Customer Reviews


260 Reviews
5 star:
 (183)
4 star:
 (45)
3 star:
 (17)
2 star:
 (7)
1 star:
 (8)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


227 of 233 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Final 5 4 10
After the tragic events at the end of series 4, the tenth Doctor chooses to travel alone and over the course of his final year in the role this equates to 5 longer than usual "special" episodes for David Tennant leading up to the very impressive arrival of Matt Smith at the end of THE END OF TIME PART TWO on 1 1 10 (which might be significant to any numerologists out...
Published on 22 Jan 2010 by Emanon

versus
37 of 42 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars The greatest doctor, but not his finest hour...
For me, David Tennant is the greatest Doctor we have seen since Tom Baker. David is for 21st century Who, what Tom was to the 20th. The strength of David's performance has carried these specials, and made every one absolutely worth watching.

At the same time, I've become increasingly frustrated with Russell T. Davies' (RTD) writing for the series. Not that I am...
Published on 21 Mar 2010 by K9


‹ Previous | 1 226 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

227 of 233 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Final 5 4 10, 22 Jan 2010
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
After the tragic events at the end of series 4, the tenth Doctor chooses to travel alone and over the course of his final year in the role this equates to 5 longer than usual "special" episodes for David Tennant leading up to the very impressive arrival of Matt Smith at the end of THE END OF TIME PART TWO on 1 1 10 (which might be significant to any numerologists out there...).

First up is the 2008 Christmas special THE NEXT DOCTOR in which the whole idea that this Doctor might not be forever is addressed. David Morrissey guest stars when the Doctor meets a figure not unlike himself having adventures during a Victorian Christmastime and a comic tragedy unfolds that mixes Dickensian imagery with Cyberpunk as the Cybermen return with the help of Dervla Kirwan in a plot involving the kidnapping of street urchins to help create their Cyberking where only the Doctor(s) and a very different type of TARDIS can save the day.

By Easter, the Doctor has taken to riding buses around London, but even a simple bus journey can't be uneventful as before you know it he's been transported to THE PLANET OF THE DEAD with only Michelle Ryan's cat-burglar and a busload of passengers (as well as Lee Evans and UNIT) to help get him home. The stakes are high as a race of planet-eating flying manta rays are getting ever closer...

The darkest, scariest moment happens fifty years in the future when THE WATERS OF MARS are threatening to overrun Lindsay Duncan and her crew on Bowie Base One. The fact that they're all already doomed adds a dark edge to the story, but when the Doctor himself decides that he won't put up with that any more things take an even darker turn.

Back to Earth at Christmas again (via the planet of the Ood) for this Doctor's final battle. THE END OF TIME PART ONE is a curiously dark piece for Christmas Day when John Simm's Master is resurrected and attempts to hijack the Immortality Gate project with dire consequences for the whole of mankind. Bernard Cribbins, Catherine Tate and (briefly) June Whitfield are all that the Doctor can rely on as an even scarier menace than the Master - headed up by Timothy Dalton! - plans its own resurrection.

THE END OF TIME PART TWO follows on quite naturally, and the universe must be saved (again) but only at great personal cost to the Doctor. It's no secret that the events of this epic story lead to the end of the line for this particular version of the Doctor, but it's a terrific ride and makes for a rather spectacular sendoff. Bernard Cribbins makes one amazing octogenerian action hero, and John Simm & Timothy Dalton are impressive foes, but the episode really, truthfully belongs to David Tennant.

Quite right too.

With his regeneration fast approaching he does (rather self-indulgently you might think) get to revisit all his best friends, but, you know I think he deserves that at the end of four truly amazing years.

Full length episodes of DOCTOR WHO CONFIDENTIAL are included for each episode, as well as the Doctor Who proms, a selection of deleted scenes and there's a slew of extras for the final episodes including David Tennant's video diaries, a Comic-Con appearance, and the BBC Christmas idents that were so very popular at the time. There are also main cast (David Tennant and Catherine Tate/ David Tennant and John Simm) and director (Euros Lyn) commentaries on the last two episodes which are a lot of fun, there's a rather nice accompanying booklet with a lovely little piece written by David Tennant himself to top off a rather nicely put together set.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


81 of 88 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars David, Russell and everyone else...THANK YOU. FOR EVERYTHING, 7 Feb 2010
By 
R. Wood "ryecroftwood2" - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)    (TOP 1000 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
Once upon a time, I was NOT a Doctor Who fan. In the old days of Who, I avoided it like the plague. I hated the effects, the writing, the acting blah-blah-blah. And it took Russell T Davies and his vision of a new Doctor Who to make me interested. Then Christopher Eccleston regenerated into David Tennant...and the rest was history.

In my opinion, the quality of the stories really took off when Tennant came on board and had peaked at Series 4 (which remains my favourite series of Doctor Who bar none). And then after an amazing five year run, after so many painful departures...the man himself David Tennant declared that he was finally leaving.

It shocked me to the core, along with everyone else. For me (and millions more), he was MY Doctor. He made me a fan, and the fact that Russell T Davies was also calling it a day was heartbreaking.

So this boxset, containing the final five specials of the Davies era, marks the end of a truly wonderful era. Taking place after the monumentally superb Series 4, the premise here is the Tenth Doctor (after vanquishing greatest enemies Davros and the Daleks and saying goodbye to his best friend Donna Noble) is once again on his own. After losing so much, the Doctor decides its best to remain on his own and not to endanger anyone else and risk his heart being broken again.

