Top critical review
I didn't enjoy this, especially in kindle format
on 13 November 2013
I loved the book, I can't recommend it enough and I'd urge anyone to read it but I was sadly disappointed by the graphic novel. If I hadn't read the book, I may well have liked a bit but I also found the kindle format really didn't work for me. It showed a condensed form of the page with say 3-4 slides, then it showed each individual slide. This made it very fragmented and disjointed to me.
Maybe as an actual book, rather then kindle, would be better. If you haven't read the book you may well enjoy but after reading the book this just falls really short. If you read this and aren't sure, try the novel, same as if you like the graphic novel try the full on one. I don't think many who loved the full novel will enjoy it, sadly, but that's just my opinion. I was torn between 2 and 3 stars- I rated 3 because the plot is awesome (same as novel's) and the artwork is good, it just doesn't work for me a) because of the novel, it fell in comparison and b) because of the kindle format, most graphic novels really don't hold up well in kindle or tablet format they are better printed of viewed on a laptop.