88 of 90 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars none more black!
This edition, like the similar one of The Velvet Underground & Nico, is billed as a "45th Anniversary Super Deluxe Edition" and has an identical format of a (roughly) 10" x 12" hardback book with cardboard slots for the CDs at the back. As with the VU&N super deluxe edition, it contains stereo and mono versions of the original album, extras and out-takes and a live...
Published 17 months ago by freewheeling frankie
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Too much of the same
Let's get the obvious comments out of the way first. Unless you live on the Moon you already know the groundbreaking importance of the Velvets and how this album is their most extreme statement that invented the seventies. It's also safe to say that if you shelled out the extra cash for this you (like me) are already a fan and already own the original (along with all...
Published 16 months ago by jason johnson
Most Helpful First | Newest First
88 of 90 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars none more black!,
This review is from: White Light / White Heat - Super Deluxe (Audio CD)
This edition, like the similar one of The Velvet Underground & Nico, is billed as a "45th Anniversary Super Deluxe Edition" and has an identical format of a (roughly) 10" x 12" hardback book with cardboard slots for the CDs at the back. As with the VU&N super deluxe edition, it contains stereo and mono versions of the original album, extras and out-takes and a live recording.
But there the resemblance ends. Firstly, it contains only 3 CDs as opposed to 6 - the relatively small difference in price between the two indicates that you're mostly paying for the book, but while this is beautifully produced as with the VU&N, it's considerably slimmer - 56 pp as against 88 - and 5 of those pages are occupied by large print quotes lifted from elsewhere in the text (as opposed to only 1 with VU&N). While much of the content is similar - an essay, photos and gig posters - there's much less of it, and unlike the VU&N you don't get the lyrics. With regard to the photos, which are excellent as far as they go, this is not surprising - during the VU&N era they were part of Warhol's Factory milieu and far more regularly photographed. By the time they recorded WL/WH they'd cut their ties with Warhol and were on their own. The essay (by David Fricke) is not only much shorter than Richie Unterberger's in the VU&N but told me a lot less that I didn't already know, though it contains a lot of good quotes of the band members.
However, now we come to the musical contents. There are 5 considerations for the fan who already has a relatively recently mastered version of the stereo mix on CD:
1. The mastering
2. The mono mix
3. The studio extras
4. The live recording
5. The amount of previously unheard content
Is fine. But I can't hear much difference between the stereo mix and the most recent remaster I'm aware of (dating from late 1990s/early 2000s?). Whereas the VU&N Super Deluxe was notably changed and improved from the early 2000s Deluxe Edition. This of course isn't to say that there's anything wrong with it - it sounds great, as does the mono mix.
The mono mix:
I've waited decades to hear this. It's fair to say it doesn't reveal any spectacular surprises - the different runtimes, alternate guitar parts etc. etc. that are common between mono and stereo mixes of rock albums from c.1965-68 are completely absent and one is left with the faint suspicion that the mono mix was created by combining the channels of the stereo mix - does anyone know? It certainly sounds ... more concentrated, and perhaps a shade better. But nothing dramatic. It's interesting to hear the most obviously stereo tracks (The Gift and Lady Godiva's Operation) in mono, and they both work fine. Sister Ray sounds superb - it all does, frankly - but it just isn't very different from the stereo mix, give or take the lack of channel separation on The Gift.
The studio extras:
The two studio discs contain additional material as follows:
CD 1: I Heard Her Call My Name (alternate take) - much of the guitar sounds so similar to the issued take that I'm tempted to believe this is just an alternate mix, though such a different mix that it sounds much more different from either the mono or stereo album mixes than they do from each other. Guess I'm Falling In Love (instrumental version) - this was issued on Another View but has been remixed for this release and sounds far better; it's faster than the live version (see below) but wouldn't be quite as good even if it had vocals. Temptation Inside Your Heart and Stephanie Says are not the 1984 mixes that appeared on VU but appear to be original 1968 stereo mixes, which were first issued on the Gold compilation in the 2000s, which many fans would have ignored, assuming they had it all already; Peel Slowly And See contained the same 1984 mixes as VU. The two takes of Hey Mr Rain that previously appeared on Another View have also been newly remixed and sound pretty good. And finally there's a previously unissued Cale-era version of Beginning To See The Light with a great, stomping beat and a partly different lyric. This is the only additional studio track that is a completely unheard recording.
