44 of 49 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Deeply Affecting
This film runs 'The Godfather' close for arguably the finest cast of any movie. The acting is second-to-none and boasts the combined talents of De Niro, Streep, Walken and Cazale. The early part of the movie is devoted to the relationships between the main characters and a marvellously joyous Russian Orthodox wedding scene that sets up the tragedy that befalls the three...
Published on 14 Feb. 2003 by Steven Moses
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars One shot? I don't think that much about one shot anymore, Mike ..,
Apparently, The Deer Hunter has achieved a degree of protected status; a film so revered by some that it is exempt from criticism. At least, that is the opinion of Mark Kermode, who then goes on to criticise Michael Cimino's rites of passage epic, calling it self-indulgent, rambling, somnabulic and racist* (amongst other things). Well, I don't know about all of that but...
Published on 4 Dec. 2012 by Crookedmouth
Most Helpful First | Newest First
44 of 49 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Deeply Affecting,
This film runs 'The Godfather' close for arguably the finest cast of any movie. The acting is second-to-none and boasts the combined talents of De Niro, Streep, Walken and Cazale. The early part of the movie is devoted to the relationships between the main characters and a marvellously joyous Russian Orthodox wedding scene that sets up the tragedy that befalls the three friends after their capture at the hands of the Viet-Cong. The changes both physical and mental as the men return from war and the effects on their loved ones is brilliantly portrayed. Russian roulette although arguably not historically correct is used as a metaphor for Walken's disregard for his own life and the hunting trip on De Niro's return only serves to highlight his own high regard for life.
It's one of those films that stays with you long after viewing and causes you to think deeply on the terrible effect war has on people and communities. Outstanding.
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Moving portrayal of the psychological effects of war,
'The Deer Hunter' is not a conventional war film. Rather, it's an exploration of the psychological effects of war on the individual. At over three hours long, some call this film epic, others horribly dull and depressing. Split into three acts, the first hour of the film follows the three main characters Mike, Nick and Steve (Robert De Niro, Christopher Walken and John Savage) in their home town of Clairton, a small, industrial town with a large contingent of Russian immigrants. The story begins with Steve's wedding, which doubles as a send-off party for the three men who have volunteered to fight in Vietnam, but with no real knowledge of what to expect. However, an uninvited guest at the wedding, a 'Green Beret' who has recently returned from Vietnam, hints at what they can expect... he is a man who has been psychologically destroyed, and his unusual behaviour is greeted at first with anger, then amusement, but no real comprehension. We also follow the men on a last deerhunting trip in the mountains, as the film builds up our understanding of each character. Indeed, the deer hunting segments serve as a powerful metaphor that underpins the rest of the movie. The peace and tranquility of the mountains are counterposed with the sound of choppers and gunfire in Vietnam. From the outset it is clear that Mike, who sees deerhunting as more than just mere sport, has a deeper understanding of what the war will do to them, as is somehow better placed to cope...
The second third of the movie throws us straight into the thick of battle, from the sleepy streets of a small Pennsylvanian town, to the brutality of the Vietnam War. Almost immediately, one of the most controversial scenes in movie history is upon us, the brilliant and shocking scene where American (and allied) POW's are forced to play Russian Roulette against each other by their Vietcong captors.... controversial not least because it portrays the VC in a particularly brutal light, and the Americans as victims. But this scene is where all three main actors are at their very best (Indeed, Christopher Walken would win an Oscar for his performance in 'The Deer Hunter'). It is here that Steve and Nick are psychologically broken, and where Mike (De Niro) has to save his friends from certain death.
The final third of the movie (which I won't go into much detail so as not to spoil the film) deals with the aftermath once the conflict (for these men atleast) is over, and (one way or another), they return home to find that life can never be the same again. It is here that the true emotional depth of the film is captured by Robert De Niro's amazing talent. It is difficult (if not impossible) not to be moved by his portrayal of Mike who finds it hard to cope with the mundane realities of a previous life that no longer has much meaning or comfort. Add to these performances some brilliant supporting roles, including Meryl Streep who, like De Niro, was nominated for an Oscar. Also, the now legendary score, including the famous theme 'Cavatina' by Stanley Myers (and performed by John Williams), adds poignancy to many scenes throughout the film.
'The Deer Hunter' won the Oscar for Best Picture, but is not without it's critics. The take-home message from this controversial film has been the source of many a debate, and has been criticised for being overtly patriotic, but I personally do not see it as such. I don't think that it either glorifies or belittles the role of the Americans in Vietnam, rather the film is more about the people than the politics, and who those people were... not trained soldiers or the hi-tech killing machines that we see today, but just Joe Public, steel-workers, shop-owners, bartenders who go deer hunting at the weekends... volunteers who didn't know what they were letting themselves in for.
Moving, brutal, and (ultimately) quite depressing, 'The Deer Hunter' stands head and shoulders above other films of the genre (like Apocalypse Now or Platoon) in that it uses far more subtle ways to portray the grim reality of life and war.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Review of 'The Deer Hunter',
This review is from: The Deer Hunter [DVD]  (DVD)
First off i've watched many many films in my short time here on earth. As i've studied film in college i have really began to see the beauty of filmmaking. The Deer Hunter for me is one of the best films i have ever seen and i believe ever will. The film first off introduces the audience to the relationship between 'the gang' of friends and we see intimate moments of friendship between them which comes back later to give some of the most brilliant moments ever in film history. Do not be fouled, this isn't a film based in Vietnam, the film shows only roughly 30 minutes for it's 3 1/2 film in Vietnam. I suggest you watch 'Apocalypse Now' if you are interested in that sort of film. This film is based entirely on the bond between the friends and the impact of Vietnam on them which changes them forever.
A glorious film by Michael Cimino and i suggest any one who is interested in watching a fantastic story and character development to watch this.
What a gift.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliantly crafted film!,
This review is from: The Deer Hunter [DVD]  (DVD)
The perfect gift for all movie buffs is THE ROMA VICTRIX WINE BEAKERCalix Imperium, Roma Victrix Pewter wine beaker
Brilliantly crafted film follows the paths of three young men from small-town Pennsylvania, focusing mainly on De Niro's Michael and three times in their lives: just before they go to fight in Vietnam, some momentous times during the war, and the situation at home when they finally return. Heart-wrenching, epic, and a fantastic study of the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder, not only on the people fighting the war but their loved ones at home. De Niro, Streep and Walken stand out in a superb cast - not much to complain about with this one.
Oscar Wins for Film Editing, Sound, Supporting Actor (Christopher Walken), Directing, and Best Picture. Oscar Nominations for Original Screenplay, Cinematography, Supporting Actress (Meryl Streep), and Lead Actor (Robert De Niro).
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars It only takes one shot,
This review is from: The Deer Hunter (Special Edition) (2 Disc)  [DVD] (DVD)
(Warning: this film contains war bruality and violence that is "not suitable" for sensitive people)
The Deer Hunter was the one, that no studio would take on, following the end of American involvement of Vietnam, a couple of years previous. The help of Sir Henry Belfonte, the chairman of EMI as one of a three-picture-deal, ensured it was made and released to the public.
Fresh out of Thunderbolt and Lightening, Cimino and his crew studied the impact of Vietnam War, via many sources, to add to the accuracy and realism of the tough times in half capitalist and half communist divided states of North and South Vietnam.
The Deer Hunter deals with a group of blue-collar steel workers drinking buddies' in a small Pennyslevania town. Michael and Nick are the closest and are probably seen in our eyes as the most afraid of going to fight, Nick promises whatever happens, he wants Michael to take him home where he belongs......
The title, is a metaphor, since in this case, the men refer the deers as "girls", hence it is important to find one to settle down with and that "you've only got one shot" like the precise shot to kill the deer, to get it right before the oppertunity is gone forever.
The acting, shows the men try to stride along with three serving in Vietnam, how difficult and lost their lives' become, how empty and meaningless. The performance of Walkden, who comes across as loving, cheery and happy, slowly reverts in a suicidal troubled man whose longing to go back, means nothing to him now. De Niro gives the emotion of a man of dedication, glory and trust, but deeply worrying and sad. Meryl Streep in her first main role, plays the role of abused Linda, who is Nick's girlfriend, but doesn't cherish her love for him as much as she likes to think.
