5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
Disappointing, even for a Gabriel fanatic like me!,
This review is from: Scratch My Back (Audio CD)
Listened to this several times now and it's really disappointing. I'm struggling to listen to the whole thing from start to finish without wishing to press the off button! The only tracks that really grab me are "Listening Wind" where we see Peter's phrasing at its best a la "Games Without Frontiers" and the beginning of "The Boy In The Bubble" where the words take on a whole new meaning. "Street Spirit" though is utterly dreadful (I've never been keen on the original either so what chance did PG have!) and "Mirrorball" fails to move me and is a pale shadow of the original. "Heroes" - poor, very monotonous, "Philadelphia" - listen to Neil Young's version instead, much better. A few of the others have started to grow on me - "Flume" especially gets better with each listen (the original is excellent but not as good as "Re: Stacks" by Bon Iver - what a wonderful song - anyone who has not heard this should give it a listen) as does "My Body Is A Cage" and "The Book Of Love" - so hope springs eternal!
This is by far the most dissappointing Gabriel release of his entire career in my opinion and I'm a big big Gabriel fan - I'm now pissed off with him for two reasons - his stubborness to reform the classic line-up and this, what is in the main "very depressing durge!"
The worse thing is I've paid the £150 to see him live at the O2, so have to sit through 2 hrs of this and the soundcheck too!