12 of 13 people found the following review helpful
Wit and scholarship,
This review is from: Hot Flushes, Cold Science: A History of the Modern Menopause (Paperback)L.S.Sinclair's ventilations are worthy of opposition. She agrees, it seems, with Dr Foxcroft's main line of argument, yet ends by referring to menopausal women as "victims of" ovarian failure, which is surely the central point that the "Hot Flushes, Cold Science" takes issue against: it's not a failure, but a point in a natural cycle. Nor are they "drugged with" anything, an image which suggests carriage-horses, fog and Evil Doctors with stovepipe hats doing that syringe-quirting thing they always do in movies.
It is true that some women have "unpleasant symptoms"? What would L.S.Sinclair do with them that would keep her clear of the once-useful, now less so, catch-all argument of "paternalism"? Tell `em to perk up, read the scriptures and perhaps do a little light tatting?
Meh. Louise Foxcroft has produced a delightful and unusual blend of scholarship and empathy, of careful reasoning and playful wit, which reminds me of the late Roy Porter, looking at the way in which the (until recently, male-dominated and institutionally paternalist) medical profession regard women as inherently defective, and the normal course of female life as a voyage through frailties and sicknesses to which we more perfect and magnificently robust men, the highest creations of God and Nature alike, were quite immune.
Show a doctor a woman, and he will come up with a disease. (Followed, probably, by a cure and, of course, a bill.) Women doctors aren't free of guilt in the business of menopause either, though. Far too many women face a stony lack of sympathy from their female GPs and now that medicine is becoming a primarily female profession, certainly in Britain, it will be interesting to see how things proceed.
This book's not before its time. Only a couple of weeks ago a (female) friend had to listen to a retired lawyer well stricken in years, with the allure of a gibbon, explaining to her that women over fifty (i.e. menopausal/post-menopausal) were useless for anything; were inherently ugly; were repugnant to any healthy vigorous male (thinking, perhaps, of himself?) and should do the world a favour and, like Mr Toots in "Dombey & Son," should "...glide into the silent tomb with ease and smoothness."
To give a book one star because one is personally affronted (that silliest of emotions) by its conclusion seems to me both unfair and a category mistake. Nobody sets out to write a book of this sort with the intention of confirming the prejudices of any reader, let alone one particular individual, and to think otherwise argues a robust egocentricity and a failure to respond to other points of view which is surely a necessary (if not a sufficient) cause of the very "paternalism" of which the reviewer complains. My instinct would be to give Dr Foxcroft four stars because one never, ever gives full marks, but purely out of a desire to redress the balance, I shall give it five.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-1 of 1 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 15 Apr 2009 11:31:03 BDT
L. S. Sinclair says:
Ovarian failure unfortunately is detrimental to female health. I take exception to the idea that hypo gonadism is a natural event which shouldn't be treated with appropriate therapy. One wouldn't ignore other natural events which could have long term impacts on the health. Urinary incontinence, vaginal atrophy, rising cholesterol levels, oesteoporosis are caused by the menopause.However this is considered culturally acceptable and thus attracts little sympathy and plenty of ridicule.
I wouldn't suggest tatting - my own choice is Poker and carefully tailored bio identical hormone therapy.
I think that to suggest that menopausal women should be treated with anti depressants is a grave insult and underestimates the long term effects of reduced hormone levels.
Male sufferers of hypo gonadism get appropriate therapy whereas women are offered anti depressants.
Get real Hedgemon - two female relatives ended their lives wheelchair bound due to the effects of the climacteric. No thank you.
Foxcroft wrote a thought provoking book with a sorry conclusion. Anti depressants do not cure many of the unpleasant lifelong symptoms caused by menopause.
I stick to my guns. Women suffering from untreated hypo gonadism are victims of an engineering flaw and society's expectations of diminished quality of life after 50
Louise S Sinclair
‹ Previous 1 Next ›