Shop now Shop now Shop now  Up to 50% Off Fashion  Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Listen in Prime Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

4.0 out of 5 stars6
4.0 out of 5 stars
5 star
4
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
2
1 star
0
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 22 May 2003
If only television documentaries had advanced down the route Peter Watkins and the few others like him suggested in the late 60's...but instead the dumbing down, the rapid editing, the constant noise...
His use of amatures to portray the people involved provides a kind of realism I have not seen anywhere else.
Would be perfect for use in the classroom as it presents very coherantly the differing perspectives and the mistakes made on both sides.
Excellent and beautiful.
0Comment|14 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 22 October 2007
I remember watching parts of this many years ago and decided to rent it and watch in full.
I'm just amazed that this film has not been brought to new generations. It's such an important statement, Scottish history apart this film applies to any modern day conflict. I've seen this sort of conflict first hand and as far as Peter Walkins movie goes it doesn't really matter if it is culloden, Ireland, Iraq, Africa, you will always get bloodthirsty soldiers, scared soldiers, sympathetic soldiers and you will always get innocent, non-combatant civilians caught in the middle. Make Culloden an Educational resource if nothing else.
0Comment|4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 July 2010
Ground breaking in it's style and so good it has yet to be surpassed. After all these decades, it still remains cutting edge. You are drawn into the belly of the battle, into the heart and mind of every man and boy on that field. Hypnotic and so so powerful. I saw it only once on bbc i player about a year ago. I think of it every day. Essential viewing for anyone with an interest in film making and indeed history. Rough, hearty cinematic perfection.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 21 May 2006
I haven't seen this film since it was broadcast on American public television in 1964. And unfortunately it is unavailable in the United States. However, now that Punishment Park has been released in the U.S., I can only hope that this film will find its way here eventually. Images from this film have stayed with me for 42 years. The British soldiers talking dispassionately about how to bayonet the Scottish fighters on the non-shield side. The running down of the fleeing Scottish women and children after the battle. The technique Watkins uses, and has used several times since, of "you are there," with the reporters directly addressing the participants. As a story of imperial aggression and repression, this film is as relevant and important today as it was when it first came out with America just beginning its trials in Vietnam.
0Comment|7 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 17 August 2009
Unlike everyone else, I was less than impressed when watching about 20 minutes of this film, which I have not seen for over 20 years. Perhaps it improves as it goes on, but the medley of misleading statements and facts did not go down well if we are assuming this is meant to be a serious representation of history.

Cumberland's army is referred to in different terms - as Hanoverian, British, English and royal. Which is it? Clearly not the third, as we are shown a Scot in the ranks of the redcoats, and the Jacobites would certainly have not used the term 'royal'. Likewise the Jacobite army is said to be made up of Highlanders - no mention of the Lowlanders, English, Irish and Frenchmen among its ranks.

Charles Edward Stuart, we are told, had very little military experience - true, but prior to 1745 Lord George Murray, also shown, had very little, either. In any case, how much did this matter? Hawley had been in the army for decades compared to Cumberland and the latter was much better.

We are told it was O'Sullivan who left the walls undefended, contrary to Murray's wishes, but the reverse was true.

We are told that the Jacobites almost took London before retreating, but the situation is rather more complex than that - many, including Murray, thought not.

There is a number given to those killed by pursuing dragoons - a suspiciously round 100, and I know of no source which gives this.We are told that James Ray was the first soldier to arrive at Inverness, but oddly enough he doesn't mention this in his account of the period. Pursuing fleeing enemy is seen here as if it were a war crime - but it was a regular occurrence after battles of this period (eg Naesby, Prestonpans).

A single cannon is used when we see the Royal Artillery firing. They actually fired in batteries of two guns. I know this film is low budget, but even so (the TV series Kidnapped(1979) at least managed two little guns). Since there are so few extras, this feels like a battle between a score of men on each side, rather than thousands, but at least a few cavalry appear.

Any good points? Well, the prominence given to Lochiel as a key player in the Jacobite army is good, as is the fact that we are told that the clansmen were compelled to fight, but on the other hand, some men volunteered (esp. Lowlanders)and some clansmen may have agreed with their chiefs or have gone along for plunder or adventure. We are also shown Scots on both sides.

If I manage to watch the rest of this, I will add a comment about that. My recollection is that the remainder is sourced from the Jacobite Lyon in Mourning, a rather one sided view.

This may be excellent in the terms of TV and filmmaking, but as history it should be treated with caution.
33 comments|6 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 11 July 2014
Nah, Not the Full DVD.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)