24 of 26 people found the following review helpful
OK addendum to The King is Dead,
Amazon Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Long Live The King (Audio CD)This EP is a collection of the best songs recorded for "The King is Dead" sessions not to make the cut for the main album. No surprise then that the mood is similar to that of the album : southern folk rock as opposed to the grandiose rock opera style of previous album The Hazards of Love.
The EP opens with the lovely E.Watson notable for stunning backing vocals from fellow Portlander Laura Veirs whose partner, Tucker Martine has produced the last few Decemberists albums. Veirs spot-on harmonies lift this song from a fairly bog standard acoustic strummer to something of great beauty that could easily have slotted into the original album. Similarly, Foregone's southern rock feel with Chris Funk's pedal steel well to the fore was unlucky to have remained on the cutting room floor when songs like "All Arise!" made it onto the album.
Burying Davy is a slower, darker number. An ominous lament with a feel not dissimilar to that of "Shankhill Butchers" from "The Crane Wife". "I4U & U4ME" makes no bones of the fact that it is a home demo. Better quality than the average home demo certainly but the difference in sound quality is apparent. The song is pleasant enough but has a throwaway quality that suggests that it was the right decision not to pursue this one further during the album sessions. "Row Jimmy" is not a great song - slow southern rock in style but without the songwriting direction and clarity we normally associate with Colin Meloy. Some nice slide guitar from Chris Funk and backing vocals from Jenny Conlee fail to redeem this one which, at 6 minutes outstays its welcome by at least 4 !
Sadly, the closing track "Sonnet" doesn't improve things much - a directionless song augmented by some boozy horns clearly designed to give it a kind of New Orleans funeral march feel but at least at under 3 minutes we don't have to endure too much of this one.
The King is Dead was a fantastic album : a real contender for album of the year but sadly, this EP doesn't do much to add to the legacy of the recording sessions that created it. For Decemberists fans and completists it is certainly worth buying for the first three tracks alone with E.Watson and Foregone being the undoubted highlights. Don't expect a mini version of The King is Dead though as this is a pale imitation whose release not too long before Christmas (and overpriced for an EP of cast-offs in my opinion) smacks of commercialism.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 5 Nov 2011 16:50:13 GMT
Last edited by the author on 5 Nov 2011 16:50:40 GMT
Red on Black says:
I had intended to pen a few thoughts on "Long live the king" but your splendid review has said it all and begs the question why the band didnt just add Forgone and E Watson to the main album. For info Meloy didn't write "Row Jimmy" its actually an old Grateful Dead song. Anyway well done.
In reply to an earlier post on 5 Nov 2011 23:16:42 GMT
Chris G says:
Thanks so much - yes, I read another review which pointed out that Row Jimmy was a Grateful Dead cover (and stated that the world didn't need any more Grateful Dead covers with which I totally concur, in this case anyway !) I completely agree that those two tracks could have been added to the original album without any drop in quality. The rest here is filler and, sadly because I love The Decemberists, smacks of cashing in. Thanks again RoB.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›