Customer Reviews

2 Reviews
5 star:
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
Most Helpful First | Newest First

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A virtuoso performance, 31 Jan. 2011
E. L. Wisty "World Domination League" (Devon, UK) - See all my reviews
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Josquin Desprez: Stabat Mater (Audio CD)
Any new disc of Josquin deserves investigation. There's a range of stuff out there, from the unlistenable to the sublime, and thankfully this fresh recording is at the latter end of the spectrum. Seven member all-male German outfit the "Dufay Ensemble" perform with one voice per part. While combining two voices per part may require some skill to seamlessly blend, with a single voice there is no hiding any foibles; but here there are none, nor any loss of power and presence whatsoever for having a smaller group of personnel. The performances, the combination, the pacing are all faultless.

At the risk of being heretical I would even say that this disc surpasses the Josquin material I have heard by the Tallis Scholars and the Hilliard Ensemble. I had thought that I possessed the definitive performance of "Miserere mei" in that by De Labyrintho in their excellent Dux Ferrera disc, but the Dufay Ensemble have delivered a serious contender to that accolade in their rendition of Josquin's setting of Psalm 51. It's definitely straight into my top three Josquin discs along with the aforementioned De Labyrintho and the Orlando Consort's disc of motets.

1. Stabat mater (à 3)
2. Domine exaudi orationem meam (à 4)
3. Pater noster/ Ave Maria (à 6)
4. Déploration sur la mort de Johannes Ockeghem (à 5)
5. Benedicta es, caelorum regina (à 6)
6. Miserere mei Deus (à 5)

Digipak with booklet containing notes and lyrics along with English and German translation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A worthy tribute to the incomparable Josquin, 15 Jan. 2011
Stephen Midgley (Tarbrax, West Calder, UK) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Josquin Desprez: Stabat Mater (Audio CD)
What is it about the music of Josquin that caused his renaissance contemporaries, as well as succeeding generations, to hold him in such awe? And why is it that listeners are still captivated today, and strong men and women go weak at the knees when they hear his music? Some possible reasons are touched upon in the notes accompanying this disc - but far more importantly, by both the choice of works and the manner of their performance, this recording makes a fair attempt to bring us some answers to these questions.

The Freiburg-based Dufay Ensemble come well equipped to perform such a task, having already recorded four superb CDs of the works of Jacobus Vaet as well as a disc of Josquin's "Missa Ave maris stella" and some motets. An all-male group consisting of alto, countertenor, two tenors, barytone and two basses - one of whom, Eckehard Kiem, directs the ensemble - their individually distinctive voices form a finely blended texture that is eminently suited to this repertory. Not only this, but they sing with insight, dignity and passion.

These qualities are immediately evident in the anguished opening chords of the first work in the programme, Josquin's "Stabat Mater". This is an absolutely beautiful work, here sung with both heartfelt expression and a sonority of the very highest quality. The other works on the disc are equally fine; highlights for me include the often-performed "Déploration: Nymphes des bois", the composer's profoundly felt lament on the death of his teacher Johannes Ockeghem evoking an atmosphere of overwhelming sadness. Then there is the glorious six-voice motet "Benedicta es, caelorum regina", a work of extraordinary richness of line and texture; it too receives a stunning performance here, with Josquin's sequence of eight chords, forming the cadence at the end of the first part to the words "Ave plena gratia", coming as close to perfection as I can imagine. The concluding item on the disc, "Miserere mei Deus", is again a profound and mesmerising work, this moving rendition by the Dufay Ensemble leaving the listener feeling not downcast, as the title might suggest, but comforted.

So, returning to the question at the beginning, this programme of Josquin works from the Dufay Ensemble offers us a marvellous demonstration of the composer's unique qualities. His polyphony is intellectually profound, yet still clearly accessible to us ordinary mortals; his extended, arching, complex melodies, like those of Bach, Beethoven and Wagner after him, are distinctive and memorable; and, in view of the type and purpose of the music he was writing, it is expressive of the texts and of the emotions within them in a way that was entirely original in his time and which brought new expressive possibilities to the art of music, and so to that of subsequent generations.

But beware of the booklet, attractively presented though it is. Eckehard Kiem's notes on the composer and his music are excellent, but their translation into English is in places faulty and, in the final paragraph, just plain wrong. I'll give a corrected version of that short passage at the end of this review. Also, somebody mixed up the printed text in the second and third parts of "Benedicta es", with the result that two lines from part 3 end up in the middle of part 2, and so part 3 begins with the wrong lines; meanwhile, the English and German translations of these two lines have vanished altogether. The track listings then repeat the error by showing the wrong title for part 3. Again, for the convenience of prospective buyers, I'll show the correct version of parts 2 and 3 below. But I must stress that these comments refer only to the printed booklet, and certainly not to the actual recorded performances: the Dufay Ensemble know better than to get their words mixed up!

However, these are very minor complaints considering what treasures this CD has to offer. If you don't already know the music of Josquin, this would be a great place to start; and if you do, I would still bet that you won't have heard anything much better than this. It is a finely judged selection of his works offering an intense musical experience that leaves us, like the composer's contemporaries, in awe of his extraordinary genius. What is more, these works are presented to us beautifully recorded by Ars Musici's engineers and, above all, in magnificent interpretations that take us to the very heart of "the incomparable Josquin".

(Note 1: last para of programme notes should read something like this: "Language-based feeling and contrapuntal virtuosity, perfect balance of sound and line, depth of expression and inherent grasp of overall structure - in Psalm 50 we see Josquin at the height of his mastery, in which he would be much emulated by the generations of composers of the next hundred years, but never surpassed.")

(Note 2: text of "Benedicta es" - Secunda pars: "Per illud Ave prolatum / Et tuum responsum gratum / Est ex te verbum incarnatum, / Quo salvantur omnia." Tertia pars: "Nunc Mater exora natum / Ut nostrum tollat reatum, / Et regnum det nobis paratum / In caelesti patria. / Amen.")
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Josquin Desprez: Stabat Mater
Josquin Desprez: Stabat Mater by Dufay Ensemble (Audio CD - 2011)
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews