Customer Reviews

2 Reviews
5 star:
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
Most Helpful First | Newest First

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Moog turns up the wattage, 11 Feb 2013
schumann_bg - See all my reviews
This review is from: Scarlatti Illuminated - Joseph Moog (Audio CD)
This Scarlatti disc really scintillates, presenting his sonatas interleaved with modern transcriptions of different ones by people like Tausig and Friedman, which beef them up but somehow leave their essential character intact. It is a fascinating exercise because in a way they do not lend themselves to romanticisation as Bach does, but these arrangers come up trumps anyway and Joseph Moog's articulation is Herculean in the thicker textures. The whole disc is so energising, it really makes you aware of the fantastic genius and energy of Scarlatti. In fact, all those lightbulbs on the cover lead me to wonder whether Moog's fingers couldn't be used as a new eco-friendly energy resource! The centrepiece is a Rachmaninov-like Chaconne by Walter Gieseking on the opening phrase of a slow sonata, which Moog plays in its original quiet version to round off the disc on a reflective note. The numbers he chooses are a mixture of familiar numbers with rarer ones, and you feel, thanks to Moog's splendid advocacy, that he has presented the composer in a new light, and shown how his music can be moulded to the possibilities of the modern piano in unexpected and vibrant ways, with some unparalleled trills, even from the outer fingers, it seems!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Frank L. Bell (Atlanta, Georgia United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Scarlatti Illuminated - Joseph Moog (Audio CD)
A fascinating collection of familiar Scarlatti originals mixed with extremely rare transcriptions of Scarlatti's originals is offered on this CD.

1. Sonata K.135 in E
2. Scarlatti/Tausig: Sonata K.12 in G Minor
3. Sonata K.247 in C# Minor
4. Scarlatti/Friedman: Gigue K.523 in G
5. Sonata k.466 in F Minor
6. Scarlatti/Tausig: Sonata K.487 in C
7. Sonata K.87 in B Minor
8. Gieseking: Chaconne on a theme by Scarlatti (Sonata K.32)
9. Sonata K.96 in D
10. Scarlatti/Tausig: Pastorale (Sonata K.9) in E Minor
11. Sonata K.70 in Bb
12. Scarlatti/Friedman: Pastorale K.446 in D
13. Sonata K.380 in E
14. Scarlatti/Tausig: Sonata K.519 in F Minor
15. Sonata K.32 in D Minor

This disc contains some of the most phenomenal finger dexterity ever recorded, and I remind my readers that I worked closely with such technical wizards as Jorge Bolet, Earl Wild, and Rian de Waal; thus I do not make such a statement lightly. Joseph Moog's technique is an art unto itself, and when combined with his musicianship, the results are astounding.

We must remember that Scarlatti himself referred to the first publication of his works as Exercises. The appellation "Sonata" came later. Scarlatti was a true virtuoso of the keyboard, and these works are the product of a man who reveled in his ability and who enjoyed demonstrating to the world just how great was his technique. No one can deny that the brilliance of most of these pieces was designed to dazzle audiences.

There have been many fine recordings of most of the original Sonatas. So it is the offering of transcriptions that makes this disc a "must-have."

The Tausig Pastorale is the least rare of the transcriptions on this disc. My late friend Charles Rosen would on occasion ask me to play the Josef Hofmann recording of this work. Just before the runs in thirds, Charles would whisper "Listen...! Listen...!" Then Charles would go to my piano and play that passage 3 or 4 times, imitating Hofmann's sound, and proud that he could do so. Along with Hofmann, other golden age greats recorded this piece, including Rachmaninoff and Ignaz Friedman, one of the other transcribers featured on this program. Mr. Moog chooses a tempo slightly slower than the old-timers, but his tempo is certainly in keeping with the Allegretto tempo instruction.

The other Tausig transcriptions of Scarlatti are played with great energy and vitality and Mr. Moog's deft handling of the scores belies the tremendous ability required to present such performances.

Whereas the Tausig transcriptions offer brilliant "illuminations" on the virtuosity of the originals, they do not stray far from the tonal territory and even the open sonorities of the originals.

That is not the case with the Gieseking Chaconne. Containing 21 variations and a coda, this work ventures into tonalities that certainly would have shocked Scarlatti. This work is based on Sonata K.32 in D minor, which lends itself perfectly to the transformations put upon it by Gieseking. I am strongly reminded of Godowsky in this work, and I consider this work to be a small masterpiece. The CD is worth buying for this work alone! This is one of the relatively few works that makes this listener want it to continue: at 6:47, it is simply too short! Joseph Moog works magic with this piece. He coaxes the most velvety sounds from the piano and his performance is hypnotic.

My favorite Scarlatti Sonata, K.446 in D, is the source of another amazing discovery, the Pastorale by Friedman. Once again I am reminded of Godowsky. This work is treacherously difficult; yet, to the casual listener, it sounds as if a child could play it. The fact that almost no one plays this work is a testament to its difficulty, because it is so lovely that many people would want to hear it. Joseph Moog negotiates the wicked stretches and voicings with ease. Friedman's "Gigue" transcription is full of exciting and dangerous leaps, which are easily tamed by Joseph Moog.

As for the original Scarlatti works on this disc, there are some of the popular favorites, such as the elegant K.380 in E and the virtuosic K.96 in D, whose arsenal of leaps, thirds, runs, trills and repeated notes is fired off with superhuman mastery by Mr. Moog, whose finger independence and accuracy are astounding. And the program closes with the quiet K.32, the source of Gieseking's Chaconne, for a perfect ending.

Everything about this CD is first-rate. The acoustics and sound engineering are wonderful, capturing Joseph Moog's power, beauty, and finesse that he creates with the marvelous instrument used in this recording. And the piano is in tune for each track. The informative liner notes are by Jeremy Nicholas, Godowsky specialist. As someone who dabbles in photography and graphic arts, I was impressed by the creativity of the cover design.

Finally, when I first received this disc, I put it into my player with the intention of "sampling" it before seriously listening to it at a later time. I was not able to pull myself away from this disc until I had listened to it completely for three consecutive times!

Thanks to the incredibly knowledgeable Donald Manildi, Curator of the International Piano Archives at the University of Maryland, for providing me with materials necessary for this review.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Scarlatti Illuminated - Joseph Moog
Scarlatti Illuminated - Joseph Moog by Joseph Moog (Audio CD - 2013)
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews