23 of 28 people found the following review helpful
And when X-mas comes,........,
By A Customer
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes: Novels v. 3 (Hardcover)
Everyone - that is Holmesian, Sherlockian and Fan - has their own way of enjoying SH. Whether it be on holiday, in the bath, on the tube/journey to work or just plain pleasure, the same sensation exists with every new 'inducted' volume; and that excitement exists here too.
I wondered whether the first two volumes would be equalled by its third. And shoot me down for doubting it! This third volume brings together the SH novels of SACD. It is filled to the brim with extra detail and commentary that will keep you thinking and rehinking and reposing the twists and turns of each. My personal favourite is "The Valley of Fear" - it has been assembled with a wealth that excites the eyes, tingles the senses with glee and a depth expected by the Talmud.....
Buy it if you're a Holmesian. Buy it if you're a Sherlockian. Buy it to know more, feel more and escape into the late 19th Century Victorian heaven of Sherlock Holmes.