Customer Reviews


5 Reviews
5 star:
 (4)
4 star:
 (1)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 
Most Helpful First | Newest First

12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Fatima Mansions final genius album..., 15 Sep 2003
By 
Jason Parkes "We're all Frankies'" (Worcester, UK) - See all my reviews
(No. 1 Hall OF FAME REVIEWER)   
This review is from: Lost in the Former West (Audio CD)
Lost in the Former West (1994) remains the highpoint of Fatima Mansions career, despite coming after genius albums (Viva Dead Ponies, Valhalla Avenue) and singles alike (Blues for Ceausescu, Bertie's Brochures). Amusingly, Cathal Coughlan took up meditation and gave up drinking prior to making this record- one would perhaps expect some loved up hippy tosh...CC instead gives us a focused take on the bowels of a morally empty, post-Cold War Europe. This is the dark stuff, made darker with the Swiftian black comedy- the album that Manics'Holy Bible so wanted to be...
Cathal gives us it straight away with Belong Nowhere, "No deathcamps here I tell you/Just grey 'convienience' hell/'neath billboard signs which yell: "You need someone pretty, someone English and shifty". The backdrop of the post-Iron curtain and the former Yugoslavia infect this album, as does an earlier strain of bile directed at what would become identified as globalisation- tracks like Your World Customer and lyrics like "Save all your revolution for a Saturday night" show how shallow Radiohead's anti-globalist material was on Amnesiac.
LITFW is almost worth buying for the hilarious cover (a restaged Liberace photo)- CC as Liberace with 'chauffeur' travelling through the depraved former West. If Lou Reed's New York and Neil Young's Rockin'in the Free World started doubt about the late 80s bonhomie and Leonard Cohen's The Future (1993)took us into bleaker, darker, laughter in the dark territory- LITFW takes us almost to the end of this experience (music would become rather apolitical shortly after this album, witness the horrors of Britpop). As with Cathal's previous outfit Microdisney, a sense of classic popsongs are apparent (CC a precursor of Luke Haines, & a descendent of Mark E Smith); musically this sounds like a blend of Scott Walker, Aerosmith, The Fall, Ministry, Faith No More, Richard Thompson, Elvis Costello (lyrically- Beyond Belief/Tramp the Dirt Down), The Young Gods, Leonard Cohen,Gang of Four & Guns'N'Roses!
Popemobile to Paraguay sounds like a demented take on Walk This Way- a suitably harsh rock sound for Cathal's vitriolic lyrics concerning (amongst themes) the Pope's stance on ethnic mass rape and US foreign policy: "the King of the papists is a friend to the rapists and the upside-down crucifixion squad...It's been awhile since you said 'Heil', you CIA-bred necrophile/No Ruskies left to rail at, not for now/& the Slavs in their millions with their scrapheaps of children must replace your South Americans/More skulls to keep your Mafia in the Mafia Top Ten". These are themes Cathal has been developing since Love Your Enemies...
The singles The Loyaliser ("you get older, you get scared, but you get no wiser") and Nite Flights (a Scott Walker cover from the album of the same name, though perhaps The Electrician would have been more apt?) are a joy- worth tracking down seperately for outtakes like Gary Numan's Porsche & As I Washed the Blood Off (perhaps a reissue could include these?). There is a hint of Walker about Walk Yr Way, which is a vaster take on the ballad side of FM as seen on Behind the Moon & North Atlantic Wind.
Bruncelling's Song sounds like Steely Dan crashing into The Fall, "I know Khomeni, John Wilkes Booth, and the Jackson Five...I'm a sad old joke, forgot I spoke...Nothing, nothing, nothing is true...some are in power, some in flyover graves". The title track is a creepy instrumental interlude, advancing on those found on Viva Dead Ponies; a themetune to the early 90s zeitgeist (we can order pizza while we flip between news programmes and wait for celebs and coke to come more into fashion...)
