3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
A tale with clipped wings,
This review is from: The Crane Wife (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine Programme (What's this?)
Let me preface this review by saying that Patrick Ness is a truly beautiful writer. He lovingly crafts a quite brilliant range of characters - four-year-old JP was the star of the book for me, speaking in the half-nonsense questioning language of bright young children. Unfortunately it also failed to satisfy me, for reasons I will try to explain.
Superficially the novel follows the story of the Japanese myth of the Crane Wife, transported to modern day London, but the mix of myth and introspection never quite gelled for me. There's a supernatural subplot which felt always too thinly sketched and almost tangential to the book - I wanted more time with the very engaging real-life people who Ness brought to life so well. I found myself reading very quickly through whole passages of the book, left with the sense that while it felt like it was saying something profound it was, in fact, what Daniel Dennett aptly calls a 'deepity'. In short, the experience was like reading a well-written equivalent of Paulo Coelho - on the first glance it says something deep about love and forgiveness, but when you look too hard it all feels paper-thin.
George is a shy, lonely man who -in possibly the most mundane and ridiculous circumstances- rescues a wounded crane which has landed in his garden. The next day, a mysterious woman, Kumiko (whose mystery is described ad nauseam to the reader) walks into his print shop with a suitcase full of paper-cut artwork. George and Kumiko fall in love, in a relationship meant to restore George's confidence, although it all happens too fast to be believable. Kumiko is too thinly-sketched to ever feel real and while that is meant to be the point, the myth on which the story hangs, it never feels like enough.
Nonetheless, this book left me interested enough in Ness's writing to want to read his young adult works - when he is not trying so hard to be so serious he really comes into his element and I would highly recommend The Chaos Walking trilogy.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-1 of 1 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 10 Jun 2013 10:35:38 BDT
I have just reviewed this book and then turned to other reviews because I couldn't understand why some people loved this book. I was looking to see if anyone could explain that, and also if others felt like me but expressed it better.
Your review helps me because so much of what you said echoes my thoughts
‹ Previous 1 Next ›