70 of 72 people found the following review helpful
Under-rated Disney classic - one for the collector.,
By A Customer
This review is from: Treasure Island [DVD]  (DVD)
Disney was just beginning to get into the swing of live-action films with Treasure Island in 1950. He was also starting to use a mix of British and American actors.
He had already hired Bobby Driscoll for Song in the South in 1946, and he now gave the 13-year-old the role of Jim Hawkins (Driscoll also supplied the voice of Peter Pan in 1955). Robert Newton is highly memorable as a totally over-the-top Long John Silver.
The film is notable for several things - an over-reliance on studio sets in typical 40s/50s style, and some bizarre characters around, not least the famous Ben Gunn. Watch out for Patrick Troughton (the second Dr Who) as one of the pirates.
It's quite strong for little children, and it is or more interest to the Disney collector, who will be disappointed that it is in normal 4:3 ratio, although the print is sharp and clean. There are some extra minutes of footage at the beginning, as this is the original uncut theatrical version.
The final few minutes of the film are wonderfully orchestrated, with stirring music, and a tug on the heart-strings as Jim Hawkins comes to terms with the fact that his hero Long John is doing the dirty on them yet again!
There is some quality acting going in; the film has a highly theatrical flavour, big on costume on sets, and highly colourful all round.
Tracked by 1 customer
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 10 Mar 2008 22:09:21 GMT
Paul T says:
Why should we be disappointed that this DVD is presented in 4:3? Treasure Island was originally filmed in 1.37:1 which is as near as dammit 4:3.
Posted on 2 Feb 2012 22:05:30 GMT
The first CinemaScope film was "The Robe" released in 1953. The 70mm process (originally called Todd-AO after its inventor Mike Todd and the American Optical company) saw its first outing with "Oklahoma!" in 1955. So in 1950, before either of these widescreen processes came into use, the 4:3 aspect ratio was standard fare.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›