CD 2: the first 2 extras here are mono single mixes of White Light/White Heat and Here She Comes Now. Any differences from the LP mono mixes will only be apparent to those with extremely sharp hearing, especially WL/WH. These are followed by isolated vocal and instrumental versions of The Gift, which are very welcome but frankly you can create these at home from a stereo version very easily - I did some years ago.
The live recording:
At last, a complete legal release for the legendary 30 April 1967 performance at The Gymnasium in NYC. This was one of the Velvets' last gigs as part of Warhol's entourage and they didn't play live in New York again for over 3 years. A couple of tracks (Guess I'm Falling In Love and Booker T) leaked out in the 80s - the former on a bootleg and the latter initially on a John Cale album before both subsequently appeared on the Peel Slowly And See box set. Most of the rest came out as a more complete bootleg a few years ago. It's unclear who recorded it, or how - John Cale claims to have been given a copy a few decades back but not to know its source - but the sound quality is staggeringly good apart from a number of drops and surges of volume which to my ears should have been easy to correct as the sound quality isn't dramatically affected. If it's an audience recording, it was done with quality equipment, but the lack of audience noise and the often too-loud vocals (occasionally clipping, unfortunately) suggest a reel-to-reel fed from the mixer. Unlike the very rough-sounding Valleydale Ballroom recording that appeared in the VU&N super deluxe set, this tape has been looked after and was in good enough condition to be capable of further mastering improvement - it sounds considerably better than the already quite good quality bootleg. So it's hard to understand why those volume variations were left in.
The recording shows the Velvets in grungy rock'n'roll mode - it starts off with the scuzzy jam of Booker T, continues with the previously unheard I'm Not A Young Man Anymore - not their greatest song but chugs away merrily and features lots of great guitar and pumping bass. Guess I'm Falling In Love sounds better than ever and features some of the best rock'n'roll guitar playing ever recorded. Two songs from VU&N follow; I'm Waiting For The Man is about halfway between the studio version and the 1969 Live version; the vocals are bit too loud, as they are also in Run Run Run. Sister Ray suffers initially from some feedback on the vocals; it's cleaner sounding than the studio version, slower and a bit stiff rhythmically; the vocals are still mixed too high and the organ takes a while to make its presence felt but it's fascinating to hear such an early live version and like all the tracks here it's chock full of fantastic and well-recorded guitar playing. Finally, we get a version of The Gift. Booker T has long been confused with The Gift and the recent bootleg of this gig didn't clear up the confusion because it included neither. Once you've heard this, although they're fairly similar it's clearly apparent that Booker T is NOT The Gift because THIS quite plainly is. Although at this point it's still an instrumental, it's a fully formed version of the backing track used for The Gift on WL/WH. If this is the whole of the gig, this quite laid-back (if very grungy!) jam seems a strange way to end - one is left thinking there might be more, but presumably this is all John Cale had and it's great to hear something that wasn't on the bootleg. It's also worth noting that it's not at all clear if this is the correct running order - on the bootleg (which lacks the two instrumentals) the running order was otherwise the same but I'm Not A Young Man Anymore was preceded by tuning up which has been edited off here, so it could well have been the beginning of the set; who knows where Booker T belongs, in that case? Most of the songs are completely separate edits, dating perhaps from before the tape was given to John Cale.
The amount of previously unheard content:
While there are a lot of mix variants on the original album and studio extras, the whole 3 CD box only contains 2 recordings (Beginning To See The Light and the live version of The Gift) that are completely new and haven't even (to my knowledge) come out on bootlegs, though as noted above the live recording has never sounded so good despite the failure to correct the volume variations. All the other studio songs except Temptation Inside Your Heart, Stephanie Says and the 2 45 versions are previously unissued mixes. It's a shame that they didn't feel able to include any 1968 live recordings of the Cale line-up in this box - some of them are quite listenable and available recordings of the Cale-era 4-piece without Nico are pretty thin on the ground to say the least. I can certainly see myself playing the Gymnasium gig quite regularly, and you can't say that for the hard-to-listen-to Valleydale Ballroom gig included in the VU&N super deluxe edition.
