169 of 177 people found the following review helpful
This review is from: The Telegraph (Kindle Edition)
I'm a bit confused by all the negativity here. For £10 per month, you get a copy of a decent paper delivered every morning, including Saturdays & Sundays, which was a nice suprise. So thats a lot cheaper and more portable than the paper version, and even better when you're by the pool on holiday.
From a quick scan there are over 100 articles on the daily edition and 200+ on the weekend, so it feels pretty comprehensive, and with a paper like the Telegraph you know the content is going to be well written and of a somewhat right of centre political outlook.
So for me, this is great. Good content everyday for a reasonable price and minimal hassle.
Negatives - doesnt have pictures, but so far I'm not really missing them. I want the actual news! doesnt have tables, thats really annoying for things like the football, but I can get that thorugh other means. Fix the pictures/tables in a way that keeps a nice user experience, and it'd be a 5*
Tracked by 4 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-9 of 9 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 22 Sep 2010 00:18:45 BDT
Last edited by the author on 22 Sep 2010 00:19:25 BDT
S. Bryce says:
But aren't you annoyed by the clear lack of care which has gone into this version? While the price is now better (and would probably deserve an extra star on my review), I find it really annoying when an article has text from the wrong place stuck in the middle of the body of the article. I also find it annoying that there is little use of bold or headings to help clarify lists, etc. in an article.
Also, the newspaper may be laid out so that a number of related stories appear next to each other on the page - not so in the Kindle version. Often a related story appears several stories after the main story, which I find annoying.
My original 2 star rating is probably more like 3 stars now that the price has been reduced to £10 per month.
To get a 4 star rating, I just want somebody to actually read through the Kindle edition, correcting formatting etc., ensuring that no text is appearing in the wrong place and making sure that the related stories run on from one to the next. It should not be acceptable to the publishers to put out something which is so badly presented.
To get a 5 star rating, I want everything above along with pictures and tables.
In reply to an earlier post on 26 Sep 2010 08:43:45 BDT
Yeah, the order of the articles is pretty variable. It seemed to be getting better but then went to pot again, and more random text seems to be appearing mid story.
Also, I went on holiday to Portugal last week. The paper would download over wifi but not 3g. This is definitley not what I expected given the 3g coverage map of most of Europe. Is probably a Kindle thing rather than Telegraph, but still spoils the experience.
Adding the above 2 annoyances together would probably drop the review down to a 3* now, but its a good & generally happy 3*
In reply to an earlier post on 4 Oct 2010 12:47:39 BDT
Mrs. K. Davies says:
To be honest i think i would only use this on holiday(save the trek around to find a newstand selling English papers)so could i just take out a sub for one month and then cancel or would that be difficult/cheating, do you think?
In reply to an earlier post on 4 Oct 2010 19:27:54 BDT
Subscribing & cancelling is dead easy. You even get the first 14 days free.
Cheating - who cares? You get your paper & The Telegraph / Amazon gets some extra cash & you might just subscribe longer. Only thing to make sure of is WiFi coverage as 3g didnt work for me abroad
Posted on 6 Feb 2011 13:14:47 GMT
Mrs. J. A. Smith says:
Our grown up children wanted to buy a kindle for their father (my husbamd) who suffers fom Parkinsons, turning the pages of the Telegraph causes him some problems. However on reading the many comments on lack of continuity, pictures & tables we are holding back. How could we enjoy the property page with its beautiful houses missing, the gardening section with its plants & offers, the list of omissions is endless.
With a 2nd home in Spain & the weekend Telegraph costing 5 euros 20 centimos out there it would have been a Godsend but now readers' comments state that the 3G version doesn't work.
In reply to an earlier post on 6 Feb 2011 20:02:36 GMT
The 3g bit seems to depend on where you are. Didnt work in the Algarve for me, but worked fine out in the sticks in France.
Agree the rest harms the experience a lot, but for the cash it'll do for me - but then I dont buy the paper for the pictures in the first place! Have you looked at the telegraph / times websites / ipad versions? Am told they are good & have pictures.
Other alternative - check on Amazon.com - does thier version of the kindle ship pictures to the papers? Seem to recall it did at some point
Posted on 27 Feb 2011 11:33:01 GMT
Bill John says:
Can Newspapers be delivered to a Kindle whilst on a Cruise?
Specifically, P&O Aurora from Southampton to Carribean and return. I would not want to use the onboard wifi - too expensive!!
In reply to an earlier post on 19 May 2011 09:09:53 BDT
Mr. P. J. Jones says:
Interesting - my wife uses a Kindle and gets the Daily Mail overseas on 3G so it may be a Telegraph issue. I was going to get a Kindle for the Telegraph (can't take my laptop to the pool!) but will wait.
All other issues - in the various posts - typos, articles not together, lack of tables, text format etc. are common to the Daily Mail as well.
In reply to an earlier post on 17 Dec 2011 14:48:08 GMT
K LAMB says:
Bill John asks the very same question I have - as we are going away on a world cruise early next year a newspaper lionk to Kindle would be great.....but thge cost of wi fi on board is astronomical. Any feedback anywhere please?!
‹ Previous 1 Next ›