Shop now Shop now Shop now  Up to 50% Off Fashion  Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Listen in Prime Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars61
4.5 out of 5 stars
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
All history students are subject to inevitable essay question whether the British Empire was a dynamic benevolent force for good or a monstrous imperial atrocity imposed with gunboat diplomacy? Anyone reading Jeremy Paxman's recent tome "Empire: What Ruling the World Did to the British" will inevitably fall into the latter camp as he mounts a well written but ill-tempered critique of the Empire and its legacy which is explicit in emphasizing how generally awful it was for those who came into contact with it. Perhaps a more scholarly if slightly less readable approach comes in this excellent book by John Darwin "Unfinished Empire" which is revisionist in the sense that it questions the strict dichotomy of heartless British rulers on the one side and colonial victims on the other. Darwin has been treading these boards in previous books. But here he gives full vent to the thesis that it is a myth to speak of "A British Empire" when, in fact, the governing characteristics was a system that was contradictory, tangled, messy and very short lived. Therefore to speak of some strategic "Imperial Project" is a complete misnomer. As he points out "even in 1914, the Colonial Office contained only 30 senior officials who were ostensibly in charge of 100 different colonial spaces, not to mention 600 quasi-autonomous Indian princely states that technically owed allegiance to the British crown". In this respect, therefore, this book could be more accurately subtitled "Empire by hotchpotch" with free trade providing the only really coherent unifying theme. The consequence of this was that "it was largely a private enterprise empire, the creation of merchants, investors, migrants and missionaries amongst many others"

Studying how the Empire developed in India, Ireland, Africa versus the Americas, Australia, and Canada, for example, shows entirely different models of British rule largely provisional and improvised. Most English-speaking Canadians and New Zealander settlers would have seen the process has an "empire of partners". In other parts of the global map the wistful cliché that "the sun never set" on the Empire should not disguise the fact that it did witness astonishing levels of violence and cultural racism. Richard Gott has pointed to Britain's use of "terror by example" such as the brutal treatment of sepoy mutineers at Manjee in 1764, where it was ordered that they should be "shot from guns"; a terrible warning to others not to step out of line. Moving into the sorry story of British rule in Ireland would throw up even worse horrors. Darwin is certainly no apologist for this, but he is keen to explore why the textures of Empire held together with such resilience and held off challenges from other equally aggressive European nations. This he believes was a testimony to a range of "qualities", not least the underpinning foundation of British imperialism which was its "extraordinary versatility in method, outlook, and object." In particular, the British excelled at recruiting local elites and interest groups as collaborators without whose consent little would have been possible. This, more than all the boastful talk of "enlightened reform and disinterested trusteeship", was at the heart of British rule and more accurately explains its extraordinary grip on countries the sheer size of India, where the resources of Empire were almost deployed by a skeleton staff.

Andrew Roberts the conservative historian in reviewing this book concluded that "Darwin's book might at long last herald the victory of the post-Marxist phase of imperial historiography, and not a moment too soon". This reviewer is not so certain about Roberts schadenfreude not least since Darwin's emphasis on the role of free trade could readily appeal to supporters of Karl Marx as a step towards the formation of a bourgeoisie. In the last analysis, Darwin's book is a cool, logical and well-argued case. Its central thesis that rather than being "constituted by empire" for Britain's Empire was "only a phase, an exceptional moment" is neatly provocative. Winston Churchill certainly wouldn't have agreed with that sentiment and for generations of British politicians, particularly in the Victorian age, the "Empire" was a humongous source of national pride which appeared to beguile any rational analysis. Darwin has done a service here putting it into more subtle and sophisticated context and unlike some of the more radical revisionist historians he makes no attempt to take the Empire's fall and dress it up as a ​victory. Recommended
0Comment|27 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
VINE VOICEon 28 November 2012
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
I thought that this book might be fairly interesting to read: I was wrong! It is one of the best books that I have read all year.

Like many people. either born in Britain, or with an interest in British history, I had a passing knowledge of the main events affecting the UK from the 17th to 21st centuries: I knew about Suez, the World Wars, Trafalgar, the Battle of the Nile, Invasion of and expulsion from the United States and other incidents that have helped to shape this great country of ours. Where this book is so useful, is that it stitches these historical events into a single fabric.