This is a superbly produced item and the musical content is iconic and brilliant. But at nearly £50 for 3 CDs and a nice but not particularly content rich book it seems overpriced to me. While the mono version sounds great, it doesn't sound sufficiently different from the equally great-sounding stereo version to make its reissue 46 years on as massively desirable as I'd hoped it would be. If you love the original album you'll want it, but I'd say this is for real completists - especially those who haven't managed to acquire the Gymnasium bootleg, which is, in any case, available in the 2 CD version for a quarter of the price. In those circumstances I've docked this emphatically 5 star album a point for the price, the paucity of previously unheard content, the too-great similarity between the mono and stereo mixes and the failure to correct the volume variations on the live recording.
Finally ... the appearance of this edition (nearly a year after the 45th anniversary it ostensibly commemorates) does suggest that in a year or so we will see a similar set issued for the Velvets' 3rd album. It will contain the Val Valentin and Lou Reed stereo mixes of the original album, perhaps the very rare mono mix, a substantial chunk of the post-Cale content from VU and Another View (unless that's going to be the subject of a fourth super deluxe set, which I seriously doubt) and one of their many gigs at the Boston Tea Party.
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Uber Dissonance,
The Velvet Underground were perhaps the ultimate yin/yang band: with an incredible lyricist who was selfless about who actually sang them, capable of self-surrender ("Jesus") and total egotism (Lou Reed turning down the rest of the band in "I Heard Her Call My Name" - thankfully improved on the remaster), with a musical character capable of howling feedback and sweet chiming melodies, artistic yet streetwise, tough but vulnerable, basic yet relentlessly experimental, concise and pithy but able to do stream-of-consciousness ("Black Angel's Death Song") and a seventeen-minute epic, they had it all.
Where their debut combined all of these assets (making it a candidate for the greatest album of all time - and certainly one of the most influential), "White Light/White Heat" saw them focus on their dissonance and ferocity. (And their next album "The Velvet Underground" was all subdued sweet melodies). Consequently this can be a tough album to listen to, should you prefer the more focused and structured Velvet's songs - there's no "Sweet Jane" here, nor even "Venus In Furs" or "Heroin". In addition, this album is often cited as the worst-recorded album of all time, for the feedback, bleedthrough and distortion of the red-lining guitars and organ blew the studio capability apart (this being the mid-60s we're talking about here).
Nonetheless, this is a remarkable album, with musianship to die for. It starts relatively conventionally, with the eponymous title-track. It features a tremendous honkytonk rhythm, almost similar to "All Tomorrow's Parties", but where that felt portentous, this feels manically exhuberant, appropriately given the subject matter of speed. It ends with an incredible surge of bludgeoning energy, the like of which I have never heard anywhere else.
"The Gift" follows - a Lou Reed short story narrated by John Cale, over the backing of the Velvet's doing their Booker T and the MGs impression. The story is macabre and has an intensely black humour, and some wonderfully deft touches. Waldo's chracter can be immediately surmised by Sheila's two word summary of him..!
"Lady Godiva's Operation" starts fairly conventionally and, like a Burroughs story, just gets weirder and weirder. When Reed's voice cuts through with "Neatly" and "Sweetly" you wonder what planet they were on, and when the shivering starts you know you've never heard the like before. Bizarre but great fun.
"Here She Comes Now" has an achingly beautiful melody, played with impeccable gentleness. But almost in reply they follow with "I Heard Her Call My Name" which seems its crazed half-cousin. Where the narrator in "Here She Comes Now" is in love with a woman who doesn't notice him ("Ahhhh... she's made out of wood"), in "I Heard" the Velvets magnify that moment when love turns her gaze upon you to absurd proportions. Reed's guitar soloing is incredible, hyped and amplified to almost unbearable levels, and featuring perhaps the best use of feedback ever - after he says "And then my mind split open," there's a (relative) pause, and then the feedback explodes.
