Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop All Amazon Fashion Summer Savings Up to 25% Off Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Oasis Listen in Prime Shop now Learn more

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5 stars39
4.4 out of 5 stars
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

I'm not an art historian or critic and therefore can't comment on every aspect of the book's content as some reviewers in the media have done. It hasn't detracted from my enjoyment of the book that Sue Roe has based it on secondary sources only; in fact the skill with which she has done this actually increases my admiration of her abilities. The fact that her thesis may be a bit wobbly hasn't impacted on my enjoyment either (perhaps critics are overly pedantic at times). The book delivers on several fronts: impressive knowledge of existing sources; fluently written; and wonderfully evocative of the period. For instance, this description of Montmartre: "a hill top village with squat crumbling houses, vineyards and squares bordered with chestnut trees, the outlooks plunging down into the mists of Paris, where life was lived slowly and quietly, like going back in time". She is excellent at describing the artists and their lives. The book leaves a lingering sense of the social milieu and the importance of collaboration - as well as rivalry - in the creation of art. Highly recommended.
0Comment|39 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
TOP 500 REVIEWERon 4 September 2014
Montmartre was an astonishing place between 1900 and 1910, “the great artistic cauldron ... where artists and bohemians of all ages and nationalities converged”, and Susan Rowe describes it vividly, with all its cafés, bars and studios, where so many of the young French artists of the time congregated and all knew each other: Picasso and Matisse (conscious rivals), Derain, Vlaminck, Modigliani, Utrillo, Van Dongen, Braque, Marie Laurencin, Henri Rousseau, Juan Gris, all of whom we follow in greater or lesser detail in this book, both in their daily lives, their affaires and their art. Several of them belonged to what Roe calls “la bande Picasso” at the Bateau-Lavoir, the large ramshackle building in which several artists had their studios at that time. That decade saw one form of art succeeding another with great rapidity: Pointillism, Fauvism, the influence of African art and the different varieties of Cubism. Enormously important was the shrewd art dealer Ambroise Vollard who bought and promoted these avant-garde artists; so was the American art collector Leo Stein, whose sister Gertrude figured so much in Picasso’s life and to whose literary innovations Sue Rowe devotes a few pages. Other art dealers (Kahnweiler, Uhde) and patrons (Shchukine) also figure prominently.

We see particularly Picasso and Matisse starting the period very poor and ending it famous and prosperous. Striking also is the contrast between the robust Picasso and the sensitive and easily depressed Matisse. The other character of comes very much alive in the book is Picasso’s partner Fernande Ollivier.

There is also a lot about the early cinema, the ballet, fashion designers - about everything that contributed - mostly centrally, but sometimes more marginally - to the atmosphere of Montmartre.

In 1911 there was a lot of rebuilding and demolition up on Montmartre, the latter including several of its windmills. The centre of artistic life moved from Montmartre to Montparnasse, on the Left Bank (south of the river). What was left of the former became a tourist attraction, and the serious painters were replaced by the amateurs who set up their easels on the Place du Tertre. So this is where Sue Roe’s book ends.

A small niggle: in the Kindle edition, quotations which are footnoted at the end of the book, instead of having superscipt numbers referring to the sources at the end of the book, are either partially or wholly underlined, a very unusual and quite irritating device. But that apart, I found the book very interesting and hugely informative.
0Comment|7 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
This art/cultural history by Sue Roe covers about ten years (1900-1910) in the life of one of Paris' iconic neighborhoods, with a focus on a handful of young artists (Picasso, Braque, Vlaminck, Derain, Modigliani) and several art dealers and patrons (mostly notably the Steins in this latter category). Overall, this an extremely well researched and imagined (conversations are presented that may or may not have ever taken place) account of how modernist art gradually evolved at the beginning of the Century. The book--as strong and entertaining as it is--has a definite focus on the Montmartre neighborhood and does not spend a lot of time trailing painters in other regions of France. In that regard, it does not attempt to be a comprehensive record of modernist art.