John Darwin is above turning this story into a political diatribe, either in favour, or against the British Empire; rather, he shows how, through happen-stance, as often as shrewd political calculation, events conspired to allow the creation of an extraordinarily elastic empire. He also gives a plausible, although he is the first to admit, not necessarily a definitive explanation of its decline. So many authors, nowadays, make the fatal mistake of judging the past by the moral codes of today. Mr Darwin avoids this trap by the simple expediency of not judging at all. He merely relates the story, the reader is free to insert his/her own opinion on the rights and wrongs of the situation.

I find this type of history absolutely fascinating: after all, if one does not understand how we got to where we currently stand, how can we make valid decisions as to where we should be heading? I thought that I would enjoy it, I did not expect it to be quite so "unputdownable". Anyone with political aspirations, an interest in British and world history, or indeed anyone able to appreciate a darned well written book NEEDS to read this. Definitely high upon my top ten books of the year!
0Comment|36 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
I've read several books about the British Empire, and found them something of a struggle, as I'm not particularly captivated by the subject. However, I was pleasantly surprised by this effort, which I found to be a generally good read. It didn't venture into the excessive detail of some books which some books on Empire have done (and I'm thinking in particular of Niall Ferguson's and Piers Brendon's efforts here) but looking at the wider picture of Empire, mixing facts and anecdotes in well laid out in rounded chapters. It covers history impartial as you can be an issue that still raises controversy, even as the last generation involved with the Empire passes away and Britain faces a multicultural future largely brought about as a consequence of Empire. It looks in its various chapters about how the Empire came into being, how it ran, the basis of its existence, the challenges it faces and how it met its end. Darwin both looks at the benefits that the Empire brought to Britain, as well as the injustices that were perpetrated, and the methods, ultimately backed by force, that were used even when the emphasis was on trade. He also, unusually, puts the Empire into historical context, i.e. by acknowledging that Empires have always exist, and very likely to continue (through economic or soft power methods), or will undergo some form of revival in the future as new countries come to the fore that might not feel so hidebound by western colonial guilt. Like many histories of Empire, it understands that there was no project as such, and that the Empire came into being and was held together by an set of exceptional circumstances that Britain took advantage of, and which when it ended also brought with it the end of Empire.

In summary I would say this is a good read and would benefit both the student of Imperial studies and the development of the modern world but also the interested layman.
0Comment|5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
The properly deserved pedigree of prize-winning author John Darwin is beyond doubt as a highly respected historian and expert on the rise and fall of empires. His latest book `Unfinished Empire' embraces the British Empire from medieval English ambitions, through the golden age of British imperialism, up to decolonization after World War II. The detail and depth of scholarly input is endorsed by the comprehensive `Notes', the specialised suggestions for `Further Reading', and the meticulous `Index'. After an introductory `Preface' the main content of `Unfinished Empire' examines ideas and options for rule, and presents the core activities of making contact and taking possession with provision for war and suppression, administrative arrangements, legal procedures and operating trade with pragmatic tactics on converts and cultures. With shifts along the way, and with defining moments, this continues through to ending of empire.

Narrative is crammed with facts and figures and often comes across as piecemeal with a degree of repetition, as instead of a linear style there is reliance on a series of themes that are somewhat convoluted. Perhaps it is geared more to academics rather than lay readers, but there is much to expand the knowledge and understanding of those limited to the usual school text approach of the Armada, Clive of India, Nelson at Trafalgar etc. or more modern commentaries on home rule in Ireland, the Suez crisis etc. Instead of a swashbuckling strategy with gunboats up the river John Darwin outlines more complicated situations with colonization involving traders, investors, immigrants, missionaries etc. as possibly more meaningful than the military and politicians. His subject is huge yet the author seeks always to allow his readers to reach their own conclusions whilst remaining neutral with analyses and explanations. In addition to descriptive enlightening text on the various forms of colonization he outlines multi-sided arguments giving insights to positive merits and benefits of the British Empire balanced with references to the negative effects of exploitation and the often brutal acts under British rule. `Unfinished Empire' may not be an easy read, but it is rewarding - and thought provoking.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 9 October 2012
A beautifully written and well researched explanation of the rise and fall of the British Empire. Darwin describes how Britain acquired the largest empire the world has ever known. Then Darwin concludes why in logical argument. The hyperbole that other writers on empire seem to find necessary is refreshingly absent. Darwin is not afraid of condemning the worst excesses, or of praising the success of British rule, but is careful to put them into context. This is a very readable book that should appeal to both academic and interested laymen alike.
0Comment|20 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
VINE VOICEon 19 March 2013
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
This is a well-researched piece of academic exploration of how the British Empire rose and fell. This is not a dry academic treatment, but designed and explained so that non-academic can read this large undertaking. There is a vivid description of how Britain acquired the largest empire the world has ever known. The author does condemn some of the more terrible things done under the premise of `Empire', but he also comments on the positives that enabled relatively small groups to control vast areas of the globe, but these statements are couched in the circumstance of the time and place. This is a work that is an important read to both academics and non- academics a like. Well worth a four star rating.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
VINE VOICEon 14 May 2013
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
I found the first few pages hard going, but perseverance was richly rewarded. Darwin's book is cleverly structured so that though there is to some extent a chronological narrative thread running through it, it is mainly organised thematically; so, for example, there is a chapter on the problems raised by having to defend the empire, one on the different forms of government that were applied in different territories and another on trade, as well as a chapter on the end of empire. That may mean it is not the ideal book for a complete newcomer to the history of the empire, but for someone with a little existing knowledge it was a great way to get into some very thought-provoking analysis.
Darwin emphasises the diversity of empire and the lack of central planning. His book is a great antidote to one-sided views of the empire as either the bringer of civilisation to backward countries or a pure machine for exploitation. It also makes one reflect on how much Britain itself has been shaped by the imperial experience.
And Darwin reminds the reader how recently the empire was a reality that many thought would continue indefinitely. Darwin argues that even after the "geostrategic disaster of 1940-42" it was not obvious that the empire must be lost. Into the late 1950s the orthodox view was that Britain's future prosperity lay in trade with the empire and commonwealth, not Europe. That may prompt readers to reflect on what might have been.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 March 2013
This is an excellent book.