However all this pales into comparison with the closer "Sister Ray". Reed often mentioned freeform jazz musicians like Ornette Coleman in relation to this song, and so traditional rock concepts of verse and chorus, melody and harmony are out of the window. Built upon a huge surging three-chord riff, "Sister Ray" grows into a monstrous epic, with Reed and Cale almost literally duelling it out, with guitar and organ freeforming and interjecting upon each other and the vocal. Like Coltrane's "Asenscion" and Coleman's "Free Jazz", each seems to take turn to solo while the other instruments comment upon and freeform over it. This gives the whole piece an insane level of musical ferocity - "Sister Ray" was done live, in one take, and no-one backs down at any point to accomodate anyone else. All mighty good, a gleeful musical decontruction. And yet the closing of the song tops all that, when the steady propulsive beat (deftly accelerating or slowing as the song demands) of Mo Tucker's drums finally become as thrashed as the other instruments, which leads to a huge feedback soundblast, an incredible outpouring of sonic energies at the speed of light. Utterly jaw-dropping incredible. Lou Reed's vocals also deserve a mention - he narrates a seedy debauched tale of junky transvestites and a murdered sailor, but two and a half times, and with ever more distortion, playing with the words, stretching them out, misshaping them. Everything is dissonant, distorted, even the lyric and voice. To some, "Sister Ray" is the greatest song ever recorded - it's unsurpassed in many ways. No punk band ever approached this level of power.
In sum, this album is certainly an acquired taste, but if you like feedback, distortion and plain old noise, it's the finest example of its kind, unsurpassed in forty years.
81 of 85 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars don't buy this one first,
If you've got this far you probably know this is one of the most critically acclaimed rock albums ever. That is well deserved but it doesn't mean you're going to like it - it's also one of the most uncompromising rock albums ever (one reason the critics like it so much) and was quite unprecedented at the time - and completely out of step with the current hippie/flower power/peace and love ethos. It was also made very quickly and cheaply with an engineer who wasn't hugely enamoured of the group, so the niceties of production were pretty much non-existent. This doesn't matter, for the most part, as long as you like extreme, noisy, brutish rock'n'roll.
The title track is a short, snappy slice of distorted rock'n'roll which you could imagine being recorded by Jerry Lee Lewis or Little Richard - although it would sound very different. Then they slow down for The Gift, with the band jamming grungily away on 3 chords in one channel while John Cale, with his marvellously deadpan Welsh voice, recites an amusing and macabre short story Lou Reed wrote while studying English in the early 1960s. This is followed by the two quietest tracks on the album, Lady Godiva's Operation and Here She Comes Now. The former is sung mostly by Cale, with sudden interjections from Reed, and is another macabre little tale over a quite unique droney background with the only appearance of Cale's viola on this album. The latter is by far the most "pleasant" piece of music on the album, a prettily hypnotic little ditty wondering whether a girl will come.
What was side 2 of the original lp begins with probably the most extreme track, I Heard Her Call My Name. By all accounts this doesn't do justice to their live performances of the song and is the one track where the recording shortcomings matter, but it is still quite extraordinary, featuring among the most savagely atonal lead guitar ever committed to tape. This really isn't for the fainthearted but it certainly isn't without merit. And finally... the last 17+ minutes of the album are taken up by the awesome Sister Ray. Again the lyrics (about a bunch of drag queens shooting up heroin and murdering a sailor they don't appear to have known very long) are sordid and macabre, but Lou Reed relates this scuzzy tale with sardonic relish over an astonishing and propulsive one chord blast that never lets up, driven along by Maureen Tucker's hypnotic drumming. They were determined that there wouldn't be either a second take or overdubs - they had to nail it first time. There is no bass, just two guitars, organ and drums. At various points it develops into a volume duel between Lou Reed's guitar and John Cale's organ, with Cale pulling out more and more stops and then Reed cranking up the volume and distortion on his guitar. It never degenerates into self-indulgent jamming or outlives its welcome, indeed for many devotees it's too short. The demented glee with which they bash it out completely transcends the sordid subject matter - this really is rock distilled down to its essence.
