Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop All Amazon Fashion Summer Savings Up to 25% Off Cloud Drive Photos Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Oasis Learn more Shop now Learn more

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5 stars205
4.4 out of 5 stars
Format: DVD|Change
Price:£3.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 11 January 2003
Nicolas Cage gives a wonderful performance as Seth, an Angel who falls in love and begins to long for the ability to express that love. Seth is an Angel who helps the dead cross over and in some respects this film resembles the 1930's film "Death Takes a Holiday" with Frederick March and Evelyn Veneble.

Meg Ryan is Maggie, the doctor who is the object of Seth's affection. She somehow sences his prescence when trying to save one of her patients and he is touched and bewildered by her. Andre Braugher steals every scene he is in as Seth's fellow Angel and friend. They all hang out at the library and gather every morning at the beach to see the sunrise and hear the singing of heaven. Dennis Franz has a fine turn as a patient in Maggie's hospital who knows Seth is there because he to was once an Angel.
This provides Seth with a way to truly love Maggie if he can find the courage to leave heaven behind, and just, fall.
This is one of the most romantic movies of recent years and has a message about the wonderful things we all take for granted. More than that, it is a story about the importace of love, even one felt for only a moment, for it is that experience which makes us special among all creation.
I will not ruin the last portion of this film if you have not seen it, but as we all know there is a price we pay for being human. This film is for anyone who has ever loved someone as Seth does, who would trade all eternity for just one breath of her hair. This is a truly memorable film you will watch over and over.
Films like this are rarely made anymore and this is one to cherish. You will never forget the line, "When they ask me what I liked best...I'll say it was You"..........
0Comment|44 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
As she reads 105 degrees on the thermometer she’s just taken out of her six-year old daughter’s mouth – we hear Mum’s panicking thoughts - pleading for help from a higher power. "I don't really pray…but if you could help out here…" she says in escalating dread. Yet her child Susan doesn’t seem fazed – staring instead at a man in a long black coat with a peaceful face on the other side of the room that Mummy doesn’t seem able to see.

His name is Seth - and next thing he’s walking alongside Susan who’s lying in her pyjamas on a hospital gurney looking up at him as a group of doctors and surgeons try to get her to the operating room on time. Moments later Seth and tiny Susan are looking in at the medical commotion through the glass outside – holding hands as they watch an unresponsive child’s body and a mother breaking down in agony. Susan looks up and asks Seth - "She won't understand?" He calmly replies - "She will…someday…"

Inside hot cars motionless on a log-jammed freeway - we see the citizens of LA and hear their thoughts about doomed love affairs ("he's never gonna leave her…"), work worries and how everything takes twenty minutes in Los Angeles. We then witness more angels in human form at work – one listening to the thoughts of a mother proud that her daughter has had a 6lb 4oz baby and become a parent too - helping an air-traffic controller concentrate when his debt problems almost distract him from Flight Federal 595 - and two working a kid and a scared liquor store owner on opposite sides of the counter – urging them both to 'stay cool' as the jumpy young man nervously robs his till with a gun.

These angels aren’t flashy – they don’t have wings nor halos - they don’t stop bullets or avert car crashes – they remain invisible to the human world and only lay on hands to help and sooth. They ponder what their charges say about life – usually from a height - dangling their legs over skyscraper girders, aeroplane wings, 100-foot high cowboy adverts for cigarettes and the Hollywood Sign. They also gather on the beach each morning (without leaving footprints in the sand) to witness the sunrise and hear the music of possibility…as a new day begins...

As you can imagine a reworking of Wim Wender's beloved 1987 classic movie "Wings Of Desire" by Hollywood types was always going to be open to ridicule and charges of crass commercialism – but 1998's "City Of Angels" pulled off the transition with a genuine deftness of touch – producing a movie that moved many movie goers far more than they thought it would. The brilliant Dana Stevens adapted screenplay smartly keeps it about people – about finding humanity – the joy in everyday occurrences – and knowing there is always love in your life in one form or another.

Principal in pulling this off is the spot-on casting of Nicholas Cage and Meg Ryan. Cage plays Seth – an Angel who is more than curious about what it would be like to actually 'feel' let alone be human - while the talented Meg Ryan plays Doctor Maggie Race – a Thoracic Surgeon in L.A.’s Mission Hospital who is having a crisis of faith after losing a 50-year old patient called Tom Bradford on her table in what was a routine bypass.

