Top critical review
16 people found this helpful
Not bad for the price, but make sure you're not relying on features that don't work that well
on 17 June 2013
Over the past 3 years I've had the Edimax IC-1310 working in my home without many problems. It's great to be able to monitor the house when I'm away & know that I'll not have any nasty surprises when I get back.. well at least from a living room point-of-view.
The Foscam range of webcams caught my eye, specifically the FI8910W which can use a wireless network connection, and is steerable. I like the fact that this gives it a lot of placement flexibility.. just needing a power source & off it goes. This newer model has an IR-Cut filter which gives better colour reproduction from it's predecessor. I paid about £65 for the white version from the official UK-based Foscam distributor.
Initial setup of the camera is supposed to include you installing some Windows app to find the camera's IP address on your network; my router gives me a list of connected devices, so I chose to forego the app and use the router's info instead. I could log into the camera once I had it's IP address, and configured it to connect over wifi, altering a few other settings as I went (disabling the DDNS service, since my Edimax camera is already updating dyndns.org with my externally visible IP).
As long as you're used to fiddling with things like port forwarding you'll have everything set up within 10-15 minutes; there's not a lot to it & these days it's handy to have a phone on 3G to check things are working correctly. I added a few extra user accounts, and had TinyCam Monitor for Android working in no time at all.. specifying the local network IP on the main settings, and the DynDNS address on the extra 3G settings page.
Being able to steer the camera is really handy.. when you have it pointing in the right direction, you can save it as a preset, both from your browser, or from an app like TinyCam Monitor. I've set mine to mostly look out of the back window, but can swivel it round to look into the kitchen & hallway.. even up to the skylights, etc.
The quality of the images is pretty decent, but at 640x480, they're not extactly HD quality. Motion detection is a tad limited.. even compared to my 3yr old Edimax. There's no way to specify zones for motion detection, and it only uploads 2 .jpeg files for each motion capture event (the Edimax can upload 5 second videos!).
Annoyingly, even if you turn off the IR LEDs, they'll switch back on the next time the camera is rebooted.. which is a real pain when the camera is looking out of a window (you only see the bright glare of the LEDs shining back at you!). Hopefully that'll get fixed in a future firmware update, but I'm not betting on it. Talking of firmware, make sure you upgrade it.. the latest versions include some (unspecified) security fixes.
UPDATE; a few months on & I'm getting annoyed by the camera rebooting itself a few times each day. There's no guarantee it'll be online when you want to view it, and the IR LED option defaults back to On each time, which adds to the annoyance factor. Dropping this to a 3-star rating.. almost a 2!