Shop now Shop now Shop now  Up to 50% Off Fashion  Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Listen with Prime Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5 stars3
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star
Format: DVD|Change
Price:£6.55+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

Your rating(Clear)Rate this item
Share your thoughts with other customers

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 24 January 2010
This is a movie well worth investigating and makes an ideal companion piece to Walter Ruttman's 1927 classic "Berlin, Symphony of a Great City".

Both came towards the end of the silent era, amid the explosion of creativity and experimentation which marked the tumultuous Weimar years and offer a visual feast of candid images, of life in Berlin immediately before the dawning of the Third Reich.

Whereas Ruttman's film is a montage depicting the city as a living, breathing organism, through the juxtaposition of industrial machinery, light, traffic and the movement of people as they go about their daily routine, Robert Siodmak's "Menschen am Sonntag" (which is also credited to Billy Wilder among other notables) follows four young Berliners who escape the tedium of their working week by spending a day together at the Nikolassee on the edge of the city.

"People on Sunday announces itself as a 'film without actors': the five principals are all amateurs, who actually worked in the jobs described in the film: taxi driver, music shop assistant, wine salesman, film extra, mannequin. Yet their performances are strikingly natural and unselfconscious. Since they all had weekday jobs, the film was shot over a number of Sundays during the summer of 1929, and the sense of unforced credibility must derive from the fact that these were exactly what the title says - ordinary Berliners on their day off, doing pretty much what they would have been doing in any case." (Philip Kemp, DVD liner notes).

A certain degree of sexual tension inhabits this movie, as one might expect given the initial scenario: Taxi driver Erwin lives in an apparently tumultuous relationship with model Annie who can't quite make it out of bed to enjoy the promise of an adventure by the lake. Their mutual friend, Wolf, the travelling wineseller (what a cad!) has however just struck up a friendship on the street (his pick-up routine must be seen to be believed!) with film extra Christl and, well, why not a double date then? The four of us? And Annie if she can make it, but I doubt it.

And so the day by the Nikolassee unfolds, with its flirtations, calamities, jealousies, petty squabbles and occasional hilarity.

But it is also the context for all of this which makes the film so important: here not far from the cusp of a massive social and political upheaval are a million picture postcard images of the life of the common man, woman and child as they go about their lives, away from the mind-numbing grind of the working week. Background images neither scripted nor posed, principal characters moving fluidly and purposefully through the place and the time. They are a part of that real world, not pasted to it. And importantly, these scenes would have been played out too throughout the immediate pre-war years and beyond, so this picture of life as it was lived by urban dwellers is equally relevant to students of the National Socialist years.

All too quickly though the weekend ends. Some relationships may have permanently shifted. The working week, with its inevitability and its tedium now await. But so too once again will there be the tantalising promise of further reward and release. "Maybe next week, Wolf?"

The (2000) soundtrack, composed by Elena Kats-Chernin and performed by the Czech Film Orchestra is an outstanding one, and is available on iTunes. (As is another version, under the English title "People on Sunday", but it is quite different. I'd stick with the film version).

Berlin, Symphony of a Great City is available through IHF.

For a comprehensive and thoroughly absorbing overview of all things Weimar, Erik D Weitz's "Weimar Germany, Promise and Tragedy" (Princeton University Press, 2007) is an ideal starting point.
0Comment|24 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 July 2007
If you enjoy classic silent cinema then you won't want to miss this. At times the odd scene is reminiscent of King Vidor's The Crowd, made just the year before (most especially in those moments set indoors, during which one of the couples gently bicker or the scene during which the principals first meet up for their group date); while at others the open air, carefree mood is suggestive of Renoir's masterpiece Partie de Campagne, made a decade later. But People on Sunday is a distinct work in its own right, an evocative film made by some stellar talent as already noted by other reviewers here: the Siodmak brothers, Edgar Ulmer, Billy Wilder and Fred Zimmerman - all of whom would go on to varying degrees of success in the States after fleeing the Nazis. Their film is thus both a record of a time lost, a beautifully shot piece showing a Berlin that was soon to vanish for ever, as well as demonstrating the collaborative talents of some major figures in their early years. There is no hint of the dark years to come seen here, or the debilitating effects of run away inflation which marked the end of the Weimar Republic and led to the inexorable rise of extreme politics. People on Sunday is above social comment, unless it is political by the fact of focusing on ordinary people. It simply tells the tale of a group (played by non professional actors we are informed, but it hard to tell) enjoying themselves while out on one sunny weekend day, picnicking, boating, kissing, promising more to each other and so on, interspersed with more general shots of the German people similarly at play. The skill and pleasure for the viewer is in the way this is done, completely without ostentation, shot marvelously, everything still feeling fresh, spontaneous and genuine today, and done with a real feeling for place. In fact so much of the film seems easy and laid back then one just knows that it is an illusion; such art takes a great deal of time, patience and skill.

If you want to see more of German cinema from this period, other than more familiar classics, then this is a real treat being both less known and marvelously restored. The BFI DVD version has been created from several sources and is the longest version available. It also features a splendid Weill-like score, which fits the milieu like a glove.
0Comment|28 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 8 November 2015
Great move I'm a silent movie fan
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)