These five specials (spanning from Christmas 2008 to New Year's Day 2010) feature David Tennant and a delightful all-star guest cast. Here he has a different companion for the duration of each adventure, resulting in some terrific, classic episodes, all running for an hour except the BIG FINALE, which runs for a stonking seventy-five minutes. Overall, it's most befitting for David's last run, and as the end draws nearer, his performances excel to the point where he reaches the height of his greatness, going out in a true blaze of glory that honours his Doctor and everything he's given us.

The fact that the man's regeneration was inevitable and obvious is immediately touched upon right from the word `go' with "The Next Doctor", which sees No. 10 confront his first omen of what lies ahead. The realisation that one day, he himself will have to go. Even though things don't turn out to be as they seem at first glance, it's nevertheless a premonition that sets the scene nicely for this final story arc.

All the specials are made so because of Davies (who wrote three of the specials himself and co-wrote two of them with Gareth Roberts and Phil Ford), the re-emergence of the Cybermen, terrifying new creatures, the final darkest days of the Time War and of course, the excellent assortment of guest stars on hand. You can expect nothing but first-class performances from the likes of David Morrissey, Michelle Ryan, Lindsey Duncan, and Timothy Dalton (SERIOUSLY!). They're all given wonderfully three-dimensional characters to act out, share plenty of the spotlight with David and help to make the specials essential viewing with their presence. And of course, it's great to see the return of old favourites like Bernard Cribbins (Wilfred Mott), Catherine Tate (Donna Noble) and the godlike John Simm reprising his role as the Master.

The 2008 Christmas Special "The Next Doctor" is helped because of the refreshing change of festive scenery (Victorian London). David Morrissey's `Next Doctor' and the tragic mystery surrounding him drives the episode, as does the fascinating development of the Cybermen and Dervla Kirwan simply steals every scene she's in as the charismatic rogue Miss Hartigan. Until "The End Of Time", I found this to be the best Christmas Special ever done, due to the drama, great humour, excitement and heart to be found. It's certainly still got that after repeat viewing.

The 2009 Easter Special "Planet of the Dead" is another hugely enjoyable romp of an episode with Michelle Ryan's Lady Christina being a perfect match for the Tenth Doctor. Her experience as the Bionic Woman does the character justice, making her sharp, charismatic, sexy and witty. Michelle's chemistry with David is a treat to behold, and Lee Evans will truly have you in hysterics. "Planet of the Dead" really is so much fun to watch, but after this, fun time is over. Watch the ending to see what I mean.

To me, it`s "The Waters of Mars" November 2009 Special that is the true highlight of boxset. Davies really changes gears with this episode and his writing and produces what is truly one of the darkest, most terrifying and most psychological stories ever in Who. It touches upon so many adult themes, all of which are executed brilliantly. Lindsey Duncan as Captain Adelaide Brooke comes across as the Tenth Doctor's most strong-willed companion ever with her portrayal and the consequences of what happens here changes everything forever, tarnishing the Doctor and making us all realise just how much he needs a companion. "The Waters of Mars" is a true classic and one that should be watched more than any other episode here.

Finally, "The End of Time" two-part finale can be labelled epic, thanks to everything coming full circle with regards to the haunting prophecy, the Master's return, Wilfred (Bernard Cribbins) proving himself to be the ideal companion for the Tenth Doctor's last hurrah and of course all loose ends regarding the Time War, other sub-plots and David going out with redemption and as a true hero. Seeing the Doctor saying goodbye to all his loved ones and deliver his very last line will reduce you to tears and simply cannot be missed.

For extras, you can expect fantastic Confidential pieces, deleted scenes, audio commentaries for "The End of Time", David's Video Diaries of his final days, the Christmas Idents and the wonderful Doctor Who: At The Proms concert special. All of which help round up things in a very nice bow indeed.

Russell, David, everyone...THANK YOU. For everything.

Buy now.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Good to have Who on Blu-ray ... but, 12 Feb 2010
By 
Graham Cripps (Germany) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
It is excellent to finally have Dr Who available on Blu-ray. That is the best thing about this, the picture quality is absolutely superb!

That said the story is average, not really very imaginative, but it works. As the second of the David Tennant specials it is a little bit disappointing, I had higher expectations from all the specials, and they have all failed somewhat to deliver. I was expecting at least one to come up to the standards of 'The Hollow Child', 'The Impossible Planet', 'Girl in the Fireplace' or the absolutely brilliant 'Blink', but sadly none of them have. After having seen all the specials, all of which were written by Russel T Davis, none of who's stories I have ever been very impressed by, I am left with the uncomfortable feeling that Mr Davis is trying to tell us something, but I don' t know what it is, or why. The lady passenger at the end tells the Doctor "He will knock four times", then in the last special there is the four drum beats and Bernard Cribbins also knocks four times, but so what! The "Bad Wolf" message that ran throughout the first series was sort of OK and just about worked, but all these messages and links are a bit naff now and in the specials they defiantly distract from the individual plots.

