Customer Reviews

2 Reviews
5 star:
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
Most Helpful First | Newest First

17 of 17 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A collosal disco anthology !!!!, 14 Jan. 2005
This review is from: Mixed With Love (Audio CD)
A magnificent tribute to one of the first DJs to really remix tracks for the dancefloor -- the groundbreaking Walter Gibbons, a key force in the sound of Salsoul Records during its early years! Gibbons' approach was always dramatic -- really pulling apart and remixing the tracks with a groove that differed from the original -- and working in styles that were later taken up more heavily in early hip hop and house production, but which were quite revolutionary at the time. In the years before Larry Levan rose to prominence, Gibbons was one of the first DJs to move from the clubs into the studio -- and the result is an amazing legacy of remix work for Salsoul, nearly all of which is captured here in an overstuffed 3CD set! The set features 29 tracks in all, plus a wonderfully done booklet on Gibbons' life, times, and technique -- with tracks that include Gibbons' remixes of "Your Cheatin Heart" by Robin Hooker Band, "Cheaters Never Win" by Love Committee, "I Wish That I Could Make Love To You" by Double Exposure, "Catch Me On The Rebound" by Loleatta Holloway, "Block Party" by Anthony White, "Nice N Naasty" by Salsoul Orchestra, "As Long As You Love Me" by True Example, "Ice Cold Love" by Double Exposure, "Rocket Rock" by Luv You Madly Orchestra, "Salsoul 3001" by Salsoul Orchestra, "Super Queen" by Cellophane, and "Hit & Run" by Loleatta Holloway
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Them Polls Are Always Wrong, 24 May 2010
This review is from: Mixed With Love (Audio CD)
What is the best album ever made?

There is no such thing.

Seriously - how can there be a best ever album? It doesn't make sense. How can you quantify music (apart from in sales - in 'units' [urgh!])? How can the artful be rendered so artless? Yes, yes, yes these lists are fun, and yes they make for debate - but debate about what? Usually - because pop 'n' rock has a substantial body of work now - it's a debate about how one fairly average best selling album by a serious bunch of rock artists is better than another similar album.

Albums that are ALWAYS mentioned in such lists: 'Pet sounds' (fair enough - but I know it now, thanks) - 'Sgt Pepper' (not even the best Beatles record) - 'vu - banana album' (see 'pet sounds' comment, but ammend with - aye, but there was only mr peel who cared at the time).

Albums that HAVE been mentioned - 'Aja' (honestly, I'm not making this up), 'ok computer' (good voice, maybe two good songs, boring everything else), 'Astral weeks' (paint dryingly dull)

Albums that are NEVER mentioned: 'The Payback' (JB), 'Get up with it' (Miles), 'Diana' (ross) and now, ladies and gentlemen, another to correct the all-time list, 'Mixed with love'.

Apart from the 6 tracks from an album called 'Disco madness', these tracks are from 12" singles and the odd album track. They make for a surpisingly cohesive collection. They show, in fact, that Walter Gibbons was a genius.


I said 'genius'.

For the beats he innovates, for the dub inflexions, for the re-edits and deconstructions, for the fun, for the inventiveness. That he was working with some of the best singers and artists (Loleatta Holloway) was his good fortune - that they were working with Mr Gibbons was their blessing.

Even when given a half-arsed track, the man spins gold. The euro-novelty nonsense of Cellophane sudenly becomes future house trance classics - TWICE - and this is from 1979!! The silly camp country covers of 'Stand by your man' & 'Your cheatin' heart' become epic, touching, spell-binding.

Every trick in dance over the last 25-30 years can be traced back to these tracks. How on earth he's slipped through the net I don't know. Perhaps because of prejudice - after all, disco sucks.

Disco sucks because it was gay.

Sorry, I forgot.

Wasn't rock supposed to do away with all that? Wasn't CSNY, Jefferson Airplane, Jimi et al, supposed to bring us all together?

Disco, sir, did all the things that rock was supposed to do but DIDN'T. Disco brought blacks, whites, Puerto Ricans, gays and straights together to dance, have good times and listen to some fine mind-blowing music.

None of which has ever been bettered than here. More consistent than Moroder/Summer, less uniform than Philladelphia, more inventive than Salsoul's other supposedly weird compilation 'Disco trance and cosmic flavas', this, ladies and gentlemen, is one of the greatest records ever made. If such things exist, which, of course, they don't.

But just in case they DO, try this:

The best record ever made.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Mixed With Love
Mixed With Love by Walter Gibbons (Audio CD - 2008)
Add to wishlist See buying options
Only search this product's reviews