Customer Reviews


4 Reviews
5 star:    (0)
4 star:
 (3)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:
 (1)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A modern caesar... almost
I'll start by saying I have read two books by Steven Pressfield prior to this one and loved both. Gates Of Fire remains one of my favourite books and regularly encourage others to do the same, and also found Killing Rommel to be a gripping, if rather short, read. I therefore approached The Profession firm in the knowledge that Pressfield would again tell another geat...
Published on 26 Jun 2011 by J.R.Hartley

versus
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars A little dull
For those of you like me, who thought the "Gates of Fire" was one of the best historical novels ever written and that "Killing Rommel" was a cracking good read, you might be a little disappointed with the latest Pressfield novel.

The book portrays a vision of the future as a mixture of big oil companies, politics and small mercenary armies. So far so good, but...
Published on 4 Aug 2011 by Neil P55


Most Helpful First | Newest First

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars A little dull, 4 Aug 2011
This review is from: The Profession (Kindle Edition)
For those of you like me, who thought the "Gates of Fire" was one of the best historical novels ever written and that "Killing Rommel" was a cracking good read, you might be a little disappointed with the latest Pressfield novel.

The book portrays a vision of the future as a mixture of big oil companies, politics and small mercenary armies. So far so good, but then the main protagonist takes it upon himself to explain to the reader, in 'long-hand', who those power brokers are and how the world has, and continues to change under their political and military influence.

I don't do this often but I gave up on this book three quarters of the way through. In short, I found the book dull. The characters are two dimensional, you just don't care about them, there's no suspense and no thrills. It's more akin to a well researched governmental report on future global power players that the author has struggled to translate into an entertaining novel. Lots of American patriotism, lots of merged companies (Fox/BBC ...), lots of military acronyms, but just no soul.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A modern caesar... almost, 26 Jun 2011
By 
J.R.Hartley (NW England) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Profession (Kindle Edition)
I'll start by saying I have read two books by Steven Pressfield prior to this one and loved both. Gates Of Fire remains one of my favourite books and regularly encourage others to do the same, and also found Killing Rommel to be a gripping, if rather short, read. I therefore approached The Profession firm in the knowledge that Pressfield would again tell another geat tale of honour, brotherhood and military mayhem that makes the likes of Tom Clancy look like he is playing at it. Let's just say that Pressfield does not disappoint in this futureshock tale of a yet-to-be American Caesar in a world where the dominant forces are no longer national governments but where power rests in the hands of media and oil barons. Everything is here from full-blooded battles, scheming powermongers, deceit, murder and love in a blockbuster that has shades of George Orwell and Joseph Conrad. The military research is very impressive and the sheer scale and chutzpah of the novel will leave you in a spin. I ploughed through this book in less than 48 hours.

So why only 4 stars? Well, the main prlem for me was the military research is just a bit too much. I'm all for a detailed explanation of military tactics and descriptions of action sequences, but Pressfield has once again litters his work (just as he did in Kilig Rommel) with entire paragraphs that amount to little more than lists of military hardware. More than that, his descriptions are peppered with acronyms and serial numbers that mean nothing to a non-military person like me. In short, whole paragraphs are pretty tedious. While not doubting Pressfield has spent a lot of time and energy getting the military details just right, some of his other reserch is simply woeful. For example, he mentions the wedding of "Elizabeth and Prince Philip" and dates it to 1956. Now unless I'm very much mistaken he is of course referring to the wedding of Elizabeth II and her consort, Philip... in 1947. Thirty seconds on the internet would have given him the date, just as it did for me. Okay, so it's a minor thing and makes no odds to the story, but it did make me doubt other things he said.

Aside from that, the main character has some love interest that simply lacks all plausibility as she is a 2D stereotype of an ambitious journalist and quite frankly I can't understand what he sees in her as she's vile. All the sections in which she features seem horribly contrived.

The Profession is a good read and raises a few philosophical questions about how far we should let white knights run our lives and how far can we forgive someone we love and respect. Anyone familiar with the tale of Julius Caesar and his complicated relationship with Brutus will know what I mean but I shall say no more for fear of giving away the key aspects of the book. While a good book, the downside is it is not a great book and I have a dread feeling that tells me it will be made into a crash-bang-wallop Hollywood blockbuster that will have rednecks punching the air in joy and make a dimwit movie producer a lot of money while totalling missing the point.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars America in 20 years time?, 9 Jun 2012
By 
JPS - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Profession (Hardcover)
First posted on Amazon.com on 9/06/2012

Another reviewer on Amazon.com has already spotted the several dimensions that this book explores: techno-thriller, military science fiction, a cautionary tale of the future, and, in particular, of America's future more than anything else, but also the personal story of a "lost" soldier who becomes a 21th century mercenary and is torn between what is left of his ideals and his deep sense of loyalty towards his brothers in arms and his commander officer.

The last theme is one that Pressfield has already got us rather used to. You find it in particular in his "Tides of War" and his "The Afghan Campaign". There are even a couple of hints to these pieces of historical fiction in this one, for instance the passing reference to a sergeant named Telamon, from Akadia in the USA - the very same place and name as that of a mercenary solddier that pops up here and there in Pressfiled's novels taking place in Antiquity.

Another familiar element is Pressfield's ability to make the story gripping and ripping, so that, at least at times, it seems almost "real" for the reader, especially for the action and combat scenes. Although, to be honest, I am no soldier, so I could probably not tell to what extent the story is plausible anyway, the way the operations are presented correspond to what I would imagine them to be like.