All the actors put in fine performances, David Tennant is as usual brilliant as the Doctor and Michelle Ryan is quite wonderful as Lady Christina, OK her character is a bit of a Laura Croft copy, but so what. Seeing nice sights is what Blu-ray is all about, and she is certainly nice to look at. The one character who is a bit borderline is Lee Evans, who is a bit too silly. Dr Who went though a period in the Eighties where under the directorship of J N Turner it got very light entertainment and lost a lot of its believability and magic with a succession of silly characters and stupid monsters. The production staff need to careful with characters like Malcolm he is just about OK, but any more like him would undermine the credibility of the show.

The biggest disappointment however has to be the monsters. They look like exactly what they are, a couple of blokes in boiler suits wearing plastic fly heads. Many years ago there was a film called "The Dark Crystal", the insect like monsters in it were quite superb, at the time I thought wow, this would really work in Dr Who. But sadly the production team, for whatever reason, could not make that extra effort and make the costumes really dramatic and insect like. If you are going to do insects the do them properly, these are a cop out and an opportunity has been missed here, today the expectation for monsters on Who has to produce better efforts than this They are almost as bad as the legendary Myrka from the JNT era (sorry guys, but for a Dr Who special this is just not good enough).

One of the reasons given for Dr Who not to have been available in HD, up till now, was that the cost of the CGI special effects would be too high. If this is true then what about "Blink", my personal absolute favorite from the new series. As far as I can see it contains no CGI effects at all so, as it is such a classic, why does the BBC not release it on Blu-ray? I am sure it would be far more popular that this average story. Surely it cannot be that the BBC have been so naive as not to video it in HD in the first place, but having already lost 108 episodes from the original series stranger things have happened!

So of the three stories on Blu-ray so far (You cannot count 'The Next Doctor' as it is upscaled) this is rather sadly the best of the three. The other two just confuse, Dr Who should entertain, with fantasy worlds, inhabited with amazing but believable monsters. It is not about figuring out what knocking four times means, and if the Doctor saves someones life, they should not after arriving home shoot themselves dead for the sake of history, what the hell was that all about? This Blu-ray is worth getting, but the other specials, well I would rather wait and see what the BBC decide to do next. Maybe they will bring out Blink - but I doubt it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


10 of 11 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A Fine End To A Fine Era, 18 Jan 2010
By 
Mr. I. Clarke "wellerard_21" (Leeds UK) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
Christopher Ecclestone left the audience wanting more having relaunched the show, David Tennant gave a defining performance and a fine era.

These last specials were a mini series in themselves, and link nicely, with the Doctor left alone to face his demons, and face them he does.

The Next Doctor is a fun Christmas romp, with some impressive looking scenes, and the teasing idea of a peek into the future, which is ultimately revealed to be folse. David Morissey puts in a sterling, warm performance and Dervla Kirwan is icy cool in the villainess role. The only trouble is that the Cybermen suffer from what they often suffered from in the original; they were badly used, and the attempt to update the Cybermats just doesn't quite work.

Planet Of The Dead, again, thanks to its' location work looks spectacular, and works well as a sort of mid season adventure. Lots of nods here to past ideas and references in the Who mkythology; the replacement for Ace was originally intended to be an aristocratic cat burglar, which Michelle Ryan does well. Her leaving in the flying bus has more than shade of Iris Wildthyme to it. Lee Evans is obviously enjoying himself too.

Waters Of Mars is, for me a classic. A base under seige story with a twist, the Doctor knows what is supposed to happen. Lynsay Duncan and the rest ratchet up the tension in this wonderfully. The idea of the Doctor, knowing his own mortality is nearly up (a Time Lord only has 13 lives) and getting drunk on the power that he can have is a wonderful sinister ending, especially when time shows him who is really in control.

The End Of Time works on a gloriously silly grand stage; The Master having a cult, and the Master race themselves being very grand and positively daft ideas, althought it does really give John Simm a wonderful second bite of the cherry at the character and he takes it with relish. Bernard Cribbins, as ever, is superb, and Timothy Dalton as Rassilon (how did they get him back from the long dead?!) plays the part with relish. It only loses a star for what has to tbe the most drawn out regeneration of the show's history. In the usual scheme of things, he would have saved Wilf, fallen out of the booth, collapsed, regenerated. Here he does a very over done curtain call, but with two nice touches; the farewell in the mind to Rose, as well as the line, 'I don't want to go', makes a stark change as he nears the end of his lives when compared to the resignation of his predecessors. This is hardly Ecclestone's last grin!

A fine end to a fine tenure.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