What I particularly liked about the book was its credible reminder that the titans of modern art (or at least post-impressionist art) did not work in vacuums. Most of them were part of an artistic set in the Montmartre neighborhood, and elsewhere, who freely traded ideas, criticism, materials, models/girlfriends and paintings. They drank together, fought and competed for patrons. It was a fascinating period of time and Sue Roe makes the reader a witness to the dynamics of the moment with a clear chronology and credible insights into these wonderfully complicated and hugely talented characters and their behaviors and works.

Readers should keep in mind that this is a kind of snapshot of the period and there is not real attempt to pursue individual histories beyond the time.
Comment
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 10 October 2015
It appears to me there is a glaring error in this book and if there is one what is there to stop there being others? It is well documented that Paul Signac was befriended by Georges Seurat yet on page 55 Roe refers to one of Signac's friends as Paul Seurat. I have looked up Paul Seurat on the internet and can find no such person linked with Paul Signac and Lucien Pissarro so this leads me to believe that Roe meant Georges Seurat. If so, then that is a monumental error and happens again later in the book. This book has many good critical reviews clearly those writers have not read it all or they would have noticed this mustaje. I find it hard to trust in a book with such an error no matter how engaging the writer.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 21 August 2014
A few minutes hearing this as book of the week on Radio 4 and I'd downloaded a copy so that I could read along - more or less. Highly evocative of the era, an insight into Picasso that is brought to life and in my case supported by visits to all the places mentioned.
0Comment|3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
Many years ago, there was a CBS Radio series called "You Are There" that later became a television series hosted by Walter Cronkite. He returned in time to an especially significant event in history to provide an eyewitness account of, for example, John Cassavetes as Plato in The Death of Socrates, James Dean as Robert Ford (outlaw) in The Capture of Jesse James, Paul Newman as Marcus Brutus in The Assassination of Julius Caesar and as Nathan Hale in The Fate of Nathan Hale, Jeanette Nolan as Sarah Bernhardt in The Final Performance of Sarah Bernhardt, Kim Stanley as Cleopatra in The Death of Cleopatra, Rod Steiger as Richard Burbage in The First Command Performance of Romeo and Juliet, Beatrice Straight as Anne Boleyn in The Crisis of Anne Boleyn, and Joanne Woodward in The Oklahoma Land Rush.

I commend Roe on her consummate skills that enable her to transport her reader back in time to early- 20th century Paris much as Woody Allen for those who see his film, Midnight in Paris, to the years there after the First World War. Pablo Picasso was probably the gravitational center of the culture before that war but even his dominant personality could not subdue, only enhance, the charm and historical significance of Montmartre's cafes and cabarets, galleries and studios, shops and private homes during the first decade of the 20th century. She really made me feel as if I were there in the milieu. I could almost hear her voice assure, "all things are as they were then, except you are there! "

As Roe explains, "The cross-fertilization of painting, writing, and music and dance produced a panorama of activity characterized by the early works of Picasso, Braque, Matisse, Derain, Vlaminck and Modigliani, the appearance of the Ballet Russes and the salons of Gertrude Stein."The Larger framework for this book's structure also includes the World's Fair, major art exhibitions (of both paintings and sculpture), ballet and symphony performances, and relevant social, economic, and political developments in Europe as well as in the United States.

