211 of 222 people found the following review helpful
Still A Dark Horse,
This review is from: George Harrison: Living in the Material World [DVD] (DVD)A documentary on a music celebrity can be measured by content (what footage did they access and who was willing to contribute?) and insight (what new light did it shed on the subject?). On the first point Martin Scorsese knocks the ball out of the park. Though I didn't feel I knew George any better than before by the end, I was treated to nearly four hours of dazzling and emotionally moving entertainment.
I watched both parts of the film at UK preview and at no point did my attention or enthusiasm flag. In fact I would have happily sat through any outtakes! This beautifully crafted film is packed with concert footage, home movies, press conferences, interviews, photos and documents that I've never seen before, even though I've been researching the Beatles quite heavily for several years for Beatles Songwriting Academy. There are interviews with (or at least footage of) everyone you would hope to see. Beatles, wives, brothers, son, Pythons and peers. Everyone from Eric Clapton to Eric Idle.
The documentary is constructed entirely from interviews and clips without explanation or analysis. The closest we get to a voiceover is Dhani Harrison reading excerpts from his father's diary and letters to his mum. Though the film is visually stunning it's strange watching the practically square picture forced upon us by the source material. Equally quirky is the sound editing. Scorsese doesn't know the meaning of 'fade'. All the music cuts brutally, sometimes after a few seconds. Sometimes this is cool. Mostly it's odd. The film is largely chronological and there are some great juxtapositions of sound and visuals like All Things Must Pass accompanies footage of the WW2 bombers that plagued the Liverpool of Harrison's birth. The first part covers George's life up to the White Album.
It's hard to pick out favourite parts. But Harrison's obvious delight watching archive footage of the Beatles miming This Boy, laughing and singing along, is one. The Beatles performing If I Needed Someone, Harrison playing What Is Love? with Billy Preston, and seeing the Travelling Wilburys in the studio would be others.
There are moments of laugh out loud humour, especially TV footage of crusty professors discuss the significance of Pop music while Beatles and Mick Jagger seeth like captive wild animal in the background and Tom Petty recounting Harrison arriving at his house with a trunk full of ukeleles. But Harrison's story of how Lennon and McCartney inspired him to start composing is the best - "If John and Paul can write [songs] everybody must be able to". The Maharishi (a spiritual Joe Pasquali) and Phil Spector (a croaking, unblinking vision of craziness with a permanent twitching thumb) also provide some unintentional humour.
Scorsese deserves praise for not going down the revisionist myth making route trodden by the Anthology series, especially as Olivia Harrison was one of his producers. Olivia is honest, though vague, about George's infidelity as is Klaus Voorman is about his drug problems. But the lack of a narrator almost makes George a mirror in which we see his world. We know he was loved, deeply, by friends - racing drivers, comedians and film makers, musicians, but we don't whether he was truly loveable. Terry Gilliam describes George as a mix of "grace, humour and a weird kind of angry bitterness" but what made him that way? Did he ever find a release from that bitterness? Was he a good father? Nearing death Harrison asked Olivia if he had been a good husband. She never tells us what her answer was."What's the secret of a long marriage?" She asks herself. "Don't get divorced".
It may sound strange but the highest point for me was simply hearing the music. Listening to Here Comes The Sun and While My Guitar Gently Weeps I was almost moved to tears at the transcendent beauty of those recordings.
Perhaps the fact that the film cause me to fall in love with the music all over again is it's greatest recommendation.
Tracked by 3 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 18 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 6 Oct 2011 16:46:04 BDT
Robert N says:
Excellent review. Thanks.
Posted on 7 Oct 2011 03:31:55 BDT
Thank you for sharing these wonderful thoughts and observations. Let it roll for always.
Posted on 9 Oct 2011 10:41:45 BDT
Don Arden says:
One of the best reviews I've read on Amazon.I'm looking forward to watching it now.
Posted on 9 Oct 2011 13:53:10 BDT
Last edited by the author on 9 Oct 2011 13:55:53 BDT
Markus Ronald says:
I have been buying at Amazon for years now and very rarely have i had the need to comment on reviews. As i live oitside the u.k, reviews are important to me. For example i love SPooks and Waking the dead , but would never have bought The Street if it were not for the outstanding reviews.
This particular dvd has been on my wish list for some time now and at long last i can order it, however i just wanted to thankyou for a
really outstanding review. It was a pleasure reading it and i am quite sure the dvd will live up to its expectations. I grew up with the fab four and even saw them in Finsbury park.
So again many many thanks for a superb review.
In reply to an earlier post on 9 Oct 2011 14:36:37 BDT
Matt Blick says:
Wow thanks Ronnie (and everyone else) for your kind comments!
Posted on 11 Oct 2011 13:42:29 BDT
Good objective review, broadly covering all aspects that someone interested in this would like to hear about.
In reply to an earlier post on 11 Oct 2011 23:56:43 BDT
L. J. Hershbien says:
I agree as well,Matt George Harrison - Living in the Material World [DVD] Your review was a work in itself.
Posted on 12 Oct 2011 20:30:29 BDT
[Deleted by the author on 12 Oct 2011 20:31:01 BDT]
Posted on 14 Oct 2011 14:06:35 BDT
Last edited by the author on 14 Oct 2011 14:25:20 BDT
Mr Rugged says:
Given that you found a number of points to criticise why the 5 stars? Surely 4 would have better reflected your review.
In reply to an earlier post on 14 Oct 2011 15:00:37 BDT
Matt Blick says:
Because most of the criticisms are about what I would LIKE to see rather than what the product IS. It's seems churlish to say they missed too much stuff out when the film is as long as it is. For what it is, it's really a brilliant film