I am of the view that the history of the largest empire the world has ever seen has to hold lessons for all of us, both in terms of successes and failure. In the this context, Darwin takes a refreshingly even handed approach - he does not eulogise but nor does he demonise. He appears to be able to rationally reflect on the elastic nature of how the Empire came about (and certainly the acqusition, formation and ruling of individual Colonies could be and were vastly different), why it succeeded or did not succeed in various regions, what can be considered positive achievments and what were the negative consequences of British hegemony.

I have to say I don't always agree with all his conclusions, but that is the point of this book - it is there to make you think.

The final observation I would make is that one also can't view certain actions through the prism of modern sensibilities; what was done tended to reflect the cultural norms of the moment and just as God was an Englishman to those from London, I have no doubt he was also a Frenchman if you were from Paris or Russian if you were from Moscow - in short, the astonishing hubris of those who built the British Empire and the ingenuity and flexibility with which they did so is one the the more fascinating thematics of this marvellous book.

A splendid read.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
VINE VOICEon 19 March 2013
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
This is a superb book. The scale of Darwin's subject - an empire that arguably lasted 500 years and spanned every time zone on the planet - is so vast that you would think that any single volume account would have to be filled with generalizations and glossing overs, but what Darwin has achieved is a through, comprehensive, well argued and highly readable masterpiece.

I know very little about the Empire in India or Africa but, twenty-five years ago, I studied under several of New Zealand's leading historians of empire and colonization (three of whom are cited in this book - in particular Jamie Belich, whose Replenishing the Earth: The Settler Revolution and the Rise of the Angloworld is well worth reading) and have maintained an interest in the topic ever since. As a result I know a reasonable amount about the New Zealand part of this story and Darwin's grip on the details of even that very small part of his overall canvas is impressive and makes me trust the rest of what he says.

Possibly the biggest achievement of this book is that it manages to strike a sensible (and in my view, correct) middle ground between the rabid triumphant jingoism of most conservatives' view of the Empire (eg Niall Ferguson) and the self-lacerating Marxist view that nothing good came out of the process.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
VINE VOICEon 21 February 2013
Format: Hardcover|Vine Customer Review of Free Product( What's this? )
Britain's withdrawal from the world stage has been a long-drawn out process. The Victorian maps of the world, resplendent in British pink in every corner, now seem quaint relics. The narrative we have inherited from those times is of a relentless, machine-like acquisition of land, all supporting the greater glory of a nation at the centre of world events. Darwin's fascinating and wide-ranging survey shows that, actually, the British hegemony was achieved largely through a series of accidents, without any master plan. He charts the development of empire, and, importantly, its continuing presence in the discourse of the state. Even now, with just a few scraps remaining of the empire on which the sun never set, there is still, as Darwin shows, a yearning for the old certainties, and an unwillingness to let it go completely. Darwin charts the rise and fall in a measured, judicious and beautifully clear account that covers this complex and contested history in magisterial style.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)