on 4 November 2006
An excellent version, nicely sung and recorded, with excellent performances of all the "big" numbers - brisk, but never breathless. The soloists (no big names) are uniformly good.
Only one (personal) reservation - I'm very partial to the spine-chilling counter-tenor version of "For He is like a refiner's fire", done best of all by Paul Esswood for Charles Mackerras. As this recording seeks to provide the first Dublin performance, we get the less virtuosic bass version of that version. But that's my only quibble. Highly recommended.
on 22 February 2007
Having listened to many of the various versions of Messiah, and previously having had The English Concert/Pinnock (Archiv) as my top choice, this new release from the Dunedin Consort has now surpassed that. Sure, it's sometimes tricky to compare recordings of different performing versions of the Messiah (of which there are many) but this recording of the 1742 Dublin version, whilst it might have been originally adapted by Handel to cater for soloists of perhaps a lesser quality than he could lay his hands on elsewhere, is by no means a 'poorer' version for that, certainly if this recording is anything to go by.
Where this recording really excels is the superb diction of both choir and the soloists drawn from within. Maybe easier to achieve with smaller forces than on most other recordings but the diction is supreme nonetheless. Clare Wilkinson's 'He Was Despised' comes up in quite the most heart rending and tragic rendition I have ever heard (which is how it should be) and is for me, the premier highlight amongst many. The overall oratorio is presented with such charm and the sense that Charles Jennens' collection of Scriptures is narrated as an entire story from start to finish.
The playing of the Dunedin Players is superb and the balance between choir and instrumentalists in the Hallelujah Chorus in particular is supreme and produces a rendition most joyful, (aided by the wonderfully punchy trumpets and timpani) far removed from the Victoriana pomposity of a number of older versions and the numerous 'Come Along and Sing' Hallelujahs (and Messiahs in general) frequently put on each year.
Quite the most sublime and joyful recorded version of Messiah I've ever heard. The Dunedin Consort and Players (not to mention John Butt!) should be proud.
on 27 December 2006
I just thought I'd point out that this performance uses the 6-8 version of Rejoice. I've looked at that in the score but I've never heard it performed. I found it utterly charming.
Overall, having performed Messiah more times than I care to count, this performance is an enjoyable, new look at the work. At least, new to me.
on 11 January 2008
There are many versions of 'Messiah' available, ranging from those with choirs in the hundreds(Sargent. Beecham, et al)to those with much smaller choirs and with period instruments (Pinnock and others). But even if you have these, the is a version in the 'must have' category. There are only 13 choir members and the soloists 'double' from the choir. This would be an approach quite familiar to Handel; many oratorios were performed thus.In this version every crotchet is absolutely accurate; reading against the 'Dublin' score, and there are only trivial and very few 'cuts'. The sheer musicality has, in my view, never been achieved before - and I have been listening to 'Messiah' in live performance and on disc for over 50 years. Every aria and every chorus is 'fresh' and the diction, intonation, musical nuance and breath control are all superb. If you buy an oratorio disc this year, and even if you have many versions of Messiah, this is a 'must have'. Moving and memorable - quite outstanding.
This is my ideal Messiah, a work I had never taken to until I actually began to like, then love then adore, the rest of the music of its composer.
So I felt I must get a Messiah, listen, and make up my mind again. I read reviews, listened to excerpts, made a judicious choice. What a happy choice I made, since this is one of the most joyous recordings I can imagine of this all too famous work, and is blessed with a musical and emotional approach exactly right if, like me, you don't want or need a Messiah which has bombast to spare, sung by 'big' voices from the world of opera.
Not that there is anything 'small' or lacking in this performance. In fact, the vocal and orchestral colours are so well highlighted that the whole thing becomes almost a sacrament in itself - and I speak as one who is by no means 'religious' in any orthodox sense of the word.
John Butt conducts the superb Dunedin Consort & Players, from whom the featured singers have been plucked. And what a very fine quintet of singers they are, each with his or her own distinctive style, while honouring totally the words and music they are singing. Nicholas Mulroy's nicely robust tenor is the first voice we hear and is a tonic, equalled by the other four: soprano Susan Hamilton, contralto Clare Wilkinson, Matthew Brook's rock-solid bass, and Annie Gill's rather unusual contralto, which took a while getting used to, until I simply relaxed and let her sing to me.
Susan Hamilton's affectingly unfussy reading of I know that my Redeemer liveth - to take only one example from this feast of good taste and tact - is like pretty much everything here: unselfconsciously touching, weighty without unnecessary grandeur, wholly lacking in needless pomp, with attention to emotion and meaning uppermost, while not once resorting to generality of either.
It is beautifully packaged - with Rembrandt all over the cover - including an informative booklet with carefully laid out notes, biographies, and the oratorio's text with, I'm glad to say, a note as to who is singing what, as well as from where in the Bible each passage is taken. It really couldn't be better, and is as carefully and lovingly presented as the work itself.
I can't praise this 2006 recording too highly. Others may be grander or have more 'oomph' but to me this is a perfectly paced, gracefully sung and played jewel of a Messiah which I shall treasure, and play a couple of times a year when I simply have to hear it.
I think I chose well!
Most highly recommended.
on 28 April 2009
If you're looking for a grandiose and majestic Messiah, then stop reading now. Beecham is the chap. This is a small-scale performance, with twelve singers and around that number of players, in an exploration not only of the content, but also the scale, of the work's first outing in Dublin.
As might be expected, the tempi are generally brisker than a larger performance, but never overly rushed, and not relentlessly fast. What really stands out is the elegant phrasing, the razor sharp ensemble, and the diction; you can hear every note and every word.
on 20 December 2010
I have for years (at Christmas time) listened to the Pinnock version, which is fantastic. With the Butt/Dunedin Consort & Players, which I have only heard a few times, I think of words such as depth, delicate, refined and musicality. Another fantastic version. We are fortunate to be able to have such music available to us so easily. It is divine.
on 27 February 2014
For years I had viewed Messiah with horror, big modern orchestra and large chorus just do not do it justice in my opinion. I was not even tempted to try again even with a number of period instrument recordings appearing. I purchased the CD of this shortly after it came out and the scales fell from my eyes - simply wonderful and a thing of beauty. It is simple, other than strings, continuo and organ there are only 2 natural trumpets and the best sounding timpani I have ever heard. The soloists reinforce the chorus which from memory makes a total of 12 singers. It is clean and fresh and a revelation.
With brisk tempi, clear enunciation and clean and uncluttered scoring the Dublin version allows the unvarnished beauty of the piece to become apparent. The small forces can still achieve a good volume and magnificence - Worthy is the Lamb and the Amen in particular are truly splendid. The recording quality is very fine and one can hear everything clearly.
My only gripe is the download. On my kindle I cannot scroll all the way to the end and and on my PC disc2 comes first so a bit of readjusting needed.
That notwithstanding this is a joy.