Unless you like really abrasive stuff already (e.g. The Stooges' Fun House, with which it shares the pinnacle of proto-grunge) you may well find this a bit much, so it's not the ideal place to start if you haven't heard the Velvet Underground before. Try their equally excellent debut, The Velvet Underground & Nico, which is the only one of their albums to combine both pretty tunes and noise and consequently gives a good idea of the range of music they played. If you like the noisy stuff on that, you'll love this. If you don't but like the more tuneful stuff, you'll like their untitled 3rd album and Loaded.
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The best reason in the world to go deaf!,
By A Customer
This is my favourite VU album. It is one of those albums that you can't quite play loud enough. The band are at their heaviest instrumentally and Lou sings everything like he is the most pissed off person alive. He sounds, in a Dylan kind of way, like he knows the stuff is so good he doesn't have to try too hard to hit the notes.
The blueprint for loads of subsequent stuff, from early punk (Cale helped the Stooges out on their debut) and Can ('Hallelujah' is really just a funky 'Sister Ray') right up to the whole grunge thing (Check out Nirvana's version of Here she comes now, if you can find it). The most outstanding tracks are the more extreme - Cale narrating the horrifically funny 'The Gift', the maddest guitar I have ever heard on 'I Heard her call my name' and of course 'Sister Ray' - over 17 minutes of amp abuse that just wears you out.
Dark, disturbing but just so cool. The sound all young guitar based bands want, but never really achieve. This album is the best reason in the world to go deaf!
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars What a great record and half decent Blu ray audio!,
This review is from: White Light/White Heat (Blu-ray Audio)
I had just picked up the box set for this about two months ago but I loved "Velvet Underground with Nico" Blu ray audio so much I wanted to give it a shot. This BRA is an improvement over the latest remastered CD but not night and day. It is also a pretty short record. However if you want to hear everything on the two track master this what to buy.
AGAIN FOR THOSE DON'T KNOW THERE IS NO VIDEO CONTENT ON THIS BLU RAY AND THERE IS NO 5.1 MIX . JUST A STRAIGHT STEREO TRANSFER!!
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars searching for your mainline? you've found it with this album,
By A Customer
this was the velvets' second album, that, like it's predecessor (the excellent and very influential 'velvet underground and nico'), was released to very little critical acclaim, only just entering the chart at no. 199!
but 'white light/white heat's importance and influence was later acknowledged as a little thing called punk happened in the late 70s. this is pretty much, as far as i'm aware, the very first, and one of the very best punk albums.
a quick word: every review i've ever read bangs on about how shocking and notorious this lp is. to be really honest- yeah, ok, there's hardly a 'song' on it, it's still LOUD, dirty and extremely no-fi and uncommercial, but i think some of the shock value has gone, 35+ years later. it's only REALLY shocking, nasty, gritty and notorious when you put it in context: this was released in 1968. peace and love. hippies. freedom. the beatles, for cryin' out loud. and here were the velvet underground (lou reed, john cale, sterling morrison and moe tucker) making basic, noisy, droning hard-rock music and writing about sex-change operations, grisly deaths, and murderous orgies. intrigued? read on...
1.title track 'white light/white heat' is good ol' 50s rock 'n' roll (pounding, propulsive piano) given a v.u injection (fuzz, distortion, screechy guitars). for those of you less educated about the joys(?!) of drugs, 'white heat' is heroin and 'white light' is speed. and it certainly sounds like that was what was fueling the band while recording! so, not quite elvis rock 'n' roll, then.
2.a lot of people put down 'the gift', or only listen to it a few times, but i absolutely love it. in an ingenious and definetely avant-garde effort, john cale reads one of lou reed's college stories about a weirdo who posts himself to his girlfriend with grisly consequences in one speaker, while lou and sterling lay down a slick, groovy, fuzzy guitar track in the other. the story itself is a well written, entertaining little piece and cale's lilting welsh tones fit it perfectly.
