Customer Reviews


16 Reviews
5 star:
 (12)
4 star:    (0)
3 star:
 (1)
2 star:
 (2)
1 star:
 (1)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Real Meninblack
Ignore the dreaded 'concept album' tag, this is one that actually makes sense. Basically it floats the theory that Mankind was put on Earth by aliens as an experiment and they have visited to see what a success/hash we've made of it.The music, as you'd expect, is dark,hypnotic,repetitive but in no way boring. All the best albums create an atmosphere and this one has it in...
Published on 6 Nov. 2009 by S. Muzyka

versus
6 of 11 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars Or when the Stranglers lost the hooks and the plot.........,
The pub rockers hit the hit parade pay dirt in the summer of punk due thanks to the tough, catchy, slice-of-life numbers. That was good for a clutch of singles and a brace of albums. By 'Black and White' they still had the toughness but more varied dynamics alongside greater consistency of quality. 'The Raven' really raised the bar but tucked away on Side 2 was the...
Published on 20 Jun. 2011 by The Pop Picker


‹ Previous | 1 2 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Real Meninblack, 6 Nov. 2009
By 
S. Muzyka (Rugby,Warwickshire,England) - See all my reviews
Ignore the dreaded 'concept album' tag, this is one that actually makes sense. Basically it floats the theory that Mankind was put on Earth by aliens as an experiment and they have visited to see what a success/hash we've made of it.The music, as you'd expect, is dark,hypnotic,repetitive but in no way boring. All the best albums create an atmosphere and this one has it in spades. Highlights include opener 'Waltzinblack', 'Thrown Away' 'Turn the Centuries Turn' and my personal-all-time-favourite Stranglers track 'Second Coming'. The production is superb, the metallic drum sound created from Hugh Cornwell's idea of using portable tape recorders as drum mikes! The musicianship is of the Stranglers usual high standard, not that they ever get the credit for it by so-called music critics, and the mood it generates is compelling. If you're a casual fan that owns a greatest hits and little more, you may find the album a shock but I regard this album as essential if you want to call yourself a Stranglers fan. 'Rattus' and 'The Raven' run it close but for my money this is the Stranglers best record. Jean-Jacques Burnel has said the same in interviews and he should know!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Why don't people like it?, 5 Feb. 2011
I've never been sure whether it's this or The Raven I like more but it's always been clear to me that they are both the result of The Stranglers at their creative peak. The Raven is probably more adventurous music-wise but this beats it on the production/engineering front, and that's all (apparently) the tireless work of the Stranglers themselves. There's a very, very lovely warm sound to this stuff, despite its often-discussed weirdness - it sounds really like nothing else. Oh and the ideas are totally off the wall. Which is the very least we should demand from our pop stars. A brilliant, brilliant record which everyone should own and reassess on an almost daily basis.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


28 of 32 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The Stranglers feel the fear - and it IS g-e-n-i-u-s., 24 July 2002
Hello. I doubt Will Smith grooves much to this one. To be honest, neither do I - it's not that kind of an album, it's far too strange. It probably forms the centrepiece of the Annual Conspiracy Theorist's Convention After-Dinner Freak-Out ("How did you know?" gasp the conspiracy theorists, and I reply "<THEY> told me", to which they shrink fearfully away).
In this, the most marginal of all The Stranglers' work, Hugh and the gang offer us a dark and hypnotic soundtrack to the hypothesis of Biblical alien involvement. As with Radiohead's 'Kid A', 'Meninblack' (1981) was released in the wake of an acclaimed predecessor, and fans eagerly anticipating more of the same were disenchanted by the new sound. The situation was not improved when the least accessible track, 'Just Like Nothing On Earth' was issued as a single to promote the album, while prime chart material such as 'Two Sunspots' sat in conspicuous, upbeat solitude on the album.
Built on the foundations of paranoid doom laid in a track from 'The Raven', 'Meninblack' is a concept album years ahead of its time, with a strong, fluent narrative. The music is heavy and taut with the negativity and fear felt by the musicians during production.
All of which makes it sound like a really, really b-a-d listening experience. Well OK, it's true, you're not going to want this blasting out from your car stereo as you drive open-topped to the beach on a sunny day, nor as you attempt to lull yourself to sleep home alone at night. But on some other occasions, it's good: progressive, highly innovative, and intriguingly catchy. The sound has worn well: the passing of time has elevated the album within the context of its 'era' (I discovered it in 1993). Dave Greenfield's looping keyboards and synths are in the fore creating a trance-like ambience, never more so than in 'Waltzinblack', the beautiful yet grotesque opener. 'Turn The Centuries, Turn' and 'Hallow To Our Men' are hauntingly atmospheric; 'Two Sunspots' and 'Four Horsemen' have great melodies. Hugh lifts morale with occasional humour (er...sometimes at the expense of Jesus). All band members give it everything they've got, and the result is slick and seamless.
It's one of the most underappreciated records I can think of, and at or near to the pinnacle of The Stranglers' output. I'd say it's genius, but it's by no means to everyone's taste, and it's certainly no introduction to the band - that would be their debut 'Rattus Norveticus', or some 'Greatest Hits' affair. I'd recommend it to anyone with an interest in early Stranglers; fans of good keyboards; anyone up for testing the retrospective claim of bassist JJ Burnel that it sounds like a techno album; and Tommy Lee Jones. I expect it will also appeal to anyone who's gotten it into their head that Jesus was an alien.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


