Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop All Amazon Fashion Summer Savings Up to 25% Off Cloud Drive Photos Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Oasis Learn more Shop now Learn more

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars76
4.5 out of 5 stars
Format: MP3 Download|Change
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 28 August 2007
Most of this 1988 release was recorded during the band's Joshua Tree tour. It is often derided for marking the moment U2 began to balloon out of control, veering into something near parody. To be fair, there are several highly inspired moments including "Desire," "Heartland," and "All I Want Is You." An uneven listen.

Rattle and Hum is an expression of U2's urge to have it both ways. A sprawling double album that incorporates live tracks, cover versions, collaborations, snippets of other people's music and a passage from a taped interview, the record is an obvious effort to clear the conceptual decks and lower expectations following the multiplatinum success of The Joshua Tree.

But ambition has always been U2's gift and curse, and the band clearly doesn't feel fully comfortable with its sights lowered. Consequently, if amid the rather studied chaos here, you feel moved to draw comparisons with masterpieces of excess like the Beatles' White Album or the Rolling Stones' Exile on Main Street, you can be sure that Bono, the Edge, Adam Clayton and Larry Mullen Jr. won't mind a bit.

This record doesn't quite ascend to those heights, but U2 does win half the prize. In its inclusiveness and rollicking energy, Rattle and Hum caps the story of U2's rise from Dublin obscurity to international superstardom on a raucous, celebratory note. At the same time, it closes off none of the options the band might want to pursue for its next big move - and, possibly, the album even opens a few doors.

Despite Bono's insistence in the blistering "God Part II" that "I don't believe in the 60's in the golden age of pop/You glorify the past when the future dries up," Rattle and Hum is in large part a paean to the tradition of Sixties artists that U2 reveres. "God Part II" itself is Bono's personal extension of "God," the dramatic track on Plastic Ono Band in which John Lennon shed the Sixties, his identity as a Beatle and all the idols he had worshiped. Bono's update includes a pointed attack on Albert Goldman, whose book The Lives of John Lennon paints a bitter, unflattering portrait of the ex-Beatle: "I don't believe in Goldman his type like a curse/Instant karma's gonna get him if I don't get him first."

Rattle and Hum evokes the Beatles right off the bat when it opens with a corrosive live version of "Helter Skelter," a song that originally appeared on the White Album. "This song Charles Manson stole from the Beatles; we're stealin' it back," Bono announces portentously before U2 tears into the tune.

Bob Dylan sings on one track (the meandering ballad "Love Rescue Me," which Dylan also co-wrote) and plays organ on another ("Hawkmoon 269"). He is further acknowledged when U2 ignites a live rendition of "All Along the Watchtower." Jimi Hendrix, the third member of U2's Sixties trinity, is resurrected when the version of "The Star-Spangled Banner" he performed at Woodstock introduces U2's searing live take on "Bullet the Blue Sky."

U2 certainly holds its own while flirting with the greats, but Rattle and Hum is most enjoyable when the band relaxes and allows itself to stretch without self-consciously reaching for the stars. The New Voices of Freedom choir joins the band...