Sunken Cities is a gorgeous interlude, a folk song that is closest to the Microdisney work...this is followed by the pop-assault of Brain Blister ("You earn but you feel oppressed" being EXACTLY a state I've both felt & sensed in various workplaces). Even better is the schizophrenic A Walk in the Woods, a song that shifts from ballad to sinister to all out thrash- "You'll know me by the knives sticking out of my back".
Final track Humiliate Me! sounds like early Guns'N'Roses.
Lost in the Former West sounds even better these days, both a history and a suitable soundtrack to the atrocious world we populate at present. Our culture of schuadenfreude and materialism is pinpointed here...we need people like Cathal Coughlan, surely one of the most underrated performers of all time? LITFW remains Fatima Mansions masterpiece, the climax and death knell of their career. Perhaps people don't want to hear lines that make Dylan look lightweight, such as "the bigger the roadside crowd/the denser the game show cloud"?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Debut mini-LP from 1989/1990..., 20 Sep 2003
By 
Jason Parkes "We're all Frankies'" (Worcester, UK) - See all my reviews
(No. 1 Hall OF FAME REVIEWER)   
This review is from: Against Nature (Audio CD)
Against Nature is the earliest recordings by Fatima Mansions, Cathal Coughlan's next band after the feted (if ignored) Microdisney. Title comes from the Hyusman's book of the same name, - the mini LP was recorded on a low budget with a not quite formulated band sound that would be apparent from Blues for Ceausescu/VIva Dead Ponies onwards. A compilation, Come Back My Children (1992), collects the whole of this set, alongside the aforementioned Blues, the Only Losers Take the Bus/What? single, the Hive ep & their cover of Lady Godiva's operation. Against Nature alone is still very wonderful, though closer to the ironic pop of Microdisney than the full on rock assault that developed FM's sound & perfectly suited Coughlan's bleak lyrics.
The Day I Lost Everything is the greatest song here- an amusing opening sees Jimmy Tarbuck as Santa Claus/The Pope ("Kiss the ring!")- it sees the beginnings of Coughlan's wonderful anthems for the bleak world we live in. Against Nature is a bit DIY, quite synthetic- 13th Century Boy is somewhere between Dead or Alive & Julian Cope fooling around on those double albums in the 1990s (think 20 Mothers). I'd love to hear someone like Atomic Kitten or Blue sing this song (no chance sadly!)- the lyrics about "all the wars out there" and the "price of fish" show Coughlan's themes of absurdity and the backdrop of conflict become apparent (as too his Vatican baiting, extended on from his Microdisney days-see the cover of Love Your Enemies- this advanced into an artform with an infamous U2 support slot in Rome and 1994's brilliant Popemobile to Paraguay).
Several of the tracks are ballads- between late Microdisney (Mrs Simpson, Angels, Gale Force Wind) & the 1990/91 ballads (Viva Dead Ponies, A Pack of Lies, Bertie's Brochures, Behind the Moon): Bishop of Babel, You Won't Get Me Home & Wilderness on Time. Valley of the Dead Cars is up there with The Fall, a pulsing thing that sounds like a cross between The Frenz Experiment & Countdown to Ecstasy. The album ends on a suitably sinister note, this was just the beginning after all, with Big Madness/Monday Club Carol- a potent blend of ballad and child's toy music.
Against Nature is rather good, not as great as the rest of FM's back catalogue that followed from 1990-1994; but well worth owning (as I said before, get Come Back My Children, also deleted, if you can). Surely FM require the box-set treatment: Disc I: Come Back My Children;Disc II: Viva Dead Ponies/Bertie's Brochures; Disc III: Valhalla Avenue & Disc IV: Lost in the Former West (with added b-sides etc)???? Against Nature is an early example of one of the key bands of the 1990s, as with all things Cathal Coughlan, the operative word remains 'OWN'. You have been told-
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Keeping Music Evil, 4 May 2009
By 
MR P FITTON (Oldham, Manchester UK) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
This review is from: Lost in the Former West (Audio CD)
In a decently organised society the Fatima Mansions would have been huge, and their leader, singer and songwriter Cathal Coughlan, would be worshipped as a genius. Rock's final genius in fact. Alas it was not to be.

