23 of 23 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Great performances in need of a good modern transfer
First the bad news. Despite having a sticky label emblazoned with"Digitally Remastered at 96kHz" on the box cover the recorded sound appears (to my middle-aged ears) identical to that on the old Belart re-issues of the mid-1990s. This means that upper frequencies are often thin with an unpleasant ting or ziz to the sound. To make matters worse, on occasion, one has the...
Published on 13 Jan 2010 by R. T. Boakes
3.0 out of 5 stars Definitive in parts
This is a collection for the completist. Boult's association with VW spanned many years, and there is no doubt that he understood these symphonies. Somehow, though, Previn's LSO recordings from the 1970s are just more convincing. Boult gives us the tweedy, familiar VW, whilst Previn understood the darker, more complex aspects of the symphonies. Compare the two. This...
Published 1 day ago by Terry O'Connor
Most Helpful First | Newest First
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Great performances in need of a good modern transfer,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)First the bad news. Despite having a sticky label emblazoned with"Digitally Remastered at 96kHz" on the box cover the recorded sound appears (to my middle-aged ears) identical to that on the old Belart re-issues of the mid-1990s. This means that upper frequencies are often thin with an unpleasant ting or ziz to the sound. To make matters worse, on occasion, one has the aural equivalence of listening to the performance while looking down the wrong end of a telescope, with a constricted dynamic range to the sound stage and general lack of body to the sound. While FFRR (full frequency range recording) technique used by Decca in the early 1950s was lauded in its day as peak of realism, these recordings could benefit from some serious intervention of the kind given by Pristine Audio and Dutton Laboratories and that does not appear to have occurred here.
Despite this grouch the vast majority of buyers will be drawn to the `classic' status of these performances. Those who know Boult from his later EMI recordings (of these works and others) might be in for a bit of shock. The Adrian Boult of the late 1940s and early 1950s was not yet a `grand old man' but a highly experienced conductor capable of generating enormous thrust and dynamism from his orchestra, yet this is allied to a peerless grasp of symphonic structure. Listen (for example) to the opening of `A Sea symphony' to get some idea of this. From the opening B flat minor brass fanfare, followed by the choir singing Behold, the sea... Boult achieves a tremendous sense of onward momentum yet he never loses sight of the movement's proportions so that when this phase returns in the major its impact is quite overwhelming.
While Boult brings these qualities to the whole cycle some performances inevitably stand out. My list would not differ substantially from other reviewers here. The `Sea', `London', `Pastoral' and Fifth symphonies are practically definitive. No other conductor captures the enormous feeling of loss embodied in the slow movement of the Pastoral (V-W's real war symphony) like Boult. To this I would add the eighth symphony; how well Boult gets it to work as a symphony.
Let downs? The sixth is only a weak performance if you judge it by the lights of the world premier recording Boult made for HMV (in much better sound). Here, a slightly less than devilish approach to the scherzo is the only weakness for me. In the fourth, Boult seems to baulk at the demonic nature of the music, something which V-W certainly did not do in his 1937 recording with the BBC Symphony. (In Boult's defense, who else has got within haling distance of the composer's own interpretation?). The ninth could have done with another rehearsal. Finally, I am unconvinced by the spoken additions to the Sinfonia Antartica (wonderful as it is to hear John Gielgud) and would look to Bernard Haitink to give full measure to this still underrated work.
To sum up five stars for Boult and his fellow musicians but keep an eye out for other transfers now that these recording have fallen out of copyright.
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars As good as it gets.,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)Since the 1970's the symphonies of RVW began to be performed more frequently and distinguished conductors undertook their own personal journeys to record complete cycles of them. Previn added an international view to set alongside a parallel collection from Boult on EMI. Then Handley, Thomson, and Hickox, through the 1980's and 1990's, re-examined these mighty works from a more modern British standpoint. And alongside the above, a fascinating cycle from Haitink gave us a refreshing and thought-provoking take on the beloved symphonies we thought we had grown to know so well.