3.'lady godiva's operation' is, IMHO, the worst track here. again, it's a great idea and a good attempt to make it work, but it doesn't quite happen. john cale takes vocal duties for the main part, singing a line, and then lou reed sings the last word of that line. since the dynamics of the their voices are noticeably different, it comes off quite choppy. it's about a sex-change operation that goes horribly wrong, ending in the patient's death. there are some creepy sound effects (oxygen machine, choking on anasthetic, chainsaw). the music is slow, distorted and kind of easternish. there are fuzzy guitars, with squeaky viola in the background. this track is easily the weirdest thing the velvets' ever recorded, and it leaves you with a nasty taste in your mouth.
4.'here she comes now' is the quietest song here, and the most musical. it's a wave of calm in a stormy ocean- soft, gentle and not unlike the brilliant 'sunday morning' on the previous lp. the lyrics might be about sex, but it doesn't really matter; there's hardly any words anyway. some probably see 'here she comes now' as boring and far too slow and melodic for this big, noisy, lumbering, menacing monster of an album. i love it, but it doesn't prepare you for the firing-on-all-cylinders sonic assault that follows...
5.penultimate track 'i heard her call my name' is completely devoid of any melody whatsoever. it's a fast, pounding rollercoaster ride about wanting a dead girl. lou drawls 'and then i felt my mind split open' and then unleashes on us mere mortals possibly the coolest, maddest guitar solo ever recorded. note(?) after note after note, soaked in feedback and drenched in distortion, it spirals, twists, turns and screams until you know EXACTLY how it feels to have your mind split open. whatever the guy was smoking when he recorded that, i want some. lots of it. now.
6.if you thought 'i heard her call my name' was a metaphorical slap around the head, 'sister ray' is an elbow in the jaw and a few hard punches on the nose. AND getting your face rubbed in gravel afterwards. this is THE best rock song ever. nothing to beat it before or since and there never will be. standing at a marathon 17:27, lou tells us all about the attendants at an ill-fated, drug-filled party/orgy that turns murderous. 'i haven't got the time time/ too busy sucking on a ding-dong.' a few people die, the cops turn up, and from then onwards it's a complete sonic breakdown. the musical apocalypse. i can't describe it any better than that. if you can stick this one all the way thru, start to finish, after listening to all of the previous tracks, then well done. take a few headache pills, throw up if you need to, and go lie down in a darkened room for several days. then when you're fully recovered, go and listen to the album again.
so that's basically an analysis of one of the top 5 best albums in the world ever. it's a rock masterpiece and every single person who has ever even contemplated the idea of being in a punk band needs this now. all you so-called 'punks' out there listening to the latest so-called 'punk' bands and all you teens listening to commercial, watered-down top 40 'rock'- these guys are the originals. listen and learn, and have a change of underwear on hand for afterwards.
those wise people that choose to buy the monster that is 'white light/white heat': your life will change (and so will the relations with neighbours, so you might want to move into a cave somewhere) when you hear this amazing cd. before you play it, tho', try and invest in double glazing. or get the number of someone that'll fit new windows, cuz you'll need 'em after one spin of this album.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars the velvets 'difficult' second album,
The Nico album gets most of the critical acclaim. It's undoubtedly a classic but if you want to hear something really extraordinary then you should check this out. Everything about this album, from the subject matter of the lyrics to the primitive production and anarchic song structures, is subversive. Years and years ahead of its time, it still has the power to unsettle 40 years after it was first recorded. Not that it deliberately sets out to shock in a calculated Pistols way. That's just the way it came out.
If you make it as far as the final track and are still enjoying it then i can promise you a rare treat. Still reeling from the most brutal guitar solo ever recorded ('I heard her call my name')? It's just about to get much much better....