56 of 63 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The Next Doctor... and the next!, 10 Jan 2010
By 
J. Palmer "The Big Bear" (Devon) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
I've watched a lot of Doctor Who - "my" Doctor was William Hartnell and I started watching the series just after the first story. I've watched a lot...
Where does it say that EVERY story must be tense, exciting, original and scary? Just check out the original series for some wonderful clunkers! These specials should be taken for what they are: Popular family-oriented science fiction adventure. It's designed to appeal to the masses - it wouldn't be Doctor Who if it didn't - so why read more into it than that? OK some of the plots are wafer thin and some of the designs are ludicrous - what were they thinking of when they brought us the Cybershades? - but the whole is greater than the parts and the series marches on.
How would I rate these specials if pressed in a convention bar? Well, "The Next Doctor" was a bit of a disappointment as I just don't like huge robots, especially Cyberman ones! "Planet of the Dead" was better, despite the flying bus, "Waters of Mars" was actually quite good, but what happened to the Doctor towards the end? He's never gone quite so far out before, possibly the nearest the character has ever come to this was in the Tom Baker scene from "Genesis of the Daleks", where the Doctor debates the moral rights of the Daleks to exist at all. The final two-parter veered between daft and magnificent. If a casual viewer had tuned in for these, they would be left dazzled and mystified in turn. The Master Race? Too silly! The ACTUAL knocking four times - too brilliant for words! After saving the human race, the Doctor gives his life to save one old man? Fantastic! But would he have done this if he did not know the prophecy of his death? Probably! Some continuity strangeness was evident - unless old Rassilon has messed with time to live on - but overall a good way for David Tennant to bow out. I will watch these again and probably enjoy them more each time. Nostalgia grows like that!
So on with the new and apart from looking young enough to be my grandson, I have hopes that Matt Smith will carry on the good work. He's got a great team behind him after all!
And I've watched a LOT of Doctor Who!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


103 of 116 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Special Features, 31 Dec 2009
By 
Tijs Hegemann "thijshegemann" (Brüggen) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
Special Features

The Next Doctor
Doctor Who at the proms
The next Doctor confidential
New special moving menus

Planet of the Dead
Planet of the Dead Confidential
New special moving menus

The Waters of Mars
Waters of Mars confidential

The End of Time: Part One
Xmas confidential
David Tennant video diary - the final days
BBC idents
Audio commentary on feature

The End of Time: Part Two
New Year confidential
Russell T Davies intro to deleted scenes & deleted scenes
Doctor Who at comic-con 2009
Audio commentary on feature
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


37 of 42 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars The greatest doctor, but not his finest hour..., 21 Mar 2010
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
For me, David Tennant is the greatest Doctor we have seen since Tom Baker. David is for 21st century Who, what Tom was to the 20th. The strength of David's performance has carried these specials, and made every one absolutely worth watching.

At the same time, I've become increasingly frustrated with Russell T. Davies' (RTD) writing for the series. Not that I am one of these people that appear to have an irrational hatred of a man I have never met:far from it, I love the fact he brought the series back, and he has given us some great stories (The Christmas Invasion, Tooth and Claw, Turn Left and Midnight to name but a few).

Increasingly however, RTD seemed to have simply run out of fresh ideas, and was not able to produce a series finale that had a satisfactory resolution. Thus for series 1 we had Daleks trying to take over the world, series 2: Daleks & Cyberman trying to take over the world; series 3: the Master had a go; Series 4 the Daleks again and the Specials the Master had another go. Similarly, we had alien invasion of contemporary earth for Christmas special 1 (a classic), alien invasion of contemporary earth for Christmas special 2, destruction attempt of earth for Christmas special 3, then an alien invasion of Victorian earth, and for the last Master tries to take over - you guessed it - contemporary earth. With its infinite format, don't you think Who deserved some originality? I do!

So to the stories:

The Next Doctor - I was really thrilled at this one... at first. The Doctor seemed to be having a ball, for once we get a Christmas special away from contemporary earth, and the premise seemed good. However, like most RTD specials the storyline seemed to have been set up for the pre-publicity gossip (i.e. is David Morrisey the next Doctor?)and subsequent viewing figures. However, this as a basis for a good story, just doesn't simply work, and you feel so let down as there's no explanation for Miss Hartinger's motivations or why the Cyberman would go along with it; and the Doctor destroying the plot from a hot air balloon was just plain ludicrous. 6/10 - great promise, but awful resolution.

The Planet of the Dead - A landmark episode as the first story to be broadcast in High Definition. Not a landmark story though - it looks beautiful but I lost interest rapidly. David Tennant is great as usual, but the plight of those on the bus and monsters that look as though they came from the Slyvester McCoy era did not really grip my attention. Perhaps too much was trying to be achieved in one go, or we just didn't know enough about the characters on the bus to feel involved in their plight? 5/10

The Waters of Mars - the classic of these specials. This story really had a "classic Who" base under siege story. For the first time, shown on a Sunday instead of a Saturday, for once we see a different side to Doctor's character. Here he relishes the fact he is more than a mere mortal and has the capability to change future events as a Time Lord - almost like a God. The Doctor himself is scary, and it is made even more so by the sacrifice that comes at the end of story by someone who realises that her timeline cannot be changed. 10/10

The End of Time. Both David Tennant and Bernard Cribbins carry a very poor story to wind-up the 10th Doctor's era. Bernard Cribbins is an amazing man, now 80 and running around like someone half his age on screen, and with a real zest for life still. Not only that he gives an excellent and moving performance throughout! I hoped that RTD would not use his "let's throw as many elements in the mix as possible for a finale but not worry about tying them up" again but I was disappointed. The Time Lords return as evil psychopaths who want to .. take over the earth (groans), and now Rassilon is alive and well apparently. How did the Time lords manage this miraculous feat of returning after the Time War? Well it's obvious... they seeded a banging noise in the universe which allowed them to re-appear !

David Tennant plays the regeneration scene very well, but I can't help thinking the line "I don't want to go" was greatly out of chracter for the Doctor (too egotistical and wimpy). However, on the plus side: whilst many have criticised RTD's self-congratulatory visit of old companions , I think for once he showed originality for the regeneration sequence.

