Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop All Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now DIYED Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Oasis Listen with Prime Learn more Shop Men's Shop Women's

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5 stars4
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 star
4
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
0
Format: Audio CD|Change
Price:£82.38+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

Your rating(Clear)Rate this item
Share your thoughts with other customers

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 9 July 2012
Smithsonian-Folkways have issued this tribute to Woody Guthrie to celebrate his birth 100 years ago this year. A fine tribute it is too: a lavishly produced 150 page hard back book, designed rather like a LP album, with three CD's inserted.
The book is beautifully designed with many illustrations: photographs of Woody Guthrie and others, many reproductions of his drawings and paintings, letters to and from him, manuscripts of his songs and of record labels and sleeves. The display of these sleeves is particularly attractive. There are essays by Robert Santelli about Woody Guthrie's life and by Archivist Jeff Place on his music and recordings. There are detailed notes on the songs, a list of available recordings and an extensive discography. There are a few errors and omissions apparent only to the dedicated discographer: the harmonica on Hard Travelin' is played by Woody himself and not Sonny Terry and the Rounder important My Dusty Road collection is not mentioned.
The three CD's exhibit a comprehensive collection of Woody Guthrie's recording over his whole career from his very first recordings in 1939 to one of his last in 1951, when he is showing signs of the tragic disease which would eventually end his life. They were mostly - but by no means all - recorded by Moses Asch, of Asch, Disc and Folkways records, whose catalogue the Smithsonian fortunately bought on Asch's death. Here we hear Woody alone and with Cisco Houston, Lead Belly and Sonny Terry singing folk songs, children's songs and his own compositions.
Of the forty-five titles on discs 1 and 2 all except one, a children's song, have been released before on CD, the majority by Smithsonian-Folkways themselves - and then sometimes more than once. Three come from Library of Congress recordings and one, which is of great interest, from a very expensive Bear collection of CD's and book. Seven of these titles were issued recently by Rounder in their My Dusty Road collection and I have to say that these releases, having been taken from the metal masters, are clearer than the Smithsonian-Folkways releases.
Disc 1 and 2 may not be anything new for the avid Woody Guthrie collector but disc 3 certainly will be: this is a true gem! Only two titles have been released before, both children's songs and both on 78 recordings only, never on CD. We are fortunate that Moses Asch recorded radio programmes and here are several to allow us to hear what Woody sounded like over the airwaves. Another item (Reckless Talk) is added from the Woody & Cisco 1944 sessions recorded by Asch; to me these are an unbeatable series of recordings. Two sets are of particular note: Woody's very first known recordings in 1939, which were possibly demos he made himself and a series of four titles he broadcast on Children's Hour for the BBC in 1944. The wonderfully plumy voiced BBC announcer who introduces him, doesn't seem to know quite what to make of Woody Guthrie and the songs he sang!
Listening to these songs again makes me feel that, although the times that Woody Guthrie lived through are long gone, the songs he wrote are still fresh and sadly relevant today: songs of greedy bankers, greedy landlords, unemployment, poverty and social injustice; all written with his observant eye and bitter humour. I wonder what he would have sung today.
0Comment|17 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 August 2012
I notice Amazon don't bother with track listing on a lot of stuff these days so here it is:

Cd1
1. This Land Is Your Land (Alternate Version) 2:44
2. Pastures Of Plenty 2:25
3. Riding In My Car (Car Song) 1:49
4. The Grand Coulee Dam 2:10
5. Talking Dust Bowl 1:51
6. So Long, It's Been Good To Know Yuh (Dusty Old Dust) 3:40
7. Ramblin' Round 2:14
8. Philadelphia Lawyer 2:28
9. Hard Travelin' 2:31
10. Pretty Boy Floyd 3:00
11. Hobo's Lullaby 2:23
12. Talking Columbia 2:28
13. The Sinking Of The Reuben James 3:00
14. Jesus Christ 2:37
15. Gypsy Davy 2:49
16. New York Town 2:35
17. Going Down The Road (Feeling Bad) 2:56
18. Hard, Ain't It Hard 2:42
19. The Biggest Thing That Man Has Ever Done (The Great Historical Bum) 2:17
20. This Land Is Your Land (Standard Version) 2:16
21. Jarama Valley 2:52
22. Why, Oh Why? 3:27
23. I've Got To Know 5:32

Cd2
1. Better World A-Comin' 3:05
2. When That Great Ship Went Down (The Great Ship) 3:17
3. A Dollar Down And A Dollar A Week 1:35
4. Talking Centralia 3:24
5. 1913 Massacre 3:35
6. Dirty Overalls 1:55
7. My Daddy (Flies A Ship In The Sky) 2:33
8. Worried Man Blues 2:58
9. Hangknot, Slipknot 2:30
10. Buffalo Skinners 2:16
11. Howdi Do 1:40
12. Jackhammer John 2:36
13. The Ranger's Command 2:49
14. So Long, It's Been Good To Know You (Wwii Version) 2:45
15. What Are We Waiting On? 2:07
16. Lindbergh 3:10
17. Ludlow Massacre 3:28
18. Bad Lee Brown (Cocaine Blues) 2:14
19. Two Good Men 3:45
20. Farmer-Labor Train 2:49
21. The Jolly Banker 2:50
22. We Shall Be Free 3:01

Cd3
The Los Angeles Recordings
1. I Ain't Got No Home (In This World Anymore)* 3:26
2. Them Big City Ways** 2:27
3. Do Re Mi* 3:33
4. Skid Row Serenade** 3:00
5. Radio Program :
The Ballad Gazette With Woody Guthrie 14:20

This Land Is Your Land*
What Did The Deep Sea Say?*
Blow Ye Winds*
Trouble On The Waters**
Blow The Man Down
Normandy Was Her Name**
The Sinking Of The Reuben James*

6. Children's Hour July 7, 1944 10:19

Intro-Wabash Cannonball*
900 Miles*
Stagger Lee*
Pretty Boy Floyd*

7. People's Songs Hootenanny 8:53

Ladies Auxiliary
Weaver's Life*

8. WNYC Radio Program: Folk Songs Of America December 12, 1940 16:24
John Hardy*
Jesse James*
Tom Joad*

9. Reckless Talk** 1:42
10. All Work Together 2:39
11. My Little Seed 2:30
12. Goodnight Little Cathy** 2:20

* Previously Unreleased
** Previously Unreleased Original Song
0Comment|6 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 6 August 2012
Within the last 5 years there's been a plethora of Woody Guthrie even one called Bob Dylan's Woody Guthrie Favorites.There's the Proper Box,the Folkways recordings issued in a suitcase,there's the Almanac Singers,the Weavers and the tributes as well as the 3CD set by Billy Bragg.
But the big attraction here is the thick book inside the box.
Clearly Woody Guthrie is now for the rich collector.
For anyone loathe to pay over £50 for mainly stuff thats been issued many times there IS a £2 10 track sampler with the same sleeve and the Elizabeth Mitchell song Little Seed
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 March 2013
Excellent package of Woody material.
Arrived on time blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah 4 more words required
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)