Track Listings

1. Helter skelter
2. Van Diemen's Land
3. Desire
4. Hawkmoon 269
5. All along the watchtower
6. I still haven't found what I'm looking for
6. Freedom for my people
8. Silver and gold
9. Pride (in the name Of love)
10. Angel of Harlem
11. Love Rescue Me
12. When love comes to town
13. Heartland
14. God Part II
15. Star Spangled Banner
16. Bullet The Blue Sky
17. All I Want is You
22 comments|16 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
I can't understand why any U2 aficionado would criticise RATTLE AND HUM. I have THE JOSHUA TREE too, which seems to be everyone's favourite, but this one is surely on a par. Well, it's all a matter of opinion, and mine is that it is! Seventeen tracks, no less, and some classics among them. For me the best include Desire, I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For, Pride (In the Name of Love), Angel of Harlem, God Part II, and the best of a fantastic lot: All I Want Is You. Even if you removed all these outstanding songs the album would still be pretty decent. 25 years down the line and this one album contains some of the best rock music in an entire generation. Forget the 'Americanist' allegations, the moaning about the accompanying feature film - this is U2 at their best. A landmark musical creation by any standard, and an indicator of what made U2 one of the greatest rock bands on earth.
0Comment|3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 7 June 2011
Somewhere along the extended length of a career, whether you're a writer or filmmaker or musician, you hit a creative peak and along with impulse and self-belief comes the reasoning that you can do no wrong. On the whole critics are quite good at identifying that creative peak in artists too, and the reviews and analyses that follow usually move in one of two directions: either it's your masterwork and will never be bettered; or you've become bloated, self-indulgent and think that if you write, direct or sing the telephone directory, people will go out and buy it in droves. Well, if The Joshua Tree was U2's peak (and arguably their re-invention with 1991's Achtung Baby runs it close!) Rattle and Hum was by-and-large, as reviews have noted, their comedown. A mishmash of ideas said the critics, a potpourri of studio outtakes and ill-considered "classic" covers that U2 had no right touching. And then there was that "discovery-of-America" odyssey that the accompanying film turned out to be. Hindsight is always useful in these instances and now history is being somewhat kinder to Rattle and Hum - possibly because in comparison to Pop-era U2 in the late '90s, this record now looks like Sgt Pepper, Pet Sounds and Exile on Main Street all in one! There are vignettes here - Van Dieman's Land, Hawkmoon 269, the Dylan collaboration, Love Rescue Me - that don't really work, and one can still accept that All Along the Watchtower isn't quite Hendrix in his pomp. But the thrust of Desire, the grandeur of All I Want is You and the sheer joy of re-creating Memphis-sound rock and soul with Angel of Harlem (surely a bona-fide U2 classic?!) makes this a record worth re-visiting every now and then. Add to that a few gems such as Heartland and the angry, Achtung Baby prelude, God PtII, and you have some lasting legacies here. And oh yes, that film. When it moves from the somewhat self-conscious visitations to Graceland and Sun Studios (and even there the "live" take of Angel of Harlem is pretty scorching) to the live footage, for a band to leave off the album (which was after all there to shift the units, not the film which got a limited and short-lived theatrical release) such definitive live versions of With or Without You, Where the Streets Have no Name and a quite brilliant Exit, is to return to that creative peak theory and the utter self-belief in one's material. If it doesn't fit the record's intent, the fans will accept it, they seemed to say. Of much more importance anyway and featured on both record and film, is the apocalyptic rendition of Bullet the Blue Sky which sums up the time, context, and history for this album. Bono - already on the way to being the world's guardian, missionary musician - had travelled to El Salvador and seen what the American-backed right-wing government was doing to its people and at a time when Ronald Reagan was being hailed as one of America's great presidents and praised for bringing about the beginning of the end of the Cold War. As U2 toured America through 1987 and 88 and realised how little the people knew of their government's Central and South American foreign policy, the song took on ever more pleading and ferocious overtones. The final lines said it all and complicate far more the relationship with the US at this time that the band had, which people have often been quick to see as fawning and overly reverential. "Pounding the women and children, who run, into the arms of America" sang Bono breathlessly at the end. U2's America was grandiose and memorable, but it was also frightening and ignoble. Any record that can capture even a fleeting moment of life going on around it such as this one, therefore deserves your attention.
0Comment|10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 15 March 2000
This is a tribute album which U2 at the time of its release were heavily criticised for, but what critics fail to see is the outstanding use the band make of their roots in songs like "Heartland", "Love rescue me" and "Hawkmoon 269". What can be seen is an intensity carried on from the Joshua Tree, with an influence of blues, folk and country, which deliver beautiful melodies and powerful sounds. U2 were criticised for not delivering anything new, but how can songs like "All I want is You" and "Desire" not be considered original material. There is something about U2 in this album, Larry Mullen's intensity behind the drums, Adam Clayton's heartbeat sensation, Edge's atmospheric echoes and Bono's even stronger commitment to reaching his listeners, creates something enourmous, something which bursts out of your speakears, which renders this piece of music as original and as intense as U2 meant it to be.
0Comment|12 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 January 2012
When this album came out, U2 were being rammed down your throat so as a result I just refused to listen to them. We were on the back of the massive album 'The Joshua Tree' and 2 of the main singles from that album 'Where the streets have no name" and 'I still haven't found what I'm looking for' did nothing for me.

However being a regular listener to Virgin Radio I happened to hear 'Angel of Harlem' and later 'When love comes to town' with BB King and thought they were tremendous. As a result I bought the CD with the view that it had better be good or I'll never buy another U2 CD again.

Initially I thought it was ok, but as I listened more I got into the energy of the album. I loved the anger in 'Helter Skelter', 'Pride' is just awesome with so much passion in it. The fore mentioned songs were excellent and songs like 'All along the watchtower' and 'Hawkmoon 269' gave the album real depth.

I am not a U2 fan but this album is 1 I go back to time after time and am never dissappointed. Pushing 5 stars.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 October 2012
This album has live and reworked versions of classics such as Helter Skelter, I Still Haven't Found..., and Pride, and reveals hidden gems such as Heartland and Love Rescue Me, as well as better known songs such as Angel of Harlem. There are the obligatory cringey live Bono momemts (the anti-apartheid stuff made my toes curl when I first heard it) but overall this record is varied and very listenable. It presents the band during an important transitional period in the wake of the success of Joshua Tree, exploring American blues influences and expanding their sound. Even though it was critically mauled this is an important step in the history of the band and remains a surprisingly compelling record.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 8 March 2012
Hi to all U2 fans

This albu, is worth it for the gospel I still have not found what I am looking for, a special song.

For those of you that purchased this album in its original format, the extras are great. Like you I just got around to swapping the vinyl for cd and onto the iPod, this has so much more.

For this price it is a must.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 15 April 2013
I bought this album solely because I am collecting all the U2 albums ever released as they are one of my favourite bands. This album is held in high regard by my friends. I had a listen, but wasn't over-awed by it. Oddly, I much prefer the less popular albums like Zooropa. So edgy and different! Comes down to personal taste at the end of the day I suppose...
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 27 May 2013
I decided to download this classic album having bought the original back in 1988, which I had lost. So disappointed that Sunday Bloody Sunday, which featured live - along with Bono's impassioned intro - on the original is missing. Which was for me, one of the album's highlights. The addition of All I Want is You only partly remedies this annoying decision.
11 comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 April 2016
An album that is often criticised, I personally really like it. The live versions of songs like Bad, Sunday Bloody Sunday and Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For are the best versions available. It loses one star because inexplicably it doesn't have the live version of With Or Without You, which is fantastic and is on the DVD.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)