The editing of The Deer Hunter places the film into chapters, broken down and easy to follow, to show the horror of war and conflict, also the slow distrengtion of their friendship and the lives' which are recked.
The Deer Hunter is daunting, brisk and moving, it is one of the finest Best Picture films and arguably one of the finest seventies films ever made.
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Great Movie,
This review is from: The Deer Hunter [VHS]  (VHS Tape)
...This film becomes more astonishing with each passing year. Cimino's portrait of a community coming to terms with the Vietnam War is so multi-layered it repays repeated watching.
At the centre of the film stands DeNiro's Michael - for my money his greatest performance, as he manages to suggest a complex, quiet man who in war knows what it takes to survive but in peace cannot give up on his friends. Around this is one of the casts of the Seventies - Streep delivers one of her most understated, restrained and heartbreaking performances whilst Walken is career best. Add to these great work from Cazale, Savage and Dzunda and one realises why the seventies produced so many good movies.
Cimino marshalls all his forces with a slow burning grandeur - the opening wedding scene is almost documentary in it's portrait of a mid-western immigrant community whilst the famous Russian Roulette scene is remarkable, nerve breaking cinema. The final scenes are emotionally charged - for this viewer the movie is never a second too long. If you really want to know what Hollywood could produce when it had some guts and integrity then watch this.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A haunting piece of genius.,
This film is strange for a war film in that you actually see a lot of the characters personal lives; and because it's an intelligent, brilliantly crafted film, you actually do give a damn about what happens to them and the impact the war has on their loved ones. This film is one of the classics so I felt I had to watch it, I was instantly hooked and as the film drew to its conclusion I thought tragedy was inevitable and I could barely look at the screen. I was left heartbroken at the end of it. It's emotional, tense and shows the vietnam war in far more than just the usual scenes of explosions and American men creeping around in camo while gradually turning into savage beasts. I urge you to watch this film.
25 of 30 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A gruelling, powerful war movie.,
One of the first american movies to deal with the vietnam war, The Deerhunter focuses on the effect of the war back home rather than dwell on the frontlines.Robert De Niro, John Savage and Christopher walken are three friends all set to go to war.the film begins by showing us a wedding where the characters are introduced and the relationships defined.this covers the first hour of the movie and Cimino's build up is deliberately slow and detailed to let us become familiar with and care for these characters.the movie then follows the men on a hunting trip in the mountains before the leave(the hunting seems almost like a stay of execution)before we are taken to the savagery of the battlefield.the most memorable and shocking scenes occur when the friends are captured and forced to play each other in russian roulette.these scenes have a raw power rarely seen in many movies with all the leads excelling.Walken in particular(an oscar-winning performance)is outstanding,his uniquely twitchy,nervous persona has never been so astutely utilised.
the aftermath of the war shows De Niro finding it impossible to adjust to life back home alienating his friends Meryl Streep(excellent, as ever)and John Cazale.Savage is without his legs in a veteran's hospital and Walken roams the vietnam streets playing russian roulette for money,a ghost searching for his deliverance. When that final curtain comes it is an incredibly powerful blow that will leave the viewer reeling.Gripping and powerful, The deerhunter is a perfect companion piece to Apocalypse Now and Platoon.It may be heartbreaking and gruelling but it is ultimately rewarding.
5.0 out of 5 stars Standing the test of time, still delivering an emotional KO,
Let me state upfront that when "The Deer Hunter" (1978 production but wide release in early 1979; 183 min.) was first released, I was 18 years old, and the movie left a profound impression on me when I first saw it. I have seen bits and pieces of it here and there (usually by channel-surfing coincidence), but I hadn't seen the movie proper in several decades. There recently was a nice write-up in the Financial Times about this year being the movie's 35th anniversary (as to its wide release), and I told myself, I just have to see this movie again! My preference would've been to see it again in the theater, but that not being possible, I ordered the Blu-ray.