These are among the dozens of passages of greatest interest and value to me, also listed to suggest the scope of Roe's coverage:

o Montmartre village (Pages xiii-xvi)
o Henri Matisse (17-23,55-56, 107-113, and 169-171)
o André Dorain (18-19 and 105-113)
o Pablo Picasso (23-25, 36-39, 56-58, 78-81, 87-94, 157-162, and 270-274)
o Picture sellers in Montmartre village (28-35)
o Paul Cézanne (31-33 and 204-206)
o Maurice Vlaminck (43-48, 85-86, 111-112, and 246-248)
o Georges Braque (61-68, 81-82, 178-179, 237-238, and 243-246))
o Serge Diaghilev (69-70, 204-206, and 303-304)
o Bateau-Lavoir (75-79, 140-141, 154-155, and 179-180)
o Gertrude Stein (97-00 and 134-140)
o Amedeo Modigliani (142-148 and 208-210)
o Picasso and Matisse (154-155 and 175-177)
o Gauguin's influence on Picasso (160-161)
o Salon d'Automne (204-206 and 303-304
o Ballet Russes (258-262 and 286-289)

There is a Farmer's Market near the downtown area here in Dallas at which merchants offer slices of fresh fruit as samples of their wares. In that same spirit, I now offer three excepts from Rose's narrative that are representative of her skills:

o "The real revolution in the arts first took place not, as is commonly supposed, in the 1920s, to the accompaniment of the Charleston, black jazz, and mint juleps, but more quietly and intimately, in the shadow of the windmills -- artificial and real -- and in the cafés and cabarets of Montmartre during the first decade of the twentieth century. The unknown artists who gathered there and lived closely overlapping lives are

o "There had always been painters in Montmartre; its reputation as the centre of artistic life dated back to the reign of Louis VI, who was a great supporter if the arts. (Montmartre appears in records dating back to the twelfth century.) The Abbey of Montmartre founded under his rule and built on the site now occupied by St. Peter's Church, between the Place du Tertre and the Sacré Coeur, attracted generous donations, earning Paris the title of 'Ville de Lettres'. Montmartre's reputation had originally been founded not on prostitutes but on nuns, some of whom achieved sainthood." (Page 15)

o "'What I am searching for, [Modigliani] wrote in one of his sketchbooks, 'is neither the real nor the unreal, but the Subconscious, the mystery of what is Instinctive in the human race'. The new go0al for the modern artists was to find ways of expressing the interior life. In their own way, Picasso and Matisse, Derain and Vlaminck, Diaghilev and Poiret, Marie Laurencin and Gertrude Stein were all by now engaged in this quest." (211)

o "The struggles of a few dedicated, near-destitute artists working in the broken-down shacks and hovels of rural Montmartre seemed to have created the foundation for the wider arena of modern art. In retrospect, the bohemian world of the artists in Montmartre in the first decade of the century may be seen as a kind of living [begin italics] parade [end italics], a brief, dynamic, entertaining drama containing all the seeds of the main, twentieth- century show -- and all the fun of the fair." (312)

Sue Roe provides a superb Bibliography to which I presume to add David McCullough's The Greater Journey: Americans in Paris, Gabrieller Selz's Unstill Life: A Daughter's Memoir of Art and Love in the Age of Abstraction, Anne Sinclair's My Grandfather's Gallery: A Famliy Memoir of Art and War, and Paul Durand-Ruel: Memoir of the First Impressionist Art Dealer (1831-1922) co-authored by Flavie Durand-Ruel and Paul-Louis Durand-Ruel.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 20 September 2015
A good, racy read giving an excellent feel for the period. The quotations from the artists and other participants of the Montmartre 'scene' are cleverly woven into the narrative. When I next stay in Montmartre, I shall see it from a significantly different perspective.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 11 August 2014
A lively and readable account (though sometimes a little gushing), competently collaged from already available sources. Lack of sound Art historical knowledge and understanding are not a barrier to enjoying this book, but I'd be fascinated to know who 'commonly believes' that Modernism began in the 1920s with the Charleston etc - a preposterous assertion!
Sue Roe ably communicates her love of this period and offers hours of reading pleasure even if there are no scholarly or helpful insights.
44 comments|9 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 23 December 2015
A superb, fascinating, and insightful book dealing with the art scene in Paris during the first 15 years or so of the 20th Century.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 4 March 2016
I attend Art History classes & find this book very detailed for a novel. It is a break away from really serios studies.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)