Customer Reviews

3 Reviews
5 star:
4 star:
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
Most Helpful First | Newest First

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars As good as you'd hope to hear today, 9 Feb 2014
Ralph Moore "Ralph operaphile" (Bishop's Stortford, UK) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Wagner: Die Walkure, Act 1 (Nina Stemme/Vienna State Opera/Welser-Most) (Audio CD)
Beautiful orchestral playing, excellent conducting, first rate sound for a live performance - that leaves only the question of the singers, and they are as good as you may generally hear today unless you are lucky enough to get Jonas Kaufmann as Siegmund.

Neither lead singer seems to me to be amongst the very best I've heard, however: both have more of an incipient wobble in their vibratos than is ideal for the Wagner singer who needs to maintain complete steadiness of line at often punishing volume, intensity and tessitura. I am always conscious of the beginnings of a bleat when they are under pressure. Nor does Botha have the baritonal heft the role requires; no wonder Ramon Vinay, who was both baritone and tenor in his glorious career, was the ideal Siegmund. Still, Stemme is pretty vibrant, committed and thrilling in her "Der Männer Sippe", which is the best passage in this performance. The Hunding is a bit gruff but perfectly adequate; the main thing is the dramatic thrust of the music in what is surely the best Act in all Wagner. It's hard to shake off memories of old classic versions from Walter, Karajan and Leinsdorf; I find that in particular Melchior's and Vickers' voices have etched themselves into my memory but it's curmudgeonly not to welcome good, modern, live performance such as this.

This was part of a recording project aborted because of the indisposition of the Wotan, so we have only this Act from the 2007 performance directed by Welser-Möst.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

6 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant-but where's the rest of it???, 10 July 2013
D. S. CROWE "Music Lover" (UK) - See all my reviews
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Wagner: Die Walkure, Act 1 (Nina Stemme/Vienna State Opera/Welser-Most) (Audio CD)
I have already provided a brief scenario of the convoluted politics surrounding the release of the DG recording of the 2011 Ring from Vienna under Thielemann in my review of the set. In its on/off release was a source of speculation-generally that either Franz Welser-Most had vetoed it in his capacity as Music Director, or that Thielemann had vetoed because it had too many flaws. Even Austrian Radio was reluctant to broadcast it!
Both camps strenuously denied the rumours, and as we know it did finally appear, deeply flawed but with its strengths too.
Hot on its heels, we now have a taster from Orfeo of FWM's 2007 performance of what was then a new production-and what a fizzing, exciting account of Walkure Act One it is! It was his conducting of this cycle that in no small way contributed to his "coming up on the rails" to succeed the ailing Ozawa whose flaccid tenure was coming to an end, when Thielemann had been the favourite. On this brief snapshot, one can see why.
The recorded sound, re-mastered from DDD Austrian Radio Master Tapes is superb-actually preferable to that by DG in that it is more sense of air, more sheen and provides a more accurate impression of what its like to be in the house.
FWM proves yet again to be a highly accomplished Wagnerian. In this act he conducts with the luminosity of Karajan-some of the chamber-like effects are breathtaking-but with the drive and energy of Leinsdorf. This is no mean feat!
The opening prelude whips along at a pace Usain Bolt would find difficult to sustain, and he never allows the music to stagnate, while shaping it exquisitely. The orchestra play with absolute assurety, ravishing tone and tremendous weight when FWM allows it. The deep brass-bass trombone and tuba-growl with a real snarl, and the high brass in the sword motif are thrilling-and impeccable. The strings and woodwind are ravishing, and there is great detail revealed in the recording. Playing, conducting and recording are a triumph!
The singing, if not quite the best we've ever heard, is the best for a long time where Kaufmann is not involved!
Johan Botha's debut here as Siegmund is a major success. His open throated clear voiced Siegmund is streets ahead of Ventris in this role, and he just lacks the last vestige of darker baritonal quality in his voice to be ideal.
His lyrical singing is beautifully mellifluous, his cries of Wälse are thrilling enough, and though one can hear him winding himself up to sustain the final "Wälsungeblut", he brings it off magnificently.
Ain Anger is a dark, firmed voice Hunding who starts off brooding and quietly menacing and builds up to become an imposing threat indeed.
He doesn't quite match the power and menace of Frick or Salminen, but it is a very fine assumption.
The main focus for the promotion of this disc is Nina Stemme's debut as Sieglinde.
In 2007 she was at her peak of course, so I had hoped her Sieglinde would be excellent. It's not excellent-it's utterly superb!
Like Varnay on the second cycle recording of the Keilberth Ring, this Sieglinde is no down-trodden victim waiting for rescue.
This is a Sieglinde simmering with restrained passion, disdainful of the husband forced upon her, and radiant of emotion when she recognises the true object of her desires in Siegmund.
There is no more assured Sieglinde on record-Stemme does not have the limpid beauty of Crespin or Janowitz, but she compensates for this with truly thrilling passionate singing in an interpretation that is worth the cost of the set alone!
The presentation is beautiful, other than a photograph of FWM that makes him look like a nerd with no friends-and of course, in true Orfeo fashion, there is no libretto. However, I cannot imagine that this disc will be bought by anyone other than those who already have a libretto or 10!
Its release poses some questions-where's the rest of it?
Why release only this tantalising snippet? We may one day get to learn of the politics-Vienna strikes again!
I'm happy to assert that it's the best Walkure Act One since the era of Solti, Bohm and Karajan- Gergiev and Kaufmann notwithstanding, as it is so much better played and conducted.
Fans of any of these artists need not hesitate-and diehard Wagnerians are in for a treat- but it is cruelly tantalising. So much better than Thielemann! 5 Stars. Stewart Crowe.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Debut recording of Walküre Act 1 for Stemme, Botha & Welser-Möst., 1 Dec 2013
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Wagner: Die Walkure, Act 1 (Nina Stemme/Vienna State Opera/Welser-Most) (Audio CD)
I chose this disc because I was interested to hear what the conductor and soloists would make of it. Nina Stemme sings Wagner every where these days, as does Johan Botha. Both sound fresher than I've heard them before,. but the standards for this Act of Die Walküre are so high that I feel they have some way to go. As does Welser-Möst. The prelude to Act 1 goes faster than Usain Bolt could run and is in consequence very disappointing. He can (I hope !) only improve.
Sound quality is very good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Only search this product's reviews