39 of 40 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars HORROR MASTERPIECE
At last a decent DVD release for this disturbing classic from nearly fifty years ago. Vilified and treated like a video nasty on its initial release this trip inside the mind of a pyschopath is still so fresh and refreshing. Recommended for all students of serious horror, the tale of a disturbed young mind with a blade on his camera tripod filming his victims...
Published on 30 Mar 2007 by Anton
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Open up your peepers for peeping Tom!
I enjoyed the modesty of this film, and the complexity of the portrayal of the human mind. The film debated what drives someone to go to the cinema to watch murder, sex and violence? A very brave film for its time, it threw back questions that the audience weren't ready to be answered. Definately a head of its time, caused much contraversy (according to my film lecturer)...
Published on 13 Aug 2003 by gemcoombe
Most Helpful First | Newest First
39 of 40 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars HORROR MASTERPIECE,
This review is from: Peeping Tom - Special Edition [DVD]  (DVD)At last a decent DVD release for this disturbing classic from nearly fifty years ago. Vilified and treated like a video nasty on its initial release this trip inside the mind of a pyschopath is still so fresh and refreshing. Recommended for all students of serious horror, the tale of a disturbed young mind with a blade on his camera tripod filming his victims expressions as he kills them is utterly gripping. Acting all round is top notch in a production way ahead of it's time. Recommended.
29 of 30 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The film that was scarier that Psycho!,
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars has retained its disturbing power,
This review is from: Peeping Tom - Special Edition [DVD]  (DVD)Peeping Tom (1960)
This is one of those films that is well preceded by its backstory. Director Michael Powell, one half of one of Britain's most famous filmmakers, Powell and Pressburger, committed career suicide with this film. The British public were so offended by this offering that the studios pretty much closed their doors to him, and one of our greatest filmmakers ever was prematurely finished, at the height of his powers. Only later, championed by the likes of Scorcese, did the world reevaluate Peeping Tom, and come to agree that it is a masterpiece. As a loss to filmmaking, it seems a similar story to that of Buster Keaton, after making the General, when it was a massive flop, and Keaton was not allowed the freedom to make his own films any more. He became a sideman, tied to a long-running inescapable contract, and ended up a frustrated alcoholic. Later, the film was recognised to be a masterpiece, some say the greatest silent film ever made, and one wistfully wonders what he might have produced had he not had his creative hands tied in such disastrous fashion.
This film, as you'd expect upon hearing of the reaction it forced from the public of the time, is brutal and shocking. Compared to Psycho (although Hitchcock suffered no similar public disgust), it is the story of a man who is only a "focus puller" in the movies, but who longs to be a film-maker. In his part time, he kills women with his camera, filming their last moments. By seeing what he sees while he does it, we are drawn into the murderer's mind perhaps more than in other killer films, and one wonders if this is one reason it feels so much more uncomfortable than other killer movies. Another reason for the outcry is that we don't see this man as just a cold-blooded killer. We learn some of his backstory, his painful childhood under a damaging and abusive father, who would wake his son in the middle of the night to film his terrified reaction to having a lizard dropped in his bed. Interestingly, these film flashbacks star the director Powell and his real-life son.
We gain sympathy for the killer, and understand some of his motives. He isn't sadistic. You get the feeling he doesn't like what he does, that he is messed up and confused and needs help. He is shy, nervous, and you can sense a longing to be rid of the nightmare and to be saved. His biggest chance of salvation comes from a neighbour, played by Anna Massey, although her blind mother, fantastically played by Maxine Audley, has strong reservations about the whole thing (as you may expect). But the more she delves into his past and his troubles, the more risk she runs of becoming his next victim, even though he's desperate for that not to happen. As we can see he wants her to be OK too, we see he is not fully in control, and is almost (but not quite) as powerless as we are. Thus we feel we are in the grip of something else, which is a very clever sensation, and almost pulls us away from hating HIM. We hate what he is fighting. We hate his father for having donet his to him. It's an interesting and very powerful sensation.
The cast are excellent, the story compelling, but the standout is the direction. Every shot is interesting and unusual, the colours strong and vivid, and the overall effect is one of continued creepiness. The whole film is soaked in unease, and I genuinely worried for all the people in the film. It almost felt as if there was no "baddy", certainly not in the normal serial killer sense, and I think that may be the thing that so terrified the people who ended up killing the film a few days into its initial release. I'm glad I got to see it, but I'm not sure I'd want to watch it again. It felt an ordeal, but a powerful and memorable one. Still, after all these years, the film has retained it's power to cause deep unease, in some ways even more than the more celebrated Psycho. It's a powerful film, and one can't help but wonder what Powell might have gone on to create. Above all the acted deaths in the film that people were upset by, it's the real death of Powell's film career, that their reaction caused, that we should mourn the most.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A great movie which some find unpleasant,
This review is from: Peeping Tom - Special Edition [DVD]  (DVD)This is a great, unpleasant, disturbing film made by Michael Powell three years after he and his partner in the Archers, Emeric Pressburger, went their own ways. British critics loathed it, said so loudly, and the movie died within weeks of its release. Some say it destroyed Powell's career.
Mark Lewis (Carl Boehm) is a young man who works as a camera puller at a movie studio, who also at night photogaphs girlie pictures for magazines. His father, a psychologist, studied the effects of fear by putting his son in terrible situations and then photographing the child's reactions. Lewis lives in the second floor of a house and often watches those movies while he sits alone in the dark.