So for the discs/extras:

- It is rather cheeky to say the least, that for this release that the BBC has decided to master these @1080/60i on Blu-Ray rather than 1080/50i for the UK market. Many have complained at seeing a slightly jerky picture, and odd colours. Why isn't the BBC mastering in the UK for the UK market?

- DT's Video Diary - a nice, personal look at his last year on the show.

- Doctor Who Confidentials - for once, not cut down- except for the one for The Next Doctor - which has some small edits.

- Commentaries - only 1 for The End of Time. Why or why, given podcasts had been recorded for the other stories?

- BBC Christmas idents. Christmas 2009 will go down as the Christmas of David Tennant, so nice to include these. Though like many, I cannot understand why they didn't also include David Tennant announcing his last show on New Year's Day?

- Doctor Who @ the Proms. Given this was filmed in HD and recorded in surround sound, the decision here to present on the Blu-Ray in SD/ Stereo is a huge wasted opportunity.

So: should you buy this set? For a fan of the 10th Doctor, then absolutely: though the extras are not up to their usual standards for the reasons outlined above. For the "casual fan" then there are many other stories from David Tennant's era that stand out much better than those on offer here. Hence my 3* rating.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The End Of An Era, With Some Superb Specials, 3 Oct 2014
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
These are David Tennant's five final episodes as the 10th Doctor. They range from bad, to okay to very good. David Tennant has always been my favourite Doctor and I was sad to see him go at the end of "The End of Time, Part 2."

Here are my thoughts on all the five specials:

The Next Doctor - This is by far the worst of all Russell T Davies Christmas specials for Doctor Who. The concept is a good idea that is badly executed. It's not that great at all and surprisingly dull. I find it really boring. The Cybermen are okay but not very menacing. The acting is solid, but the episode itself is underwhelming. Grade: F (4.5/10)

Planet of the Dead - This is an improvement over "The Next Doctor", but it's still nothing spectacular. The character Christina is annoying and the plot is nothing "special." The story is basic and the episode lacks substance. David Tennant plays really well as the Doctor as he does in every episode he's been in. It is just not up to the standard you would expect. The ending is bad, it's contrived. Making the bus fly is silly and the characters on the bus are not well developed. Nearing the conclusion, someone who can predict things (we never knew how she was able to) says to the Doctor "he will knock four times." I liked that and it resonates into the next special, which is a vast improvement over this episode. There are some enjoyable moments and funny scenes but it's not that memorable at all. Grade: D- (6/10)

The Waters of Mars - This episode is very good. It's the darkest episode of Doctor Who I have ever seen and the real villain of the episode is the Doctor himself. It contains some very powerful scenes, creepy monsters and is highly thrilling. A few flaws are contained within it but this is a great special. I was so happy seeing this after the last two let-downs. Grade: B (8.5/10)

The End of Time, Part 1 - This is the best episode of the two-parter. John Simm plays brilliantly as the Master and some of the scenes are creepy. I like the emotional scene in the café, featuring the Doctor and Wilfred Mott. It's a very good set-up for Tennant's epic exit in part two. Grade: B (8.5/10)

The End of Time, Part 2 - This episode is very good as well. David Tennant's acting is phenomenal and I like how he says goodbye to his companions at the end before he regenerates. When David Tennant does regenerate into Matt Smith it will most likely leave a tear in your eye, especially if you have been watching the 10th Doctor all the way like me. The plot itself feels over the top in some places but it's the acting and emotion that makes this episode so wonderful. It's not as good as part 1, but still great. Grade: B- (8/10)

The Specials for Doctor Who is a good box set to collect, particularly if you are a fan of the show or Sci-Fi in general. I would get this set to own the great episodes "The Waters of Mars" and "The End of Time, Parts 1 and 2." I have thoroughly enjoyed the Russell T Davies era and I feel that some of the emotion which made these earlier stories so great is lost when Steven Moffat takes over as showrunner. I still like Matt Smith's era, but the RTD era is my favourite.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Tenth Doctors Final Adventures, 31 Aug 2014
By 
Timelord-007 (The Eccentric Wanderer) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
Doctor Who - Complete Specials.

DVD Info.
Format: PAL
Language: English
Subtitles: English
Subtitles For The Hearing Impaired: English
Region 2
Number of discs: 5
Classification: 12
Studio: 2entertain
Running Time: 305 minutes

Broadcast
Original channel BBC One
Original run 25 December 2008 - 1 January 2010

Special Features
Commentary with Cast & Crew
Deleted Scenes
Exclusive David Tennant Video Diary
BBC Proms
Doctor Who Confidential.

Trivia: The Next Doctor.
1)The episode played on public expectations, as David Tennant's successor to The Doctor was soon to be announced, this was heightened by the fact that David Morrissey had apparently been in talks to play the Eleventh Doctor.
2)The balloon TARDIS is "Tethered Aerial Release Developed in Style."
3)The set for the cyberfactory is actually the Torchwood Hub set from Torchwood (2006) cleverly disguised.
4)David Morrissey was only cast 5 days before filming.
5)Images are seen of all previous ten on-screen incarnation of The Doctor as portrayed by William Hartnell, Patrick Troughton, Jon Pertwee, Tom Baker, Peter Davison, Colin Baker, Sylvester McCoy, Paul McGann, Christopher Eccleston, & David Tennant.

Trivia: Planet Of The Dead.
1)Michelle Ryan was a candidate for a new companion after the departure of Billie Piper in 2006.
2)The Doctor mentions "Humans on a bus, always blaming me", referring to Doctor Who: Midnight (2008).
3)Both buses were meant to be intact throughout the story, but while one was en route to Dubai, it was badly knocked about at the docks by a crane driver who was careless with a container. So the film crew sent photos of the damage back to Cardiff and there the crew made similar 'alterations' to that bus so they would match, a few lines were added to the script to explain the sudden change in the buses's appearance.
4)Adam James is the godson of the Third Doctor, Jon Pertwee & has been best friends with actor David Tennant since they played brothers in a play in 1999.
5)While trying to call UNIT, The Doctor mistakenly dials "Pizza Geronimo" - 'Geronimo' being the catchphrase of the Eleventh Doctor, Matt Smith.
6)The "four knocks" which is supposed to introduce the darkness that signifies the doctor's "last song" may be the four bars last heard in "The Sound of Drums" or "Last of the Timelords", a sound which haunted The Master.
7)This is the first Doctor Who episode in which series producer Russell T. Davies shares co-writing credit & the first episode since the show's return in 2005 to credit two writers.
8)Malcolm says he had read all the Doctor's files and the Doctor asked "Really? What was your favourite? The Giant Robot?" This is a reference to the Fourth Doctor-era story Doctor Who: Robot: Part One (1974).
9)Barclay and Nathan mention the Stolen Planets from Doctor Who: The Stolen Earth (2008).
10)The number of the bus, 200, is a reference to the fact that "Planet of the Dead" was advertised as Doctor Who's 200th story.

Trivia: The Waters Of Mars.
1)The name of the Mars colony, Bowie Base One, is a reference to musician David Bowie & his song "Life on Mars".
2)The space suit the Doctor uses is from 'The Satan Pit'.
3)When the Doctor is talking to Adelaide, he talks about this situation is like trying to save Pompeii, but by doing it he causes the catastrophe. In "Fires of Pompeii" the Doctor fires up mount Vesuvius to save planet Earth, destroying Pompeii.
4)The Ice Warriors are from the planet Mars & given a subtle mention by the Doctor.

Trivia: The End Of Time Part 1.
1)Brian Cox (Elder Ood Voice) would later be cast as Sydney Newman, the creator of Doctor Who, in An Adventure in Space & Time (2013).
2)Last ever appearance of Lucy Saxon.
3)Catherine Tate filmed her role in 5 days.
4)Patrick Stewart was offered the role of The Narrator

Trivia: The End Of Time Part 2.
1)When the Ood sing the Doctor to his sleep, they sing "Vale Decem" in Latin which means "Farewell Ten".
2)According to interviews with Russell T. Davies , all of Matt Smith lines as the Doctor are written by Steven Moffat.
3)Russell T. Davies said that the Tenth Doctor's last moments were planned out shortly after David Tennant was cast in the role, & implied that had Tennant not been cast, the scene would have been written differently.
4)The scene in which The Doctor says "I don't want to go." was filmed three times, each with increased level of intensity in the delivery. The take which made it to air was the second take, as the third & final take was considered to be too emotional.
5)Russell T. Davies used Bernard Cribbins own military experiences as the basis for Wilfrid's reminiscences.
6)Director Euros Lyn wanted to remove the scene where the Doctor visits Verity Newman, thinking it would be confusing for anyone who had missed the connection she has to the Doctor, but Russell T. Davies insisted on keeping the scene in the final cut.
7)Last episode written by Russell T. Davies.
8)The character Verity Newman is named after Verity Lambert, who was the first producer in the original series, & Sydney Newman, who created the series in 1963.
9)In the scene where The Doctor gives Jack Harkness Alonso's name, the music playing is "My Angel Put the Devil in Me" that was featured at the beginning of Season 3 episode, Doctor Who: Daleks in Manhattan (2007).
10)Timothy Dalton was a possible for The Master in Doctor Who 1996, Eric Roberts however was cast in the role.

What's The Story's.

The Next Doctor.
It's Christmas Eve in 1851 & the Cybermen stalk the snow of Victorian London, When the Tenth Doctor arrives & starts to investigate a spate of mysterious deaths, he's surprised to meet another Doctor his future self perhaps & soon the two must combine forces to defeat the ruthless Miss Hartigan.

But are two Doctors enough to stop the rise of the sinister CyberKing?

Timelord Thoughts.
This is a fast paced exciting Tenth Doctor adventure featuring the return of the Cybermen, David Tennant is outstanding throughout with his energetic Doctor whizzing back & forth while giving his incarnation emotional weight in the story's final few moments, while David Morrissey is excellent as a possible future incarnation of the Doctor who masks his own tragic past.

Dervla Kirwan is on great villain duties as Miss Hartigan who is linked somehow to the Cybermen who are at the most sinister in this episode, the massacre in the snow in the graveyard is powerful imagery while the climax with the CyberKing is tension filled action packed drama.

Overall The Next Doctor is a excellent Christmas episode & one of my favourites of the Tenth Doctor era.
Timelord Rating.
9/10

Planet of the Dead.
When a London bus takes a detour to an alien world, the Tenth Doctor must join forces with the extraordinary Lady Christina, But the mysterious planet holds terrifying secrets, hidden in the sand & time is running out, as the deadly Swarm gets closer...

Timelord Thoughts.
This episode co-written by RTD & Gareth Roberts who wrote many great NA & Missing Adventure novels see the Tenth Doctor & passengers on a Double Decker Bus transported to a alien world of San Helios were the Doctor alongside Lady Christina race against time to stop a deadly swarm from wiping them out, This story feels a little lacklustre at times & needed a bit more drama, Michelle Ryan is excellent as Lady Christina however & plays the part brilliantly but is completely underused & I do hope her character returns as a companion one day as she would make a excellent foil for the Doctor.

David Tennant is incapable of giving a below par performance & injects this story with much needed energy & enthusiasm his look when told about "he will knock four times" is priceless, the character of UNIT scientist Malcom is played by comedian Lee Evans who is ok for one adventure but as a recurring character I think he would soon become annoying,

The are two alien species on the planet the first are called Tritovores which are a insect race & not the planets deadly creatures despite there gruesome looking appearance whom the Doctor befriends & tries to help, the deadly aliens of San Helios are in fact a swarm of alien Stingrays who will devour anything that gets in their way, again this race has no sinister intentions it's just what they do.

Overall a average episode that is injected with great performances by David Tennant & Michelle Ryan who save this episode from becoming mediocre & raise it to a above average Doctor Who episode
Timelord Rating.
6/10

The Waters of Mars.
The Tenth Doctor land on the planet Mars, at a base in peril, A creeping infection beneath the Martian surface threatens not only the human race, but also the Doctor's most fundamental beliefs he cannot change events that have a fixed point in history.

Together with Adelaide Brooke - the base's commander - the Doctor must stop a seemingly unstoppable menace before it can reach Earth & wipe out mankind.

Timelord Thoughts.
The Waters Of Mars is another one of my favourite Tenth Doctor episodes & one of David Tennants best performances as the Tenth Doctor.

The isolated setting of a base on the planet Mars is nothing we haven't seen before but what makes this story memorable is it's intensity of a crew in peril of a infected water supply that transforms them into aggressive alien like creatures while the Doctor is seemingly unable to help them as this is a fixed point in time & must always be so he cannot interfere...or can he?

The acting is this episode is top notch, Lindsay Duncan is excellent as Captain Adelaide Brooke who is completely believable in the part & who's fate cannot be undone, Duncan is a no nonsense character & her actions at the stories conclusion is both shocking & horrifying.

But make no mistake this is David Tennants show & he acts magnificently throughout this story bringing a genuine sadness at being unable to help save this crew, Tennants acting displays such facial emotions in many scenes in particular as he turns away & walks back to the Tardis as he can hear the terrified screams of the crew dying who then becomes the crews saviour but at a cost, Tennant makes his Doctor seem quite sinister here & suddenly the character of the Doctor feels very dangerous which is something rarely felt in the series & all this culminates into a shocking conclusion hinting it's the beginning of the end for this incarnation of the Timelord.

Timelord Rating.
9/10

The End of Time: Part One.
When his psychotic nemesis the Master has been reborn, on Christmas Eve. Who has cheated death at a price the battle ranges from the wastelands of London to the mysterious Immortality Gate, while the alien Ood warn of an even greater danger approaching, as a terrible shadow falls across the entire Universe.

Timelord Thoughts.
This is a good opener which sees the return of the Master who is again played by John Simm who adds a intense insanity to his interpretation of the character who has been resurrected but at a terrible cost, his scenes with David Tennant who gives a emotional performance as the Doctor knowing his time is almost up spars brilliantly with his renegade equal as there scenes together are both exciting & engaging as each actor seemingly brings out the best in there characters & each others acting.

Bernard Cribbins plays such a great character of Wilfred Mott & adds genuine heart & emotion in his performance who together with David Tennant whom share many tearjerking scenes & is a brilliant addition to this episode while Catherine Tate is more a extended cameo & doesn't really do much as former companion Donna Noble.

Overall a good opener too this two part finale that delivers action, drama & suspense which features the return of Rassilon played by ex 007 Timothy Dalton.

Timelord Rating.
8/10

The End of Time: Part Two.
The Doctor faces the end of his life as the Master's plans hurtle out of control. With the sound of drums growing louder & an ancient trap closing around the Earth, the Doctor & Wilf must fight alone.

But sacrifices must be made as the deadly prophecy warns: "He will knock four times."

Timelord Thoughts.
It's the end & the moments been prepared for as David Tennants swansong delivers a great climax to the story & is a fitting goodbye to the Tenth Doctor.

Bernard Cribbins again delivers such heartfelt emotion & plays his scenes with utter believability & conviction especially when he breaks down saying he doesn't want the Doctor to die.

John Simm is menacing as the Master who realizes he is just a pawn in a more sinister turn of event's who faces a dilemma that was rumoured to have featured in a Third Doctor story had actor Roger Delgado lived to film his final Master story as the Doctor & the Master are pited against a more vicious advisory Rassilon played with gravitas & conviction by Timothy Dalton.

However this episode belongs to actor David Tennant who has been a fantastic Doctor & also been one of the shows best supporters & ambassadors, here Tennant delivers such emotional range from humour, sadness, aggression & all out rage especially in the storys final 20 minutes, the sequence were his Doctor holds a gun to the Master & Rassilon is full of drama & tension as you cannot predict the outcome of events & the true realization of the four knocks is quite shocking yet believable.