6 of 7 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Just Like Nothing On Earth, 9 July 2008
When this album first came out it annoyed a quite a few Stranglers fans and probably still does. Everyone (including myself) expected a bunch of aggressive pop songs. The first single 'Thrown Away' was quite low key in comparison to what had been released up until then. I was intrigued, gave it a good listen and then moved away.

It was only on it's re-release on CD that I gave it another go. This album has an importance and significance that was simply overshadowed by what had come before. Heard on it's own terms this album really shines out as something of a masterpiece.

I've given it 5 stars because it really is a 'fantastic' album both in terms of it's subject matter and it's sound. It displays everything that made the Stranglers great but in another form. I think that's what a lot of listeners can't easily accept. It's recklessly daring and truly inventive. No one else could have attempted a project such as this and done it so well.

The slightly disturbing thing about 'The Meninblack' is that the band totally believed in the premise underlying the songs. Could four rational men really go to such efforts to communicate this strange message to the world? Luckily, the answer is yes they could. But they certainly paid for it. This was (perhaps unsurprisingly) an unhappy time for the band. Their equipment got stolen, the band was arrested in Nice following a riot, Hugh Cornwell was jailed on drug posession charges and their tour manager died. As JJ Burnel said - "If you dwell on black things then black things will happen to you".

The critics savaged this album and it is to the bands credit that they managed to swiftly move on to achieve astonishing success with the album that was to follow - the 1981 album 'La Folie'. It's interesting to note that their most successful (and ivor novello award winning) single 'Golden Brown' was actually a discarded section from 'Second Coming' - track three on 'The Gospel According to The Meninblack'.

The least that can be said about this album is that it's a flawed masterpiece. Technically extraordinary and musically accomplished this album is not for everyone. But for those with ears to hear what's really going on this album really is just like nothing on earth.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


19 of 23 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Just like nothing on earth, 9 Feb. 2003
Will Smith fans take note... The Stranglers always were ahead of their time. In this case, almost 20 years ahead. In the late 70's The Stranglers were rough, ready and as far removed from polished productions and concept albums as a rock band could get. It was a bold and brave move then that they entered the 80s with "Meninblack". After the fantastic "Raven" album, Burnel and Cornwell went their seperate ways to persue solo projects, namely "Euroman Cometh" and "Nosferatu" respectively. This appears to have been a ingenious move on their part, for on their return to Stranglers duties the band's sound was totally transformed. The production on this album is as clean as anything you'll hear, the group's inventiveness and musical ability is so far removed from "Raven" it almost sounds like a different group. But production value and virtuosity aside, what makes an album truly great is simple : the songs. "Meninblack" doesn't disappoint. "Waltzinblack" is sublime, "Just like nothing on earth" and "Waiting for the meninblack" showcase Cornwell's unusual and hypnotic guitar skills and Burnel's magnificent bass lines, while "Two sunspots" is a perfect melodic 3 minute "pop" song. "Thrown away" is quite simply one of the band's finest melodies. As for anyone put off by the very mention of "concept" albums, I'd ignore that tag. If there is a thread within these songs, it's almost impossible to follow. Just put on your headphones and enjoy the experience.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


10 of 13 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars HI-FI SCI-FI, 22 May 2007
By 
Kelvin Dickinson (Leeds, England) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)   
This is a weird album. I could grab a thesaurus and maybe find an alternative but...no, weird's definitely the word.

