Most Helpful First | Newest First
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Impassioned and authentic,
If you take a glance at my review of the woeful Davis/LSO Live version of this wonderful work, you will see that I put this set near the top of the list of recommendations. I do not rate the Chung recording; for me, there is no better account than Solti's riotous 1981 set, with an infinitely touching Von Stade almost as good as Janet Baker here in the Pretre recording, and Van Dam in incomparable form - much better than his later assumption, when the voice had started to dry out - as a subtle, insinuating demon. I almost always have reservations about Nicolai Gedda's slightly bleaty tone, but he is fully up to the demands of the eponymous rôle, and while Bacquier is not quite so elegant and vocally impressive as Van Dam, he characterises marvellously. Add to that the authentic Gallic idiom provided by Pretre and French forces, and you have a winner. This set is made even more desirable by the inclusion of Janet Baker's astounding account of "La Mort de Cléopâtre" - one of her finest performances ever on disc and you have an irresisitible package at a bargain price. Having said that, another excellent alternative version, especially if French authenticity is your priority, is the wonderful Markevitch set (see my review).
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Top-Quality Faust from Pretre,
This is a very fine recording of this demanding work. Pretre and the French operatic forces have a sure grasp of what the work is about. They sound French, which is a factor here, as Berlioz was extremely Gallic. The recorded sound is warmly analogue, in EMI's best French traditions.
The cast is, however, what will sell this set. Nicolai Gedda is, to me, the best recorded Faust, refined and impassioned. His French is idiomatic - he spoke at least 5 languages fluently. Janet Baker is perfect as Marguerite, she has no peers in the role. Gabriel Bacquier is a suitably fiendish devil, characterful and in fine voice.
I have not heard a better set than this, though several are probably as good. "The Death of Cleopatra" with Baker and Gibson seals the excellence of this set. There is no better recording of this, full stop!
No one buying this set should be disappointed.
5.0 out of 5 stars Salieri,
Berlioz' "Damnation of Faust" is an unequal work, which means that it requires a first-rate performance to hold our attention from start to finish. Sadly, the Colin Davis performance does not achieve this and the mind wanders, but this performance by Pretre and the Orchestre de Paris is compelling throughout. Geoffrey Bellamy, in his 2012 review, has made the point that it "sounds French", and he is spot on! Not many previous performances possess that vital Gallic touch. He also makes the point that it is the soloists who will sell this performance: another bulls-eye on Geoffrey's part,.
From the opening, Nicolai Gedda's Faust arrests our immediate attention. The impression I have always felt is that the story has been going on for some time, and we are now allowed to become a part of it as listeners, so it does not actually "start" as such (Berlioz did the same kind of thing in "The Trojans", and Shakespeare likewise in "Cymbeline"). A risky beginning to any musical or literary undertaking, but it works in this recording. It is true to say that from here on, we are swept into Berlioz' world straight away.
In addition to Nicolai Gedda, we have the incomparable Janet Baker as Marguerite, Her arias in Part Three (CD 1, tracks 21/22) and in particular in Part Four (CD2 track 6) are masterly. Gabriel Bacquier (Mephiistopheles) also impresses, and relishes his mocking serenade (CD2, Track - "dans la Maison"): Pierre Thau has a fine time as Brander (CD1, Tracks 10 to 12). Other moments to savour are on CD1, Tracks 15 and 16, where Gedda, Bacquier and the Chorus lead us towards one of the work's most well-known episodes: the "Dance of the Sylphs". This is quite captivating, but so is Baker's "Autrefois un roi de Thule" and the following contribution by Bacquier leading us into another such episode: the Minuet of the Will o'-the Wisps (CD1, Tracks 22 to 24). How wonderful to hear two pieces, usually played seperately, in context with the whole. However, I was a little worried about the Hungarian March in Part 1, which got faster and faster towards the end. It finished as more of a Hungarian Gallop.
After Marguerite is committed to prison, Faust and Mephistophilese ride, not to rescue her, but into the Abyss: the ride and the resultant "Pandemonium" sequence are terrific: Berlioz - and indeed Pretre - throiw everything into this passage, culminating in the triumph of Mephistopheles. Then, as the Chorus inform us:"Alors, l'enfer se tut" (then Hell was silent), and the redemption of the soul of Marguerite begins. It is quite magical, with "une voix" plus an Angelic Choir, which brings this mighty work to a peaceful close. Romantic Musical Contrivance on Berlioz' part? Perhaps, but only to the cynical and sceptical, and it is a hard soul that will not be moved by these closing bars.
A pity that, although there is a good analysis in the accompanying programme notes, there is no actual libretto, but you can, of course down-load one if you wish. This is a fabulous CD, and I cannot recommend it too highly - and we must not forget the added bonus of Janet Baker in "La Mort du Cleopatre", this time with the LSO under Sir Alexander Gibson, although I suspect you may want to play this seperately, rather than just continue with the last track of CD2.
Although this recording dates back to 1969, the sound on the CD is clear - more than can be said of some recordings, and thus yet another reason to purchase. "This "Damnation of Faust" is a real experience, which I urge you to indulge in.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Inspirational,
This Faustian feast rivals Gounod's for melodies and drama. All round a spectacular piece and beautifully executed here. It seems to help that it is a French orchestra and chorus playing a French composer - joie de vivre!
4.0 out of 5 stars Berliozs best aria!,
For me the pearl in the huge piece is one of the greatest arias ever written, D'amour l'ardente flamme sung stunningly by Dame Janet Baker, Gedda for me as usual to dry of voice, where's the sap.
5.0 out of 5 stars Berlioz at his best,
Very nice to have the CDs to replace my much listened to old LPs. Berlioz, Baker, Gedda. Couldn't be better
Most Helpful First | Newest First
Berlioz: La Damnation de Faust - La Mort de Cléopatre by Georges Prêtre/Sir Alexander Gibson
Buy MP3 Album: £6.99