Customer Reviews


3 Reviews
5 star:
 (1)
4 star:
 (2)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 
Most Helpful First | Newest First

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Very good, but perhaps not the sublime experience of previous discs, 4 Aug 2012
By 
Sid Nuncius (London) - See all my reviews
(TOP 10 REVIEWER)    (No. 1 Hall OF FAME REVIEWER)   
This review is from: Mouton: Missa Tu Es Petrus (Hyperion: CDA67933) (Audio CD)
I largely agree with Stephen Midgely's excellent review here. This is another lovely disc from the Brabant Ensemble who continue to rummage in the dusty forgotten corners of the Renaissance repertoire and keep unearthing gems there. Mouton's sublime motet Nesciens mater is deservedly well known and has been recorded a number of times. I'm not sure that I quite share Stephen's unalloyed enthusiasm for the rest of the music, though. It is very good, and the mass setting is a fine one, but I can't say that overall it moves me in quite the same way as, say, their discs of Phinot or Moulu do.

I wonder whether this is also to do with the performance. I fully expected to be writing another unequivocally enthusiastic review of the singing because the Brabants have been fantastic on every disc they've made. Here they still sing very beautifully and are as ever technically flawless, but (and this may just be me) I don't get quite the sense of engagement with the text or the wonderful spirituality which permeates their other discs. I have other versions of Nesciens mater and particularly the one on John Eliot Gardiner's wonderful Pilgrimage to Santiago disc Gardiner: Pilgrimage to Santiago has a limpid, transporting tenderness about it which isn't quite present here.

The notes, presentation and recorded sound are all, as always, excellent and I am sorry to have gone on and to have sounded critical - this is still a five star disc for me and one which I will play with pleasure for many years, I am sure. It's just that for me it's not quite in the five-star-plus category of most of the Brabants' previous discs, but please don't let me out you off - I'd still recommend it warmly.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


9 of 10 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Stunning Mouton mass, 2 Jun 2012
By 
Stephen Midgley (Tarbrax, West Calder, UK) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Mouton: Missa Tu Es Petrus (Hyperion: CDA67933) (Audio CD)
First of all, this is fabulous music. Jean Mouton, one of a number of outstanding Franco-Flemish contemporaries of the incomparable Josquin, has been poorly served on disc until now - apart from the justifiably much-loved motet "Nesciens mater". That piece makes a fine start to the present disc - with one small reservation which I'll come back to at the end - and it's then followed by a programme of equally fine works which, as far as I know, have never previously been recorded.

The most impressive of these is undoubtedly the Missa Tu es Petrus. This 5-voice cantus firmus mass is an extremely beautiful work in both melody and texture. The clarity of its counterpoint and the radiant, soaring lines remind me a little of Clemens non Papa, one of my own favourites; and yet somehow the result is quite different, for Mouton has a very distinctive manner of his own. Here the voices weave graceful garlands around the chant theme as the composer, far from being in any way restricted by the cantus firmus format, allows himself remarkable freedom to develop his inspired melodic ideas. Moreover this adventurous music, with its starkly prominent lines, is most beautifully delivered by the Brabant Ensemble, singing two voices to a part. This mass is altogether a splendid and inspired work, and truly there is not a single dull moment as it receives a vigorous, committed and profoundly musical interpretation from Stephen Rice and his excellent singers.

There are plenty more treasures in this fascinating and well-organised programme. In addition to "Nesciens mater" there are three other fine 8-voice motets. These include the majestic state motet "Exsultet coniubilando" - a good example of the tendency among many composers, both in renaissance times and after, to produce some of their noblest-sounding pieces when in grovel mode, that is to say when composing music in praise of some earthly potentate - in this case presumed to be Pope Leo X. Whatever the motivation, the result is lovely, as is the following sacred piece "Verbum bonum et suave".