Lewis also does something else. In the tripod of his camera there is a concealed knife. As he photographs a girl the knife pushes into her, while the camera films her face as she realizes she is going to die and then while she is dying. He plays back these movies, too. As you watch Peeping Tom you become a voyeur participant in what he is doing. He meets the young woman who lives below him and it is apparent that she is at first curious about him, but then attracted to him. He finds within himself an attraction that might be love, might be salvation, but which is conflicted. The movie plays out with tension, remorse and even sympathy. The ending is somewhat unexpected, but with hindsight also inevitable.
And maybe that is what made this movie so controversial. Lewis is a sympathetic figure. You know what his father put him through because you've watched those old movies. Boehm playes Lewis as a shy, nice, rather sad young man. Anna Massey, who plays Helen Stephens, the girl on the first floor, is a first-rate actress and in this role she is excellent. She eventually realizes something is wrong with Lewis, but still wants to give him love and help.
This movie was released just weeks after Psycho. Hitchcock's career was enhanced, Powell's was hurt. I think the difference was that while Norman Bates was weird to begin with and the frights were real, you could laugh at yourself afterward. Not so with Peeping Tom. The voyeur aspect of the deaths still make a viewer uncomfortable, and you can easily feel sad about the damaged Mark Lewis.
For fans of Michael Powell, he plays Mark Lewis' father in the old movie clips that show the fear experiments. Powell's young son played the young Mark Lewis.
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars "I'm from the Observer..",
By A Customer
Presented in anamorphic widescreen, Peeping Tom shows the seedy-looking cinematography in all of its glory, and the soundtrack is pin-sharp, making the most of Brian Easdale's haunting piano music.
Buy this for the film, not for the extras.
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Still groundbreaking, a work of art,
Peeping Tom still has the power to divide audiences, with viewers typically split between finding it fascinating or boring. Given the manner in which cinema has upped the ante on depictions of sadism and brutality since Powell made this film, it's not surprising that many are disappointed with the lack of graphic violence or gore on display, or the films disdain for a conventional "thriller" type atmosphere.
However, on a cerebral level, Peeping Tom retains its capacity to disturb. Rarely has a film depicted the process of a killer being created so chillingly, nor the manner in which such individuals are capable of conflicted, dualistic personalities. Consider how many serial killers have been described to be charming and kind by others who knew them (Dennis Nilsen or Ted Bundy for example). The scenes showing this transition from shy man-child to confident killer are masterful, with Carl Boehm overcoming other more obvious limitations in his casting (the accent mainly) to portray this aspect unerringly.
Yes, Peeping Tom is a flawed film in some respects, but I believe it to be a masterpiece nonetheless. Its detractors point to the staged and somewhat theatrical feel of it and the melodramatic ending, but the extent to which it immerses you in the murky and deeply melancholy inner world of such a damaged man, as well as a grimy and realistic view of British society in the late 50's, more than compensate. It is an intriguing and complex film, raising questions about our own desire to watch what we are seeing on the screen, and begs discussion about its numerous themes and subtexts. It is quite rightly in my opinion described as a work of art, with all of the demands that art places upon the appreciator to lose themselves a little in the pursuit of some semi-hidden and undefinable truth.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Stunning film,
Amazon Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Peeping Tom - Special Edition [DVD]  (DVD)It may be uncomfortable viewing at times but this is a film that has belatedly become a classic. The performances of Carl Boehm and Anna Maasey are brilliant. This special edition dvd includes a really informative audio commentary and is a great addition to the film. A film that can be watched many times. 5 stars.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars TRULY AHEAD OF ITS TIME !,
This review is from: Peeping Tom [VHS]  (VHS Tape)Truly ahead of its time, Michael Powell excelled himself and the minds of his audience with this extraodinary piece of work.
I remember first seeing this as a naive 12 year old late one night on BBC2 and it was the first film that truly moved me in a unexplainable way.
As you expect from Powell the use of colour is stunning, coupled with a difficult storyline. The film was panned on release and only due to the likes of Martin Scorsese has it become the classic that it always was.
Simply stunning, and easily ranks among Powell's best work. Buy it !
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Stunning quality release.,
This review is from: Peeping Tom Special Edition [Blu-ray]  (Blu-ray)Mainly I agree with the other review, the picture and sound quality are phenomenal for this unfairly maligned horror classic. Literally I've never seen it looking better in any previous release.
Extras wise you get...Audio commentary with ian christie, eye of the beholder featurette, The strange gaze of mark lewis featurette, interview with thelma schoonmaker (longtime scorsese editor) introduction by scorsese, a restoration comparison, trailers and stills gallery.
A Lot of these bonus features turned up on the dvd edition so the main reaseon to buy the blu-ray is the picture quality, it is marvelous so I would definately recommned jacking in the dvd releases.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A disturbing, classic.,
This review is from: Peeping Tom - Special Edition [DVD]  (DVD)This is not for the faint hearted although most of the violence is off camera. It is a disturbing classic which has aged well. There was a Making of documentary with this which was also very informative.
Most Helpful First | Newest First
Peeping Tom - Special Edition [DVD]  by Michael Powell (DVD - 2007)
Used & New from: £5.99