Most Helpful First | Newest First
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Karajan's 1977 Brahms Cycle - Towards an Appraisal,
Schumann once described Beethoven's Fourth Symphony as a slender Greek Maiden between two Norse Giants - that's crap if you ask me but even so: the adage lives on. Similarly, Karajan's 1978 Brahms cycle could be likened to a middle child; it has always suffered by comparison with the superlative '63 cycle - not least sonically - whereas the '86-88 cycle has attracted attention because of the performances of the last two symphonies where fatigue beset both the conductor and his orchestra. Elsewhere, Osborne fails to mention this cycle in his biography on Karajan: the silence is telling.
Nor does the Original Image Bit Processing overly revamp the performances. I had the original CDs and there is no marked improvement. In certain instances, the sound is still pancake flat. More on that later.
But what of the interpretations themselves? Karajan was well known for ossifying an interpretation once it had been settled in his mind - even so, the wind blows where it wills - or not.
First, an overarching point: the Berlin Philharmonic play magnificently. At this point in time, they had as much thrust as a Saturn V Rocket. They are almoners of ecstasy. If anyone could have kept up with Furtwangler in the Brahms Third, it was the line-up of the Berlin Phil that Herbie used for this performance of the Second.
Everyone knows that Three is hard to pull off. There is an exquisite ambiguity in the first movement: is it an exposition of power or valediction? The Gramophon is normally caustic towards Karajan in the Third but they hail this performance "as satisfyingly virile and forthright reading. There is no exposition repeat, but the first movement is in every other respect conveyed in masterly fashion . . . . Throughout the work, in fact, the music's pulse beats pretty strongly." I agree. Much like the contemporary Schubert Ninth on EMI - a work which he likewise labored over - Karajan threw caution to the wind and let fly. It may not displace the Furtwangler in the last analysis but my god it is a thumper. The first violins cut through the choppiness of Brahms' passagework like the prow of a Greek trireme.
Little needs to said of this Second. Karajan is a master in this work. Not one of his performances on disc is anything less than superlative. Just listen to the last movement - it is virtuosity incarnate. Not even Furtwangler surpassed Herbie in this symphony. The only rival is the '86 remake Brahms: Symphony No. 2 / Haydn Variations.
There is not a lot wrong with the First here. It is frequently beaten with a stick to the effect that Karajan was fresher in the '63 alternative. If so, it's marginal. The leitmotiv of the work `per ardua ad astra' (through Adversity to the Stars) is fully encompassed in the finale. The heaviness of the orchestration is clarified. Much like the Second, Karajan was always a master of this symphony, his one relative failure being the mushy version he recorded with the Vienna Philharmonic in the early 1960s. His last two renditions - one studio in 1987 (Brahms: Symphony No. 1) and one live in 1988 (Brahms: Symphony No. 1; Schoenberg: Verklärte Nacht) - are craggily prophetic like Michelangelo's statue of Moses.
The real problem with this set - and it is a relative one - comes with the Fourth. The two inner movements are fine. In the last movement, the intensity dips - and the same could be said of the first movement. Both Furtwangler (Brahms: Symphony No. 4; Haydn Variations / Furtwängler) and Kleiber are faster and more ferocious than Karajan and that adds to the drama. All in all, this is a compelling performance of the Fourth but a Sibylline utterance it ain't.
Back to the sound. This is going to sound unsophisticated in the extreme but the answer is this: crank it up. Yep, just turn it up and blow your speakers. For whatever reason these performances shed most - if not all - of any flatness at a high volume. And it also evangelizes unbelievers in the vicinity.
In short, this is a top notch cycle. It may be harder and more brutal than the '63 cycle but Brahms can withstand this approach.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars I'll stick with my 1960s version,
Living with, and loving, the Brahms 1st and 2nd recorded by von Karajan in the 1960s I thought I would see what he did in the 70s. The later ones are good, but I feel that in the 1960s version (all with Berlin PO and DGG} he has a greater control on the ensemble playing and just that bit more searching interpretation throughout. Please yourself - at these prices one can afford to have different versions.
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Herbert von Karajan's 1970s Berlin Philharmoniker Brahms Symphonies,
Herbert von Karajan made recordings of the Brahm's Symphonies many times through his long career and this Deutsche Grammophon 2-CD set contains what, by common consensus, is regarded as the most successful set. I'm not so sure about that, as I often find with this particular conductor that the earlier the recording, the better. This late analogue set does sound superb in it's CD incarnation, but I suspect that the original LPs sounded even better.
What I can be clear about is that this 1970s set is more impressive than the late digital set Karajan made Brahms: The 4 Symphonies, although the version of the fourth symphony in that particular set is the same as the one here as, for some reason (probably the congested sound quality), the DDD Brahms 4 was not included in the later compilation Brahms;Symphony No.4.