After Mouton's beautiful Mass, the disc ends with two fascinating and characterful motets - both in four voices, but here with the usual 2VPP arrangement understandably supplemented by an extra voice to each part. I say 'understandably' in view of their subject matter; the first, "Bona vita, bona refectio" encourages listeners to eat, drink and have a jolly good time, with the help of a text conveniently providing the clerical audience with a righteous excuse for doing so. It's a joyful, enthusiastic piece, sung here with all the panache you could wish for. Finally, "Factum est silentium", despite this innocuous first line of text, is about the battle between St Michael and the dragon and the heavenly onlookers' reactions to it. It's a vivid and exciting piece, with splendid homophonic passages accentuating the drama; and once again it's superbly sung here.

This programme, then, is another brilliant contribution to the renaissance discography from the Brabant Ensemble. As for questions of sound and clarity, I take fellow reviewer E. L. Wisty's point about a certain thickness of texture at times, which I noticed especially in the opening item but which didn't really bother me after that, and least of all in the Mass. Perhaps this is because there are other fine recordings of the beautiful "Nesciens" motet for comparison, which of course is not the case with any of the other works; or maybe I just got used to it. In any case I'm not sure that I would want to blame it on the singers or on their 2VPP format, which I find works pretty well for them as it does for several other eminent early-music ensembles; I think the acoustic and/or recording arrangements are just as likely to be responsible. But, for me at least, this characteristic - which you may or may not consider a flaw depending on your taste - is far outweighed by the fact that Stephen Rice and his ensemble have brought us a programme of rare and wonderful music and, what's more, in superbly crafted and committed performances. I really must stress again the extraordinary quality of the Tu es Petrus mass. In his excellent booklet notes Dr. Rice tells us that it's just one of Mouton's fifteen surviving mass settings. As far as I know only two of these, including the present one, have ever been available on disc; so, if the others are anywhere near as fine as this, will somebody please bring us some more?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Egregious?, 30 May 2012
By 
E. L. Wisty "World Domination League" (Devon, UK) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (VINE VOICE)   
This review is from: Mouton: Missa Tu Es Petrus (Hyperion: CDA67933) (Audio CD)
Stephen Rice in his accompanying notes concludes by describing Jean Mouton as being "in the best sense, egregious". This seems like a not unreasonable claim on the basis of the music presented here. Whilst the historical significance of Mouton has been acknowledged - he was in the service of Anne of Brittany and Pope Leo X, as well as being teacher to Adrian Willaert - his music is rarely performed, and the Brabant Ensemble here continue their mission of recording some of the less familiar Franco-Flemish composers of the 16th century.

The disc begins with Mouton's four eight-part motets, grandiose constructions indeed; the canonic pieces Nesciens Mater and Ave Maria Gemma Virginum; the triple-texted Exsultet Coniubilando with two cantus firmi; and Verbum Bonum Et Suave, one of the longest and most elaborate motets of the time. The title piece is Mouton's only five part Mass out of the fifteen masses he composed. The disc is completed with two four part motets - Factum Est Silentium on the fight of the archangel Michael with a dragon, and the curious Bona Vita Bona Refectio whose words call priests to what sounds like a rather agreeable meal.

But what of the egregiousness of the Brabant Ensemble themselves? I have often thought the sound quality of their recordings a little deficient, diffuse and lacking textual clarity, unsure as to whether this might be an acoustic problem, or else simply that the doubling up of voices lacks a certain tuning. Well here I think we have a clue. In the Missa Tu Es Petrus, the Benedictus is sung by three solo voices, in this case the three Ashby sisters who are regulars of the ensemble. I can only say: what an improvement, and no concomitant loss of dynamic. It only leads me to the feeling that the Brabants are not really as successful with the doubled voices as some ensembles. I would love to hear what Rice could do by slashing his personnel in half.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Mouton: Missa Tu Es Petrus (Hyperion: CDA67933)
Mouton: Missa Tu Es Petrus (Hyperion: CDA67933) by The Brabant Ensemble (Audio CD - 2012)
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews