Customer Reviews

Pedro Almodovar Collection - Volver, All About My Mother, Bad Education, Talk To Her [DVD]

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

With the number of Almodovar collections on the market it was difficult to decide which one I should buy. I eventually went for this one as it includes a number of his most well received films to date. All the films are top quality and feature Almodovar's colourful, graphic style and subject matter that is usually serious and quite melodramatic, but always infused with moments of black comedy. The picture and sound quality of all the DVDs are great. Sadly, there really aren't any extras included that are worth mentioning. This is disappointing but the collection is still worth buying considering the quality of the films and the price.

This contains some of Almodovar's most emotional and complex work, from the later half of his career.

As has been noted, most fans of his work will already have these films, but if not, you're getting four of his very best films for the price of one. (as of Jan. 2012)

My personal thoughts on the four films;

All About My Mother (1999) - My favorite Almodovar film to date. He finally combines the best of his older, absurdist films, with his new found maturity and real emotion that began to emerge in 'Flower of My Secret' and 'Live Flesh'. A woman's son dies, while trying to get an autograph from a great actress, leaving his mother bereft, and trying to start a new life. I won't give away any details, but her journey is both funny and tragic, and leads to some terrifically unexpected and sometimes ironic places. Full of odd and wonderful characters, and some very strong acting. A bit cute or 'forced' in a few moments, but overall a moving, special and wonderful film. If you don't know Almodovar's work, this is an excellent place to start.

Talk to Her (2002) My second favorite Almodovar film. A moving and complex study of the relationship between two men, and their connection to women in comas. A few brilliantly funny moments, and some ultimately very creepy undertones keep it from being over-sentimental. Every character is more complex then they first appear, and the confusion between what is good and what is bad in both intent and effect is very rich. Some great camera work too. Gets slow in a few spots, and the sentiment still goes over the top in a few places, but still a terrific film about the similarities and differences between love and obsession.

Bad Education (2004) Fascinatingly complex nourish mystery. A film-maker is reunited with a boyhood lover, who wants to tell a dark story from their Catholic school days. But is the story true? And who's story is it really? Gael Garcia Bernal is terrific in a complicated, multi faceted role, and all the acting is very good. Gorgeously shot, with a great score.

I wish it hit me deeper emotionally, but my mind was always completely absorbed, even if my heart stayed a little cool. Maybe that's the nature of a film where everyone is hustling and using each other.

(mild spoliers ahead)

The film is a bit obvious and self-conscious in a few spots, and pederastic Catholic priests is a cliché the film only partially transcends (although the humanity given to the priest makes it far more interesting), and a couple of the climactic twists feel less motivated than what comes before. But it's all very worth it for the `Vertigo' like layers of reality that keep getting pulled back and forcing us to keep reassessing `good', `bad', `art' and `real.' Many critics consider this Almodovar's masterpiece - and I would happily watch it a third time. I think this is the kind of film that only grows on repeated viewings. Be sure to get the NC-17 version. The changes aren't huge, but this is the kind of film where any punches pulled takes something away.

Volver (2007) Both touching and absurdly comic, as is much of Almodovar's work. The film is a paean to women's strength, like a more mature. complex `Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown'. Full of wonderful images, moments and plot twists, from a murdered good-for nothing husband who must be disposed of, to a long dead mother who returns as a ghost to explain the past. Or maybe she's not quite dead. Full of fun scenes, and terrific performances.

For me something gets a little lost in the last 20 minutes - plot elements that need to be explained never are, while things I didn't really care about, or that I liked the unsolved mystery of, are explained in great, literal detail that somehow lessens the impact. None-the-less, yet another imaginative, creative, funny and thoughtful film by Almodovar.

You can't choose if you want or not subtitles. You always see the subtitles on the film. I didn't know It and I would like have known this before the shopping.

the films included in this box set are all excellent, however as other reviews have said, have been featured in other almodovar collections.if you've already got these other box sets, fair enough, dont bother with this. but, despite this, i feel that as examples of his later, more recent work they go very well and i can see why they have been put together. if you dont already own them, or are not a hardcore fan it would be a good buy. but, like i said, these are only his most recent films and anyone looking for more of the director's earlier work, as well as these, should check out some of the other box sets available.

I ordered these films about 2 weeks ago and I have watched them all. My favourite one is Todo Sobre Mi Madre by far and the worst in my opinion is Volver. They all show the revolutionised post-Franco Spain in Almodovar's eyes; this is shown particularly well in Mal Educacion.

They also are good at helping you with A Level Spanish, and help you understand more about what Spain went through when Franco died.

Watch them! They are good films.

I bought this boxed set because I am huge fan of Almodovar's films. It feels great to own this set.

. All I expected from it. Brilliant films with Volver my favourite! Sub titles may put off some people but still well worth it.

Great set to have, love this director's work and this is a perfect collection to give as a gift for an Almodovar fan.

Pedro Almodavar's films are regarded by some people as very arty but others like me think he just likes filming sex scences with very little story line.

All fine. What more can I say? All fine. What more can I say? All fine. What more can I say?