My own personal journey had ended, so I thought, with the the Dutchman. Yet something in the back of my mind kept returning me to thoughts of a couple of old Decca 'Eclipse' LPs I'd bought, 30 odd years ago, of the 1st and 6th symphonies, conducted by Boult. I remembered more visceral performances of these pieces, good though Haitink et al had been. I took the plunge and ordered the cd's. I was right! Digitally remastered, the sound has an immediacy which hit me just as dramatically as the old vinyl did when I heard these works for the first time, over 30 years ago. But the new sound has an added clarity which reveals the huge range of orchestral nuances in these superb works.
The recordings date from the early to mid 1950's. Boult and the LPO play as if the scores are hot off the press. His soloists are on top form too. And RVW is in the studio! Just try the plagent tenderness of the 'pastoral' or the chilling intensity of the 'antartica'. No. 4 has never sounded so brutal, nor No. 5 as 'English'.
I think Boult guides us on the most rewarding journey through these greatest of twentieth century symphonies.
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Incomparable performances from Adrian Boult,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)Like reviewer Patrick Miller listening to this set was a revelation, I also found Boult's later EMI set somewhat tame.
Possibly it was the composer's presence (except for Symphony 9 due to his death seven hours before the session) that inspired Boult and the London Philharmonic to play the music as if had only just been written, the freshness of the long established works is wonderful.
The "Gramophone Magazine" reviewed most of these recording in April and May 1954 with glowing enthusiasm.
However this recording of the Symphony 6 does not eclipse the recording Boult made following the first performance in 1947 where the players are challenged by a slightly faster speed and the difficulty and excitement of playing a major new work. I recommend having both.
Theses fine performances are captured by Decca's finest mono sound engineering in the incomparable acoustics of the Kingsway Hall.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Definitive RVW,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)These are the performances of the symphonies against which all others must be measured. Boult was associated with RVW throughout his life, being present at the premiere of A Sea Symphony in 1910, later conducting the first perfomances of the 3rd, 4th and 6th symphonies, and of course recording these in 1952, 1953, 1956 and 1958, all in the presence of the great man [except for the 9th, as other reviewers have mentioned - though RVW was actively planning to attend the recording in Walthamstow Town Hall on the night of his death]. I grew up with Boult's later EMI recordings, which I still love, and Previn's and Haitink's cycles are also superb, but there's something special about this set. Still sounding wonderful, despite the years, this is the one I turn to most. The 5th has never sounded more radiant.
23 of 25 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Magnificent,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)I have long enjoyed Sir Adrian Boult's EMI recordings of these symphonies,but I had always heard that his earlier Decca recordings were more "alive"and the fires burned brighter on those. I missed them the first timearound on CD, and when I walked into to record shop and saw this boxsitting there, I couldn't resist. I don't see this listed on the US Amazonsite, so I wonder if this was some kind of import. Anyway, it has been arevelation. The VW symphonies have always seemed kind of elusive to me inrecordings. No one conductor ever seemed to hit the nail on the head onall nine. For me anyway, Boult did it here. I'll hang onto his EMIrecordings for sentimental reasons, but I think they'll be on the shelffor a while...
28 of 31 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Absolutely not to be missed!,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)Although these recordings come from the 1950s they offer the most satisfying listening experience of all. Sir Adrian Boult was, in my view, the greatest proponent of the music of Vaughan Williams and this set provides a unique insight into the varied landscape of the symphonies.
Furthermore, the composer was in the studio when these recordings were set down (or in the case of the valedictory Ninth, the recording was made a few hours after the composer's death on 26th August 1958)
Another great thing about this set is that it actually includes the Ninth Symphony which was originally recorded by the American Everest label rather than Decca (as in symphonies 1-8)
When this set was released by Belart only symphonies 1-8 were included. Decca have also included Boult's tribute to Vaughan Williams, in a short speech before the recording of the Ninth Symphony and also the composer's endearing tribute to Boult and the orchestra at the conclusion of the epic Sixth Symphony. The performance of the Sixth Symphony has in fact never been bettered, a truly legendary account.
All the performances are excellent but those of A Sea Symphony, A London Symphony, A Pastoral Symphony and symphonies 5,6 and 9 are absolutely terrific.
Don't be put off by the age of the recordings as the transfers are excellent.
Not to be missed!
[added 31st December 2012 - 'Begun in 1952 to mark Vaughan Williams's 80th birthday, this is still the best complete cycle on disc, capturing performances of searing urgency and rare spiritual power'. Gramophone Magazine, January 2013 in a tribute to Sir Adrian Boult by Geraint Lewis ]
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Vaughan William's classic 50's cycle under another guise!,
Amazon Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Ralph Vaughan Williams: Symphonies 1-9 (MP3 Download)This earlier, 50's cycle of the Vaughan Williams symphonies conducted by Adrian Boult is quite possibly the most riveting in the catalogue, in my opinion. It surpasses his later cycle for its ever freshness and vigour, and even surpasses Previn's fantastic recordings of the 70's. The mono sound is excellent; similar to the quality of Walter Legges production of Klemperer's earlier recordings in the mid fifties. There are no weak links in this cycle. The set is highly recommended by myself, without hesitation.
It is important to note, that this mp3 download is the exact same download which is also available on the original Boult cycle page (the brown covered, Decca box set), which mysteriously comes with a much higher price tag. If you are fortunate to come across this download, it is almost certain that you will be the proud owner of one of the very great Vaughan Williams symphony cycles, for less than the price of a coffee and a sandwich. Enjoy.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars An important note regarding the MP3 download included!,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)This earlier, 50's cycle of the Vaughan Williams symphonies conducted by Adrian Boult is quite possibly the most riveting in the catalogue, in my opinion. It surpasses his later cycle for its freshness and vigor; and it even surpasses Previn's magnificent recordings from the 70's. The mono sound is excellent; it's similar to the quality of Walter Legge's production of Klemperer's earlier recordings in the mid fifties. There are no weak links in this cycle whatsoever. The set is highly recommended by myself, without hesitation.
However, there is some important information that potential purchases need to be aware of. I am referring to the mp3 download. At the time of writing this review, the download, as you can see, is over twenty pounds. If you use the department scroll, drop down to mp3, and type in Vaughan Williams Symponies 1-9; it will display the Andrew Davis cycle, and what appears to be another cycle, priced at only four pounds and forty nine pence. This cheaper alternative, with its colourful cover, is the exact same mp3 Boult cycle from this page! I'm surprised that Amazon allows some of its customers to pay over three times more than others for the exact same product. This problem seems to be the same with Kempff's Beethoven Sonata mono cycle. Anyway, I hope this helps potential buyers. One thing is certain - you cannot go wrong with these marvellous recordings by the LPO under Adrian Boult.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic Value!!,
This review is from: Ralph Vaughan Williams: Symphonies 1-9 (MP3 Download)Let me start off by saying that the sound quality on some of these recordings is not fantastic. But as a newcomer to Vaughan Williams I found this collection to be perfectly adequate in introducing me to a new favourite.
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Definative recordings,
This review is from: Vaughan Williams: Complete Symphonies (Audio CD)There are moments of magic such as the slow movement of the 2nd symphony where you can almost smell the smog and damp of an autumn dusk in a London square. I'm not too convinced by the quality of the playing in the 3rd Symphony and the 4th I think was a bit of a blind spot for Boult but it is still better than most performances. In the 5th symphony there are some dodgy moments for the LPO brass in the scherzo. The 6th symphony is a triumph and is really raw and aggressive, a real contrast to Boult's Philharmonia version in the 60's. This has bite and a sense of purpose. I agree with other reviewers about the spoken narrative in the 7th i.e. there's no need for it. For the 8th compare and contrast this version with the recording by Barbirolli and the Halle. Both are similar but Barbirolli tends to tinker with the music where Boult just lets it unfold. The 9th is still waiting for a definative reading in my view. VW was ahead of all of us in this work and we have not yet caught up with his vision.
Most Helpful First | Newest First