Many fans complained at how long it takes the Doctor to regenerate as he goes on a farewell tour to say goodbye to his past companions however I disagree as I think it's only fitting Tennant has these final moments as he reflects on his past adventures which makes the actual regeneration so much more heartbreaking accompanied by Murray Golds haunting but excellent Vale Decem score which had me in floods of tears as the Doctor quotes "I don't want to go" & regenerates into a new incarnation of the Doctor causing untold damage to the Tardis.

Overall a great conclusion to this epic finale that delivers all you could possibly want from a Doctor Who adventure & allows one of the most popular Doctors to go out on a high.
Timelord Rating.
9/10

Timelord Final Thoughts.
The End Of Time is a fitting swansong for the Tenth Doctor & the actor David Tennant who has played the part for 4 wonderful years & delivered many classic new series episodes & revitalized the show making it not only popular in England but all over the world, David Tennant you were my Doctor of the new series of Doctor Who & are one of my favourite all time incarnations of the Doctor & have delivered excellent enjoyable adventures that continues to entertain to this day.

Timelord Overall Rating.
9/10
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The end of X, 20 Feb 2010
By 
ds (Whitby, UK) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)   
This review is from: Doctor Who - Complete Specials (The Next Doctor/ Planet of the Dead/ Waters of Mars & Winter Specials) [DVD] (DVD)
These specials marked the end of David Tennant's period as everyone's favourite time-travelling busybody who can never leave well-enough alone. It also marked the end of Russell T Davies and Julie Gardner's time with the show. The feeling was that there would be nothing anti-climactic about the end of Ten's time; and so it proved.

After the conclusion of 2008's Series 4 The Doctor strikes out alone in an effort to avoid causing pain to those who mostly choose to travel with him. But what of the adventures themselves?

The Next Doctor is something of a mixed bag. David Morrissey is wonderfully intense as Jackson Lake and the supporting cast, including Dervla Kirwan are nicely and unseasonably icy, but the resolution involving the Cyberking is deeply unsatisfying, possibly being the first tangible sign of RTD's increasing reliance on the deus ex machina to get himself out of plot holes. He also is starting to write the Doctor as an increasingly messianic figure, though the hints at vulnerability at the very end are rather touching.

Planet of The Dead is simply odd and can't really decide what it wants to be. It clearly pays more than passing homage to The Flight Of The Phoenix , but then uses Lee Evans to provide some odd (but not unwelcome) comic relief. There are plot holes aplenty but, once again, the performances are uniformly excellent. And I include the much-derided Michelle Ryan here, who is actually rather spiffy. True, Christina de Souza is a barely concealed Lara Croft clone, but Ryan does her work deftly and provides a nicely sardonic foil to Tennant. It is also in this episode where we start to get some small clues about ten's future and his eventual demise, "he will knock four times", in amongst the Doctor's rhapsodising over the minutiae of average lives that have become as much an RTD writing trope as those of Tarantino or Kevin Smith. Fun but ultimately lightweight.

Then we hit Waters of Mars, which is quite clearly the pick of the bunch here. The claustrophobia and the Doctor's crushing realisation of where and when he is is quite beautifully made flesh. And Lindsay Duncan is quite, quite fabulous. It's not all perfect, though. That bloody robot, Gadget, does grate but does have a part to play (however credibility there is stretched). However, in the last 10 minutes it gets even better, with the Doctor's latest meddling resulting in an unexpected and messy conclusion. Of course it also serves to immediately rein in The Doctor's burgeoning monomania: however much he tries, some things just are not fated to be changed, because 'little people' get in the way. This little passage was probably the most shocking one of these specials and shows that Davies' instincts for good dialogue and characterisation are still very strong indeed when he does get it right.

Given the hype and the kitchen sink being thrown at the series 4 finale, it was fair to assume that the final two part adventure that ends Tennant's time as the Doctor was not going to be an understated affair. As a result there were lots of things in The End of Time to love: John Simm's increasingly unhinged Master; the rather tender interactions between Ten and (undoubted national treasure) Bernard Cribbins' Wilf. And then there was Timothy Dalton and the increasingly complex and twisty plot (but once again shot through with holes - if Gallifrey was indeed timelocked, just how could they get that White Point Star out of the lock? Hmmm). And this was the central problem of the last story: RTD's insistence on continually gilding the narrative lily, including the last 15 minutes of the second part. I simply thought Tennant's regen sequence was way too long and way too self-indulgent. If he'd pared things down to the Sarah-Jane segment, Donna's wedding then Rose he may have got away with it. As it was the Jack and Mickey/Martha inserts felt a bit arbitrary and bolted on. It partially spoiled what could have been pitch perfect.

But, the first few seconds of XI look really rather promising: "Chin - blimey!"

I think that these specials ultimately show that RT has made the right decision. There is a danger that to stay any longer would have seen the creative well run dry. As it is, I think he just about gets away with it, and leaves Steve Moffat a blank canvas to work form. I'm looking forward to it already.

As ever, with the annual Who releases, the series extras are compendious and worth splashing the cash for: stripped back Confidential episodes, commentaries and video diaries all help to fill out the already good material.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


‹ Previous | 1 226 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Only search this product's reviews