What is more original for Pressfield, is the story which takes place in 2032, with numerous "flash-backs" of events that have taken place since 2016. The period has seen the rise of Private Military Companies (PMCs) - mercenaries in other words - to the extent that these - and one of them in particular - have become a major force capable of fielding tens of thousands of soldiers. Their major field of operations is the Middle East and they are employed by a range of States and multinational corporations, especially oil companies and large international banks. America seems to have largely pulled back its forces from the Middle East and concentrates on "Homeland Security" after another dreadful terrorist attack on its soil and a highly publicised scandal that has taken place in Africa and has tarnished the reputation of its armed forces and of the US Marine Corp in particular.

Contrary to another reviewer on Amazon.com, I found this geopolitical piece interesting, even if not always entirely convincing or credible. The story is made up of bits pieced together and taken from various conflicts that have taken place since the 1990s, especially in Africa and the Middle East. The story taking place in Zamibia, and its multiple atrocities, for instance, seems to be a cross between the wars and massacres in Liberia and Sierra Leone, with the "long sleeve" and "short sleeve" amputations, in particular, and those that took place in Rwanda and in Congo (ex-ZaÔre, were, despite UN forces, some atrocities still tale place). However, US forces were not deployed in any of these conflicts. Also, existing PMCs are not almost exclusively made up of ex-US soldiers, along with a sprinkling of Brits, Australians and South Africans. Nowadays, they happen to include ex-soldiers coming from a much wider range of countries, including European countries. I won't comment on the weaponry used: another reviewer has done so already. However, that a single PMC would be able, or even allowed, to take over half a dozen others and become a near monopoly seems, for the moment at least, rather unlikely for at least a couple of reasons. Some PMCs are multinational, but many are not and may even be VERY national indeed. More importantly perhaps, governments from so-called rich countries (say the G8 including Russia, to keep it short) have close contacts with, and keep an eye on "their" respective SMCs composed on "their" nationals. This is where the "outsourcing" comes in. Some governments are ready to outsource some functions to the private sector, such as the protection of pipelines or of corporate executives and staff. Others, at least officially, have banned by law such companies altogether. All might use them for deniable operations that have more to do with secret services than waging an open war. In 20 years time, we might have reached a situation familiar to that described by Pressfield. For the moment, we are rather far from this.

Another limit to this book is the theme of America's decline and increasing vulnerability. These are very topical, of course. In the book, however, they may be somewhat overblown and not entirely realistic, although this is not necessarily a problem since the book is fiction. First, I have been hearing sporadically about the decline of the United States for a very long time. I learned in school that there was a decline after the ViÍtnam war. I heard about it again during the 80s (Japan was the menace at the time) and at the end of the 80s, with the Savings and Loans debacle. Then, as the USRR collapsed, I didn't hear about it at all (quite the contrary in fact) for the next 10 years. Since 2000, the next menace is supposed to be China, which is growing about 4 to 5 times faster than America. While true, and while the US has not yet fully recovered (far from it), it is worthwhile remembering that China's GDP is still less than half that of the US and that its population, which is foiur times larger, is ageing very rapidly. Even assuming that China's GDP overtakes that of America in ten years time (a rather big assumption), GDP per head in America will still be four times that of China. So, is this decline? Perhaps, but only in relative terms. It is also a slow one and it may not be as irresistible as it seems.

Finally, there is the US dependance on oil. Oddly enough, Pressfield has not been innovative here. He has not taken into account the latest breakthrough in technology, nor the ones still to come over the next 20 years. He comes up with fuel worth 8 and then 14 dollars a gallon because of events taking place in the Middle East. Interestingly, given the potential for exploiting existing fields both on land and of the US coasts (and without even mentioning whatever oil could be discovered in the next 20 years), America is becoming increasingly self-sufficient with regards oil and gas. THis is a situation that America has not known for about half a century. So the oil shock described in the book has a distinct 1970s or 1980s flavour to it, instead of being science fiction.

So, I very much liked this book. It is a superb read. It makes a lot of good points, although I do not know, for instance, whether the ridiculously low number of Ivy League graduates or Congessmen's children that have enlisted in the armed forces is true or not. Because I enjoyed it so much, I believe it is worth four stars, but I do not think that the very pessimistic (and sometimes a bit populist) picture that it draws of America in 20 years time is realistic. At least - and this is another of the book's merits - I hope it is not. Anyway, it is up to this country's citizens to make sure that this picture does not come true and this is - of course - the whole purpose of Pressfield's cautionary tale.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars A bit of a blip, 7 Feb 2012
By 
S. Warren "ste_warren" (London) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Profession (Hardcover)
Like the other reviewers, I have absolutely loved previous works by Mr Pressfield, Gates of fire is, for me, the best in the genre. However, this book is a bit of a leap forward by the author to the near future, set in both the USA and middle east. It centres round the assumption that in future, wars will be paid for directly by the oil companies. I think that the book starts well, and has some decent characters. the main protagonist is interesting as is his mentor and god, the general. The problem with the book for me was that the story just doesn't flow that well. while liking the lead, you never actually love or care for him that much and that is what, in my opinion, Mr Pressfield does best, making you will on his heroes to either victory or a glorious death. Still worth a read, and still a good book for his fans, but I hope next time we can see Mr Pressfield going back to the past and return to what he does best!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

The Profession
The Profession by Steven Pressfield
£5.45
Add to wishlist See buying options
Only search this product's reviews