That isn't to say it's unlikeable, far from it. For a start, it's so heavily-themed that for once the concept doesn't run out of steam after the first couple of songs (unlike THE RAVEN and it's hastily explored then ignored Nordic mythology schtick). Happily, the same can also be said for the bonus tracks which, apart from the gruesomely anachronistic TOMORROW WAS THE HEREAFTER, tie in neatly with echoes and ideas cribbed from such luminaries as Erich Von Daniken, Robert A. Heinlein and...Klaatu (misunderstood alien emissary, 'The Day The Earth Stood Still'). It is, in other words, a large slice of Pseudo-Profound Tosh. They know it and we know it. Eat your robotic heart out Isaac Asimov.

The production reflects this hi-fi sci-fi, with DAVE GREENFIELD's keyboards dominating the proceedings and providing the requisite amount of bleeps and whirrs, most noticeably on track two's, JUST LIKE NOTHING ON EARTH. Similarly, HUGH CORNWELL's guitar has been geared towards a more ethereal, otherworldly sound (TWO SUNSPOTS) and the same again for JEAN-JACQUES BURNEL's bass; previous rough edges softened leaving it more melodic, yet aloof, in the process (SECOND COMING). It's down to good old JET BLACK's relentless drum patterns to provide the solid backbone to this album's experimental feel - and to keep at least one foot on terra firma. Of all the MeninBlack, he'd be the last guy you'd choose to don a spacesuit for delicate EVA duties.

The songs are, without exception, highly effective. Leapfrogging the wonderful but ubiquitous WALTZINBLACK, the standout track for me is THROWN AWAY, a little pop gem, part spoken, part-sung, with a simplicity unlike any other track on the album. Sometimes less really is more. The pounding, cyclical, TURN THE CENTURIES TURN is a multilayered instrumental affair that works those high and low frequencies with a vengeance. Play loud. Picking up the pace is TWO SUNSPOTS, a lively number which has echoes of NO MORE HEROES lurking within it's core, followed by FOUR HORSEMEN, a catchy, mid-tempo, but slightly formula Stranglers song. Good stuff nonetheless. And see how the concept's still holding up?

More complex than 'The Da Vinci Code', heaps more fun than 'Stargate: Atlantis', quality and continuity is firmly at the heart of THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO THE MENINBLACK and we're very well rewarded for seeing it through to conclusion. Do buy it.

Oh, and check out that cover. Sorry to report to the Younger Generation but the original 12" GATEFOLD SLEEVE was SO much nicer. Sometimes size really does matter, kids.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Wacky, Inventive, Brilliant, 26 Oct. 2014
By 
Their difficult fifth album that wasn't very commercial at the time but now appears to be one of the greatest things they ever did.

A wacky conspiracy theory concept album covering everything from The Bible, ETI's and the menacing Men In Black, it's a tour de force of strange and bizzare concepts that holds together due to the sheer genius and musicality of the band.

Worth it for the stunning final track Hallow To Our Men alone, every track on it is interesting.

Very good album.

Highly Recommended, a must buy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


11 of 14 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The best of the best, 20 Jun. 2004
By 
andy furkins (Swindon, Wilts United Kingdom) - See all my reviews
Quiet simply my favourite Stranglers album of the lot. But it is different, very different, but all in all magnificent. If you're prepared to open your ears and listen to this you'll be pleased that you've done so.
Buy it, enjoy it and enjoy your own second coming.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


12 of 16 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Innovative, thought provoking and way ahead of its time., 6 Aug. 2001
By A Customer
The Stranglers 'The Gospel According To The Meninblack' explored the mysterious world of UFOs a long time before the 90s vogue for it came along with The X Files and the Will Smith movie 'Men in Black'. The album itself is evocative, packed with terrific songs such as 'Just Like Nothing on Earth', 'The Meninblack (waiting for 'em),'Turn The Centuries Turn' and the hit single that should have been - 'Two Sunspots'. It was a brave move by the Stranglers to make this album, artistically, commercially and - if you know of the strange chain of deaths, imprisonments, theft and bad luck that accompanied the group in this period - in terms of their own well being. The Meninblack is a fascinating, evocative work, dark at times but always underpinned by melodic and memorable songs and dotted throughout with the odd humour and wit that was the band's trademark. A groundbreaking album by a brilliant group. Add it to your collection now.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant album, 22 April 2013
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This is a great album. If you like The Stranglers then it's worth getting. I spent years listening to the LP version, it's nice to listen to it without all the hiss and crackle!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


‹ Previous | 1 2 | Next ›
Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Only search this product's reviews