Dr. Maggie suddenly feels no longer in control and can’t shake off the stricken reaction of Bradford’s family as she broke the news to them. She did it with a little too much of that scalpel-like precision and detachment that works so well in the operating theatre but not in the real world - cockily playing Jimi Hendrix as she dabbles with someone else’s heart. It was a textbook operation - yet it went wrong - her patient’s fading arrhythmia literally in her hands – powerless to stop him from dying (dialogue above). But her partner and fellow surgeon Jordan Ferris (a suave Colm Feore) thinks that Maggie is not out of sorts nor crazy nor chemically imbalanced – just tired - and with a little rest - she should just "come back to work on Monday and get back on the saddle". But Maggie doesn’t seem able to get that confidence nor that belief back.

Then one night – tired and still trying to figure out why an abandoned male infant on the 4th floor keeps crying all the time (her Doctor friend Anne is played by the lovely Robin Bartlett) – Maggie exits the lift at the 6th floor by mistake and sees a man standing outside a ward bedroom. He turns around and it’s the beautiful Seth. They engage in small talk about the benefits of visiting hours and being in despair on the stairwell – and a flame of attraction is lit between them. His eyes haunt her and she wonders how he knew her first name when her ID tag only displays the initial 'M'?

They meet again in the heavenly upward concrete circles of the city library as she returns a book - Hemmingway's "A Moveable Feast – Sketches On The Author’s Life In Paris In the Twenties". More feelings grow as Seth sexily explains about the great American author’s skill at describing the senses of taste and touch (things he can’t experience himself but longs to). At this point Maggie thinks Seth’s a bit weird - with his cryptic replies and always wearing the same clothes whilst saying he’s not a bike courier but a Messenger of God. But something inside her aches for him – like a lost Soul moving towards its mate.

Seth tries to discuss his growing feelings with another celestial body - Cassiel (the wonderful Andre Braugher) but Cassiel seems sceptical. Then one afternoon Seth meets the rotund hedonist Nathaniel Messinger (superb casting in Dennis Franz) in the heart ward munching down on yet another tub of Ben & Jerry’s ice cream. Nathaniel can hear and feel Seth’s presence - and Seth soon works out that Nathaniel was once an angel too – but one who fell in love with a woman on Earth and 'chose' to fall to be with her (nice work from Joanna Merlin). Over more food Nathaniel explains that he gave up his power to travel at the speed of thought - never grow old and never feel any pain – for love – and hasn’t regretted a day since.

And on it goes to Maggie working out why the child keeps crying and what her strange man in black really is (from a photo) and finally to a decision that Seth must make of his own 'free will'…

Director Brad Silberling’s movie cleverly avoids any flashy 'ghost' or 'angel' tricks and allied with Gabriel Yared’s truly gorgeous film score (the acoustic "The Unfeeling Kiss" used during the market scene as they shop for fruit is particularly stunning) and other clever song choices by Peter Gabriel, Paula Cole, Alanis Morissette and Sarah McLachlan – gives his angelic messengers a calming presence – benevolent beings watching over us all but not interfering nor judging.

The February 2014 AMERICAN BLU RAY I bought on Barcode 883929374298 is REGION FREE so there are no compatibility problems for UK or European buyers. The picture is defaulted to 2.4:1 Aspect Ratio so there's bars top and bottom - but even stretched to Full Screen - the print quality is lovely throughout. You wouldn’t say it was exceptional by any means – but I feel its an improvement over the DVD I had – never overly glossy – classy in its presentation. Eyes are blue – sunsets are multi-coloured and his sweat and blood when he falls onto a steel platform look real. Meg Ryan has probably never looked more beautiful or assured while Cage brings an other-worldliness to his character than few actors could achieve. The behind-the-scenes documentaries feature fun talks with the cast both in studio and on location (skyscraper shots that terrified both Cage and Franz because they are real – short on girders way up there).

Audio is DTS-HD Master Audio English 5.1, Dolby Digital French 5.1, Spanish Castilian 5.1 and Spanish Latin 2.0. Subtitles include English SDH, French and Spanish.

