Customer Reviews


3 Reviews
5 star:    (0)
4 star:
 (1)
3 star:
 (2)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Worth it for the "Specialist."
As the previous review states, there are few surprises on the EP, and to be honest it will most likely only appeal to those who are after everything the band has done. But if you are an Interpol fan, then I would particularly recommend the EP for, "The Specialist" alone. A long song with many changes, some fantastic lines and an etheral riff that kicks in towards the end.
Published on 14 Mar 2005 by S Moran

versus
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Collectors only
If You're familiar with Interpol, you already know how good these songs are. You already know that 'Say Hello to the Angels' is one of the most epic, thrilling and decadently gloomy songs to be made in the 21st Century. That NYC is beutiful in its sad simplicity. That Obstacle 1 is the blueprint for a number of cheap immitators like 'Editors' and...
Published on 18 Nov 2005 by futureman24


Most Helpful First | Newest First

7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Worth it for the "Specialist.", 14 Mar 2005
This review is from: The Black EP (Audio CD)
As the previous review states, there are few surprises on the EP, and to be honest it will most likely only appeal to those who are after everything the band has done. But if you are an Interpol fan, then I would particularly recommend the EP for, "The Specialist" alone. A long song with many changes, some fantastic lines and an etheral riff that kicks in towards the end.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


16 of 19 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Collectors only, 18 Nov 2005
This review is from: The Black EP (Audio CD)
If You're familiar with Interpol, you already know how good these songs are. You already know that 'Say Hello to the Angels' is one of the most epic, thrilling and decadently gloomy songs to be made in the 21st Century. That NYC is beutiful in its sad simplicity. That Obstacle 1 is the blueprint for a number of cheap immitators like 'Editors' and to some extent the Killers.
The Reason you know this stuff is that you have 'Turn On the Bright Lights'. It's true there's not nearly enough Interpol material about, so Demo's and session tracks of some of the album's best moments will seem a worthwhile addition to your collection. Unfortunatley the alternate versions of songs just simply aren't different enough to be worth looking into for the most part.
Most of the 'Black Session' songs are just lacklustre live tracks which are quite badly recorded, they never seem to be loud enough. The recordings are lacking a great deal of Bass and when you have a Bassist as unquestionably superb as Carlos D, this is inexcusable. Interpol have improved as a live act to an extent where watching them now is a truly amazing experience, in this sense 'The Black EP' is an unfairly underwhelming impression of a phenominal band.
While the inclusion of non album track 'The Specialist' may be enough to tempt you, there are infinitley better versions of it. The one found here is a little too quick and lacks the real version's seductive menace.
So a massive fan or obsessive collector may want it for the sake of having a few live tracks and the admittedly cool artwork but other than that 'The Black EP' has little to offer, 'Turn On the Bright Lights' and 'Antics' However are a different matter altogether...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


17 of 39 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Not the blatant rip-off one might have feared..., 14 Sep 2003
By 
Oleg Puchko "Mr Carbohydrate" (Kiev, Ukraine) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: The Black EP (Audio CD)
Oh, Interpol, haven’t they done well, whatdoyathink? Admiration of cosmic proportions in a space of couple of years – from everyone in NME to Pitchfork via thousands of great music lovers worldwide who were tired of being force-fed with the campness of The Strokes from the cover of each and every magazine (every issue)? Check. Brilliant debut album that still thrills more and more every time it finds its way into one’s ears? Check. Making leather coats in music cool again? Check. Providing blusting soundtrack to Charlie’s Angels: Full Throttle? Eh, well, no, this one was just made up actually, but hey, Interpol do seem capable of everything these days.
Anyway. And now – this.
God only knows why this was named The Black EP, maybe Interpol are planning a series of this stop-gap releases in style of Trois Couleurs movie-series (hey, The Orange EP sounds particularly promising to me) or they just finally found the perfect outlet for their secret admiration of Jack Black. The content is all that matters here and I’m afraid it’s a little thin on surprises – and more importantly – new material.
6 tracks (OK, so you DO qualify for EP status here, unlike, say, some UK half-decent bands releasing 1 and a half track single and calling it EP too), one (Say Hello To The Angels) in its LP version, demo of NYC and 4 live tracks. Say Hello…, one of the true hightlights of Interpol’s debut, pretty much still rocks like hell giving The Strokes run for their money and remaining in you head for… like forever, even after its first listen. NYC demo is indeed all things demos should be: stripped down and lacking the polished production of its final incarnation, this can only be described as a damn fine garage ballad (it was previously released in UK as a b-side to double feature single of Say Hello To The Angels/NYC). And the live tracks from the so called Black Sessions (o-o-oh, that’s where the bloody name comes from. I see…)? Well, they’re OK too, I suppose, being somewhat less intense takes on already familiar songs (except the rare just-above-average Specialist) that will undoubtedly convince all the remaining unbelievers (are there any left?) in… oh yes… Interpol is indeed the second coming of Joy Division whether you want to accept it or not (check the opening drums and the so-Ian-Curtis-voice-it-hurts on PDA and the atmospheric Leif Erikson). Most of the Black Sessions tracks were already released in UK on the flipsides and as bonus audio material to Obstacle 1 CD and DVD single respectively. And so that you know – the complete Black Sessions bootleg is the most popular and available unofficial recording of the band on the net.
Now, all is well, but surely (bloody obvious more like) the idea of more rare material finding place on this release would have been appropriately more exciting? Interlude from the Japanese edition of Turn On The Bright Lights or the original version of Specialist originally included on Aussie LP? A Time To Be Small, which is almost forgotten at this point? Hell, Arthur Baker remix of Obstacle 1? I understand that The Black EP is aimed squarely at the American market, where none of the tracks were commercially released before, but even considering this – would American Interpol fan really rather be buying live recordings release or the one that includes something more original?
All in all The Black EP is not the blatant rip-off one might have feared (eh, this CD could have cost the price of the full-length album – just like I Might Be Wrong EP by Radiohead. It doesn’t, thank God), but nonetheless it remains a pretty die-hard fans affair. Newcomers should stick with the album, The Strokes should consider The Demos EP (sure there should be left aplenty unheard ones even after Someday single, eh, Julian?), Interpol must realize that it’s about a time they return to studio and record something even more mind-blowing then Turn On The Bright Lights.
The Orange EP, anyone?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First
ARRAY(0xa718e4e0)

This product

The Black EP
The Black EP by Interpol (Audio CD - 2007)
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews