Shop now Shop now Shop now Up to 70% off Fashion Shop All Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Learn More Amazon Pantry Food & Drink Beauty Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Shop now Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

4.2 out of 5 stars5
4.2 out of 5 stars
5 star
1
4 star
4
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
0

Your rating(Clear)Rate this item
Share your thoughts with other customers

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

It is because the British Isles are surrounded by sea that the country remained heavily dependent on that sea for resupply (which included anything from munitions to food!) throughout two world wars. By complete contrast, Germany is largely surrounded by land and had no such reliance. It followed, therefore, that Germany was able to attack this maritime lifeline almost at will whereas, British forces had no similar targets. That war against Allied merchant ships took many forms - one of which was the German commerce raider.

These were terrifying weapons of war. Converted merchant freighters which formed part of a secret fleet of pirate ships, they were armed with torpedo tubes, deck and anti-aircraft guns - all of which were concealed from view in such a cunning way that each ship continued to look like an ordinary freighter whilst retaining the capacity to change into a ship of war - almost instantaneously. Many of these ships were far more successful than Germany's leading U Boats and, instead of patrolling the defended seas around the coast of Britain, they were able to roam the world's oceans and attack that shipping anywhere at all.

It should not be forgotten that in 1941, the raider `Kormoran' sank the Australian light cruiser HMAS Sydney - which had far greater fire power, using nothing more than sheer guile, surprise and accurate gunnery. The battle resulted in both ships being lost. Whereas 315 of the crew of 398 from the Kormoran survived, all 645 crew of the Sydney were lost. It was not until 2008 that both wrecks were finally located on the seabed. They are 12 miles apart.

That story and other similar encounters are told in this hugely informative book from Osprey Publishing. In three separate actions we learn how the raider `Thor' took on HMS Alcantara, HMS Carnarvon Castle and HMS Voltaire before the author moves on to a classic duel between the Pinguin and HMS Cornwall and the Atlantis vs. HMS Devonshire. As much as I would like to say the Royal Navy always came off best, as the reader will soon learn, that was not always the case.

With descriptions of the ships and crews from both sides, this is a hugely informative work. We are also treated to some underwater images from HMAS Sydney which, I am pleased to report, lies far too deep for those divers who seek to salvage war graves.

Altogether, this is a most competent work and one which I have thoroughly enjoyed.

NM
0Comment3 of 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 22 January 2012
Recommended. An insightful analysis of one of the most intriguing contests of WW2 between German raiders on the one hand and British Armed Merchant Cruisers (AMCs) and regular cruisers on the other hand. The German raiders were nondescript looking freighters armed with guns and mines and disguised to prey on lone merchant ships. AMCs were passenger liners armed with old 6" guns, used as substitutes for scarce regular cruisers. The book covers both the climatic gunnery duels and the broader contest to attack and protect merchant shipping. This is about the only campaign in WW2 where catapult launched sea planes, used by both sides, were a major factor!

This is the standard Osprey format with a lot space for images and a concise text with well researched factual and technical information. As with other books in this format the text is more abbreviated than ideal to adequately cover the subject. For example, 1942, an eventful year for German raiders, is summarized in a few paragraphs. However the insights and analysis are excellent. It demonstrates that the notion of British cruisers protecting unconvoyed ships by simply sailing the sea lanes was a failure. The core of the book is the description of the 6 actions between the raiders and the British; 3 with AMCs (all involving the same raider, Thor!) and 3 with purpose built cruisers. This includes the sinking (with all hands) of the Australian light cruiser Sydney by the German Kormoran off Western Australia; due to the incompetence of the Australian captain. The 3 actions between the AMCs and the Thor all went decisively in the Germans favour conclusively proving the inadequacy of AMCs as warships. For those already familiar with this aspect of naval history this is a useful addition, especially if obtained at a reasonable price. For others it is a good introduction to the subject.

For first hand accounts by raider captains see The German Raider Atlantis by Bernhard Rogge and THE RAIDER KORMORAN by Theodor Detmers. See also Ghost Cruiser Hk 33 by Hans Joachim Brennecke for an account of the raider Penguin and Secret Raiders by David Woodward for a history of all the German raiders in WWII . There are few books on British AMCs; see Armed Merchant Cruisers by Kenneth Poolman. These books can be obtained cheaply.
0Comment2 of 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 April 2013
My late father was Merchant Navy during WW2 even being briefly blockaded in Montevideo by the Graf Spee.

He always accepted that the Sydney was about the largest possible warship that could have been sunk by the Kormoran "given almost perfect ambush conditions", which is what seems to have happened. He always accepted the German version of events and found the conspiracy stories laughable.

The crew of the Sydney were due to start some well earned leave as soon as their ship docked. They were being held up from that highly desirable leave by what appeared to be a Dutch ship which couldn't answer the correct signal code. Meanwhile the Kormoran was edging closer to the perfect ambush.

The supposed sight of a periscope and war fleets would leave harbour and convoys change course. The torpedo had emerged as the deadliest weapon of two world wars sinking more ships than all other systems combined. Most merchant ships would sink from a single torpedo hit and it seems that the Kormoran put two into the Sydney plus multiple shell hits. The Kormoran would probably have lost any pure gunnery battle but those torpedoes made all the difference.

This book seems to be an excellent review of what happened and I am only saddened that my father didn't live long enough to learn that he had been essentially correct in what he had always believed had really happened.
0Comment1 of 1 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 September 2010
Thought this would be ok nothing more,i was wrong, it is a very good book packed full of information about this interesting part of the war at sea,if you are starting out this book should encourage further reading, if up on the subject its a good refresher. The discovery of HMAS Sydney is also covered,the artwork is fine apart from the digital merchant type ships that do not look real,warships are ok though.
55 comments1 of 1 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 16 July 2014
1st class service
0Comment0 of 1 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)
  -  
Cruise in Luxury on Our Top-Rated Ships. Browse Itineraries Today!