Maggie says to Seth about her lost patient – "I wanted him to live…" And Seth replies, "He is living…just not in the way you think…"

Ever wonder what your invisible guardian looks like or sings in the shower? Succumb to the charms of L.A.’s "City Of Angels" and find out…
0Comment|3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 12 July 2014
I had heard about "City of Angels" but never managed to watch it. Recently it was shown on television and I was excited to finally see it. After the first half hour it started breaking up.But what I had seen was enough to make me want to watch the whole film.So I ordered it ,it arrived a few days later and my husband and I watched it the same night.
I have always liked Nicolas Cage and Meg Ryan,and the combination of both worked well.
What if heaven exists and angels are all around us to guide us, protect us and finally lead us home ? The idea is well thought through ,sad in places but also with the assuring hope that death may not be the last place for us to go.
And also the thought that it's better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all.
The film brings home the question what makes us human, with all of our imperfections and limits . Would you swap an eternal life for a life that is final ? Would you leave the security of heaven behind for the chance to experience love ?
City of Angels is a highly moving film. Romantic, deep, emotional,and spiritual.
We both loved it ,and if you like this genre of film,you will love it too.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 20 August 2003
I stumbled across this film....as you do. However since then I have been thinking about it, so profoundly touched I have been by it. The scene where the song Angels is played I have played over and over. Rarely has a film touched my very soul as this. I confess to being a hopeless romantic but in my mind there is not enough of that in the world. City of Angels makes you glad to be human and have the capacity to love and be loved and to recognise the concept of sacrifice within it.
11 comment|24 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 December 2005
This film was inspiring from start to finish and was a real tear jerker. This story of immense love give hope that there is someone out there for each one of us...
0Comment|3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 February 2015
As I saw this film on a friend's wish list, I bought it for her along with "Meet Joe Black" as a Christmas present in 2014 and she loves it. Starring Nicolas Cage (one of her absolute favourite actors) and Meg Ryan, "City of Angels" focuses on an angelic guardian come to earth, named Seth. A highly observant and rather silent character, he dares you to think again on whether you believe in angels or not. His challenging personality has an affect on Maggie, a young surgeon, which soon triggers the start of a gripping relationship. For a film that is charged by Cage scrutinizing everyone around him including Maggie, it is perfect for die hard fans of this fantastic actor.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 April 2003
My most favourite film deserves 10 stars. Definitely, absolutely amazing film.
Touching to the heart, deep and emotional, true and genuine and totally romantic.
Anyone with a full heart will feel true emotion while watching this movie.
Soundtrack is beautiful too. The acting captures you.
If you want to dream in a land far away, watch this movie, and dream a little dream.
0Comment|12 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 17 June 2014
Throw a stack of money at a tardy production team for a sensitive story. The result is seen in this offering.
Dreadful performances from Cage and Ryan combined with an attrocious script worthy only for publication in some junk
comic. Editing is totally ill timed and inconsistent. I have to ask if the film was constructed as a macabre joke to gauge
how may viewers would be taken in and start waffling about deep and hidden meanings. Attrocious in every respect.

David Turner (London U.K)
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 February 2009
City of Angels is a wonderful adaptation of the original in that it presents an alternative perspective of the incredible "Wings of Desire" and is so different in it's approach that it merits recognition in it's own right as a romantic, modernist interpretation.
Wings of Desire, however, represents something truly different and inspiring, in that it portrays a far more fundamental, poetic and encapsulating representation of the human psyche that reaches far beyond the scope of "City of Angels". Both these films can be considered standalone and within their own contexts can be considered masterpieces in their own right. Watch both and enjoy both for what they are.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 July 2000
While typing away the review I try to remember my feelings when I first saw this film - and all I can sense is a dream-like ball floating in happiness and melancholy.
Indeed this movie about an angel life-taker falling in love for a surgeon life-saver has a place in dreams: Love being that strong that it defies immortality, and that an Angel denies it all just for the chance to touch his beloved.
The bitter-sweet ending isn't at all what is expected, and for once in films, it then fails you because of that.
True you can always refer it to Wim Wenders, but a lovely film nonetheless.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.