amazon will display this name with all your submissions, including reviews and discussion posts. (Learn more)
This badge will be assigned to you and will appear along with your name.
There was an error. Please try again.
Please see the full guidelines ">here.

Official Comment

As a representative of this product you can post one Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
The following name and badge will be shown with this comment:
 (edit name)
After clicking on the Post button you will be asked to create your public name, which will be shown with all your contributions.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.  Learn more
Otherwise, you can still post a regular comment on this review.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
System timed out

We were unable to verify whether you represent the product. Please try again later, or retry now. Otherwise you can post a regular comment.

Since you previously posted an Official Comment, this comment will appear in the comment section below. You also have the option to edit your Official Comment.   Learn more
The maximum number of Official Comments have been posted. This comment will appear in the comment section below.   Learn more
Prompts for sign-in


Tracked by 2 customers

Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-9 of 9 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 13 May 2013 04:14:45 BDT
Excellent review, Noam. Like you, I had a heart-stop after the end of the bolero, which was the only disappointing part of the evening (but it does sound fiendishly difficult). But overall it's the best Vespri I've seen on DVD.

In reply to an earlier post on 18 May 2013 11:37:26 BDT
Andy Torsten says:
i don't think that D.Dessi is a match to Cheryl Studer at her prime, when she did all this with ease and perfection. She had a dramatic line and...was virtuous the same time, could make all the thrills. It's a pity that this work is so terrrible underrated and underrecorded. Can't believe that i only know one studio recording with Arroyo and Domingo and i never liked this especially. The Version with Studer is live from the Scala and the sound is ok, not perfect.

In reply to an earlier post on 26 May 2013 00:08:49 BDT
I love Caballé´s Vespri taped live at the MET.

In reply to an earlier post on 26 May 2013 17:58:11 BDT
Andy Torsten says:
ok, Caballe had also her prime time, but on the other hand she had always a very "free" style of notes and coloraturas. When i think on her recorded Lucia and I puritani...did the composers write those notes or was it because the singer lost her top notes relatively early in her career?

In reply to an earlier post on 26 May 2013 19:17:35 BDT
Last edited by the author on 26 May 2013 19:20:29 BDT
Well, actually, in her Lucia she sings all the notes and only the notes written by Donizetti (it is interesting if only for that). None of the traditional added ornaments. Lopez Cobos defends this option in the original booklet. You may, of course, argue that Donizetti expected additions by the singers and you may have a point in liking it with ornamenti an added notes. Also you may find Caballé's voice too dramatic and big for Lucia. But it seems unfair to criticize her for wanting to record the opera 'as written'. It's not my Lucia of choice, but it is an interesting contribution to the history of recorded Lucias in my opinion. Same thing with Puritani. Muti wanted it 'come scritto' and apparently suited Caballé. Again, may not be I Puritani to end all Puritani, but interesting nevertheless.

In reply to an earlier post on 26 May 2013 20:53:48 BDT
Andy Torsten says:
well, tyfi i didn't know much of those things, but as i say the top notes haven't been nice in many records of Caballe, i like her most in some of her Verismo and Verdi-Parts, where she can let her hair down, how some people say...which is your favorite Lucia, in my opinion there is no ideal recorded till now, except you call Callas as ideal of a young girlish Lucia-

In reply to an earlier post on 26 May 2013 21:42:18 BDT
I think there's not ideal of almost anything, let alone Lucias. I love the very young Scotto in a live recording with Pavarotti. And of course Callas, also live in Berlin, Karajan conducting.

In reply to an earlier post on 26 May 2013 23:16:29 BDT
Andy Torsten says:
ok, i agree, but still no studio recording, i like all of the recordings of Ch.Studer, even Lucia before her voice was destroyed, but she hasn't been a real Lucia, maybe Lucia Aliberti could have been the best Lucia on record, if any record label would taken her on contract, but they didn't... what a we have the always not girlish (she was always a goddess) Callas and the live "virgin" Scotto, we have the same taste in that case.

In reply to an earlier post on 27 May 2013 16:15:22 BDT
Sorry to disagree, Dessì is unbearable. She cheats and sings on her own side, regardless where the orchestra is going. Sometimes I wandered if she and the orchestra were playing the same opera. Just kidding, of course; the orchestra simply has a very bad time trying to follow her capricious, ad-hoc singing. Very shameful to listen to, really. The tenor is his husband, she never sings without him...and one understands why: he simply has no voice and no sense of singing. Any other version of this opera is far better.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›

Review Details