In 1943, Karajan recorded Brahms 1 with the Concertgebouw Orchestra, a magnificent, tension-filled, recording in subfusc sound Symphony No. 1/Leonore Overture No. 3/Salome (Von Karajan). Then, in 1949, at the instigation of EMI's Walter Legge, Karajan recorded Brahms 2 with the Vienna Philharmoniker on 78s, a performance I really rate highly Brahms: Symphony No. 2 / Strauss: Metamorphosen / Mozart: Masonic Funeral Music.
After that, Karajan recorded Symphonies 1, 2, and 4 for HMV with the Philharmonia Orchestra, a crack ensemble at the time, in quite mellow performances now available in EMI's massive Karajan box set Karajan: The Complete EMI Recordings Vol. 1. These records are very much worth hearing despite the slightly restricted mono sound. Symphony 3 was left to Karajan's Decca contract Dvorak: Symphony No.8 / Brahms: Symphony No.3, then he was off to Deutsche Grammophon for his early 1960s recordings Brahms: Symphony 2, 3 Brahms: Symphony No.1, perhaps the best of the lot in good early stereo.
Whichever set of Brahms symphonies from Herbert von Karajan you choose, and this set would be an excellent choice, you can be assured that he was, undoubtedly, a great Brahmsian conductor.
43 of 54 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars top class recording,
The most impressive thing for me listening to the 3rd Symphony, was the superb sound quality of this recording. The discs have been specially processed to enhance the depth of the orchestra and this works a treat. An excellent value purchase.
75 of 97 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Masterful recordings,
By A Customer
I recall that my first boxed set of Brahms symphonies on vinyl in the late 70's was this von Karajan and Berlin Philharomic recording, days when Bohm and von Karajan dominated the DG label. Since then I have had various CD recordings, buying one symphony at a time, before the days of CD boxed sets. The Halle with Stanislaw Skrowaczewski - fine budget recordings that should be re-released, the 1st with Solti/Chicago Symphony and the 2nd with Bernstein/Vienna Philharmonic, great full sound recordings. Latterly, in order to have a DDD boxed set, I bought Harnoncourt with the Berlin Philharmonic, which comes along with the Academic and Tragic Overtures and Haydn variations. Sadly, though very skilled performances I had to exchange these because of the incesssant coughing from one person in the audience who should have stayed at home. So, I am back to the safe recording of Brahms symphonies that I originally had on vinyl - bravo Karajan.
5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant versions of brilliant music,
Brilliant! Delivered well within the estimate and well packaged as you'd expect. Love the music.
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Complete Symphonies Nos: 1 - 4 of Johannes Brahms,
This review is from: Brahms: The Complete Symphonies / Karajan, Berlin PO (Audio CD)
I particularly like the classical musical compositions of Johannes Brahms and would not hesitate to recommend this particular two CD set to anyone in search of a reasonable, if not actually bargain priced (@ £8.80 inc p&p) version of these four superb symphonies. Incidentally, fyi Nos.1 & 3 appear on disc one and Nos.2 & 4 are to be found on disc two.
As others have commented previously, this recording was originally mastered wholly in the analogue domain and is all the better for that. There is none of the 'glassy harshness' that regrettably tended to afflict numerous early digital recordings which were produced during the first decades of that era. I distinctly remember Philips proud advertising boast when CD's first became available of 'perfect sound forever'.....hmmm, we shall have to see about that one....!!!
I say this as someone who over the years has had the good fortune to experiment with using numerous expensive and well-respected high-end condenser capacitor microphones, both valve, transistor and some even digital. I cannot for obvious reasons get involved in naming manufacturers, but have a colleague who purchased a pair of fairly well-respected cardioid mic's a few years ago that the makers described as a (so-called) 'improvement' (over the previous outgoing model) with a claimed extended frequency response (at both ends of the audio spectrum) apparently 'suitable to meet the needs of modern digital recording requirements'. However, in a 'side-by-side' comparison with my earlier original microphones, to the ears of those who have heard the two identical 'takes' switched directly between each other, the 'improved' mic sounds noticeably hard and unnaturally exaggerated. There are clearly good reasons why some classical engineers nowadays still tend to pay thousands of pounds for original vintage valve microphones as well as newer condenser types which are highly revered in the recording industry and for very good reason.
My advice would be to simply buy these discs and enjoy them for many years to come.
5.0 out of 5 stars The recording was perfect. I am about to see / hear it ...,
The recording was perfect. I am about to see / hear it at the Albert Hall Proms and have been delighted to refresh it in my mind before the life performance
5.0 out of 5 stars One of the finest sets of the Brahms symphonies,
One of the finest sets of the Brahms symphonies: gorgeously played by the Berliners with lovely details and an excellent vision from HvK.
5.0 out of 5 stars ... of the Brahms symphonies and you won't find many better recordings. Highly recommended,
Herbert is a expert interpreter of the Brahms symphonies and you won't find many better recordings. Highly recommended.
Most Helpful First | Newest First