13 of 15 people found the following review helpful
Nearest to perfect Beethoven I've ever heard,
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Beethoven - Violin Concerto; Kreutzer Sonata (Isabelle Faust/Alexander Melnikov) (Audio CD)
The Beethoven violin concerto poses curious problems for listener and player. The virtuoso wants to shine, and the music wants to flow with joy and life, though there can be a tendency for conductors and soloists to want to bring broader grandeur. But the music requires a great deal of nuanced reflective playing between ensemble and soloist at a good moving pace to give it the transparently uplifting quality Beethoven clearly intended, or else it becomes ponderously grandiose and downheartening to the listener, even sombre in places. Consequently, that effectively keeps the soloist as an integral part of the ensemble, and demands swift delicate clarity, rather than a dominant honey-rich glittery virtuoso-style. The question of pace and tempo has been a dealbreaker for most of the versions since the great days of Heifetz, Kogan, Milstein for example. However, Isabelle Faust is clearly extremely historically well-informed with exquisite musical taste and plays with terrific purity, happiness, and character. The solo and orchestra are a complete whole, no virtuoso prima-donna-isms here. There is a lightness of heart from beginning to end, and seriousness of intent when needed. If only other performances could match the spells of quietness and space, the lovely delicatamente in the third movement, and the perfection of phrasing dynamics and forward flow, that characterises her playing and rapport.
I am utterly convinced by this performance, and the recording quality. I have put aside Zehetmair/Brüggen and Milstein/Steinberg, and now understand the reasons for similarities and contrasts in Heifetz/Munch and Kogan/Silvestri's different readings (pace phrasing and space) so much better after hearing Faust's masterclass here. This recording surely is a lesson in Beethoven we should all take to heart.
The Kreutzer Sonata, btw, is simply the best I have heard on disc. Perfect partnership and excellently judged musicianship in every way.
This is a must-have classical library disc.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-1 of 1 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 8 Oct 2011 17:56:54 BDT
Mr. Mark A. Meldon says:
A very nice review of an excellent CD; thank you.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›
(3 customer reviews)
Location: Stoke on Trent, UK
Top Reviewer Ranking: 6,593