Couple of comments on what it was like to re-watch the movie after all these years: while I recalled quite a bit of the movie, I was struck by the many details that jumped out at me, such as the beautiful wedding scenes and subsequent reception scenes. Also struck by the beauty and grace of the young Meryl Streep (then in a relationship with cancer-stricken John Cazale, who passed away shortly after shooting this and never saw the completed movie). Also very impressed with the devastating performance from John Savage as the vulnerable Stevie, how did this not get noticed come Oscar time? Also when you look at the early/mid 70s steel town scenes, all I could think was "those were horrible times!". The now infamous Russian Roulette scenes remain as difficult to watch now as they were then, although I will say that it was a shock seeing them as an 18 yr. old. I did not expect to react to the movie as emotionally as I did, given that I knew exactly how it would play out. As it turned out, I found myself in tears on many occasions throughout the movie, and at the conclusion of it, I was a wreck, clear and simple.
Upon having watched the 3 hour movie, I'm sorry but I wasn't interested AT ALL in watching any of the bonus materials, which include "Deleted Scenes and Extended Scenes", "Feature Commentary with Cinematographer Vilmos Zsigmond and Film Journalist Bob Fisher", the theatrical trailer, and strangely enough a feature called "100 Years at Universal: Academy Award Winners". Maybe I'll get to it one day, maybe not, but it is completely secondary to reliving the emotional rollercoaster that is "The Deer Hunter", a movie that resonated with me in 1979 and still does so now 35 years later in 2014. "The Deer Hunter" truly stands the test of time any way you look at it, and is a MUST-SEE movie, period.
"The Deer Hunter" cost (in today's dollars) $59 million to make, and went on to score (in today's dollars) $196 million at the box office. Can you imagine what it would cost to shoot a movie like that in today's Hollywood? And that's assuming it could even be made today.
A quick comment about the Blu-ray: this comes as a 2 disc package, with Disc 1 being the "regular" version and Disc 2 being the "wide screen" version. I started playing Disc 1 and immediately felt something was off. It wasn't until 5 minutes into the movie that I finally figured out what the 2nd disc was for. I immediately switched to the "wide screen" version and that was perfectly fine.
5.0 out of 5 stars one shot,
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Deer Hunter [HD DVD] (HD DVD)
This review is for the Australian HD-DVD, which seems identical to the UK/France release (studio canal/universal label and same cover shot).
I won't go into detail about the film itself, which won 5 academy awards and deserves it's 'classic' status, suffice to say most people interested in this HD-DVD will have seen it at least once.
Having read some unfavorable reviews of the US HD-DVD release, I was uncertain what to expect when I loaded it into my Toshiba XE1.
On first impression the video quality appeared good but not that impressive, then at around 6min 20secs I was literally staggered by the amount of detail in an outdoor scene (just the guys with a brick building
Furthermore at just under the hour mark, when the car is parked on the mountain road, the detail revealed in the road texture, even the distant backdrop of trees is crisply rendered and looks as good as anything i've seen in high definition, doing full justice to Vilmos Zsigmond's stunning cinematography.
Any variation throughout the film seems more to do with lighting than anything. Dull scenes like the poolroom will always look that way.
The audio track is DTS-HD master audio, confirmed and decoded by my Marantz SR7002 via hdmi bitstream from the XE1.
Don't expect miracles here though, as like many older movies, the original sound design is of limited sonic impact, so louder scenes can sound a trifle harsh.
Most importantly it sounded faithful to the source, and this is about as good as it's going to get on the sound front.
I then popped in the standard dvd from the The Deer Hunter: Special Edition (2 discs) [DVD] , and what a difference. It was like going back to vhs, including the shaky titles.
To be fair, the HD-DVD has obviously been minted from a new master (unlike both previous dvd releases) as I could immediately see a lot of the print damage has been cleaned up, but still retaining the 'grimy' and cinematic look of the movie.
This is how movies should be presented on the high definition formats, a nice 1080p encode from a good print, coupled with a lossless soundtrack.
It should lose a star for dropping the extras from the above mentioned 2xDVD SE (which included some great input from Michael Cimino) but claws it back for the improvement in the picture quality alone.
Most Helpful First | Newest First