If I told you that an album track recorded in 1968 was 17 minutes long you might be excused for thinking it would be some trippy, hippy psychedelic jam designed to send the listener into a deep coma. But 'Sister Ray' is one of the rawest, most thrilling pieces of music you'll ever hear. Yes, there is a tune in there somewhere and a debauched tale of sailors and prostitutes but the real thrill is the sonic assault on the ears created by the duel that breaks out between Cale's organ and Reed's guitar. Both turning up to '11', it's a punch up to behold. Cale comes out on top........just. Heart-stopping stuff and a fitting finale to an amazing album. Buy it.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Too much of the same,
Let's get the obvious comments out of the way first. Unless you live on the Moon you already know the groundbreaking importance of the Velvets and how this album is their most extreme statement that invented the seventies. It's also safe to say that if you shelled out the extra cash for this you (like me) are already a fan and already own the original (along with all the other relevant releases including Another View, VU and the other extended version of WL/WH on Peel Slowly and See).
The actual album sounds fine here, but then again I always thought it did and I've listened to this several times and honestly can not tell the difference. So the validity of this release, for me, relies solely on the strength of the additional studio and live material.
Firstly, the extra studio material. How the hell could anybody justify including Hey Mr. Rain, Stephanie Says, and Guess I'm Falling in Love here!? They've been widely available for years and this is just lazy filler with the old 'remixed' chestnut appended. Peel Slowly and See has got a demo of Here She Comes Now - surely they must have demoed other tracks for this album - why are they not included? I really fail to believe that these were the only tracks the band had and these are the only versions of them.
Now I've got that of my chest - the good points. The early version of Beginning to See the Light is GOLD. Really, as a Velvets fan this is one of those discoveries you always dream of but so very rarely get. I would stick my neck out and say this is better than the version from the 3rd Album. Like another reviewer here I don't think that it is an alternative version of I Heard Her Call My Name, however it is sufficiently remixed to allow the rhythm guitar to come to the fore and gives the song a much rougher garage feeling.
Finally, to the extra live material. This was recorded in New York in early 1967 before the band recorded White Light and contains early versions of some of the tracks that would appear on WL/WH along with tracks from the 1st album and unreleased tracks. Two of these (Booker T and Guess I'm Falling in Love) have already been released on Peel Slowly and See and are fairly standard R & B workouts given a rough Velvets edge. I'm Not a Young Man Anymore has a similar feel to Guess... and as such doesn't add a great deal to the bands' canon but is still welcome as a new track. The real meat of this collection are the live versions of the tracks that appeared on their official albums. Waiting For the Man has evolved into a real killer - a riff lead snarl of a song that I wouldn't have guessed at given how it ended up sounding just 2 years later. Sister Ray is cleaner than the album version but this allows the rhythm to stand out more and just shows what an exceptional live band this was. Finally it ends with an instrumental version of The Gift. Apparently this has been confused with Booker T over the years but I can't see why. This is no crowd pleasing R & B, this is a down and dirty 2 chord grind that is still one of the bands' finest moments - they didn't always have to sing about deviant sex - sometimes the music just sounded like it.
All in all this could have been so much better, but there are still some gems here - but was it really worth the price tag?
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Don't you know you'll stain the carpet,
This has to be one of the worst productions ever made by any sound engineer, which only helps to make this album the garage/punk classic that it is. The throwaway style and attitude is perfect, the guitar work is frenetically exciting and the compositions are terrific. Sister Ray is a gargantuan slab of musical obsidian that will slice and rip your soul. Beg, steal or borrow a copy of this now!
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The Gift horse gets examined,
This review is from: White Light / White Heat - Super Deluxe (Audio CD)
Not as elaborate as the 6 cd versions of their first album or the upcoming third, this is nevertheless worthwhile as it contains both the stereo and elusive mono mixes, plus some extras such as a good quality copy of the 1967 Gymnasium live bootleg. One problem: as a collector I want beautfully packaged things like this to be in perfect condition, yet copies ordered from two different sellers arrived with damaged covers. I note that some sellers are listing new copies as having storage damage or dings to packaging. I don't know why it should be so hard to find a perfect copy of this, as the VU sang, 'What Goes On', or to put it bluntly WTF?! At over £30 (and up!) for three cds we deserve better.
Most Helpful First | Newest First