The band's final album, Lost in the Former West, was described by Coughlan, prior to release, as a straight-ahead "flippant" rock album. True, up to a point, and as such it lacks the some of the subtlety of previous albums (at least musically) but it is still a magnificent, snarling, furious, gloriously malevolent record in the best Fatima tradition. And it's frequently also very funny.

Other bands (RATM, Anti-Flag et al) may play at being angry, make the appropriate gestures, postures and slogans, but don't have the intellectual or musical clout to back it up. Fatima Mansions were the real deal. There was no vacuous sloganeering; enormously inventive musically and with Coughlan's hyper-intelligent lyrics, their brief recorded history represents probably the most uncompromisingly vitriolic music ever put on disc.

Jason Parkes has already done a great job of outlining the record's main themes so I won't add much on that score. Suffice to say that, as always, the Mansions were not messing about. The record starts with the massive guitar attack and coruscating rage of Belong Nowhere - Coughlan's nihilistic, anti-patriotic vitriol ridiculing and ruthlessly dismantling the very ideas of 'belonging', homeland and national identity.

Massive savage guitar (courtesy of the excellent Aindrias O'Gruama) dominates most of LitFW's tracks, but it's not all brutality. There's much lyric beauty here too: Sunken Cities is a beautiful song based on a Moravian folk tune, the jaw-droppingly bitter lyrics of Walk Yr Way are set to a stately, yearning melody and lovely piano chords, while the title track is a strange but beautifully constructed instrumental of the type that peppered Cathal's first solo album (the sublime Grand Necropolitan, for me simply the greatest album ever made).

Then there's Coughlan's voice, an instrument that can not only express rage and disgust better than any other on the planet but can also be simply gorgeous. I'd be hard put to think of a better singer in rock music (other than perhaps Cathal's hero, Scott Walker, paid tribute to here with an excellent cover of Nite Flights), not for nothing did John Peel once say that he could listen to Coughlan sing the phone book.

The problem with Fatima Mansion's records, and Coughlan's solo albums, is that it's almost impossible to listen to anything else afterwards. In comparison almost everything else sounds like nonsense made by people who are just toeing the line and playing the game. Coughlan makes records that no-one else has the intelligence, soul or courage to make. To paraphrase the late Harold Pinter speaking about Beckett: what I love about Coughlan is that he's not f--king me about, he's not leading me up any garden path, he's not flogging me a remedy or a path or a revelation or a basinful of breadcrumbs, he leaves no stone unturned and no maggot lonely. He brings forth a body of beauty.

Sadly, the legal department of a cretinous record company put paid to the Fatima Mansions, but Coughlan's solo work continues, largely unrecognised, to this day. Musically, he has mellowed to an extent (he has, he says, "lost interest in signal distortion") but his albums still contain all the qualities that made the Mansions, and previous band Microdisney, wonderful. LitFW is as good a place as any for the curious to start, however, and is very, very highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Forgotten Classics, 29 April 2013
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Against Nature (Audio CD)
Fatima Mansions are the forgotten heroes of the otherwise dismal late eighties early nineties music scene. No lovingly remastered box sets for these guys - you'll have to go hunting for the scarce originals.Completists will probably prefer the compilation Come Back My Children but this is their most accessible work and much recommended for anyone who thinks Irish pop deserves better than Bono.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars "Get these dead bodies of my race track", 29 Mar 2006
By 
russell clarke "stipesdoppleganger" (halifax, west yorks) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (VINE VOICE)   
This review is from: Against Nature (Audio CD)
Once again I find my self; worryingly it must be said, in complete agreement with esteemed reviewer Mr Parkes. .....With one slight deviation, I think Fatima Mansions debut holds up better than some of their subsequent albums. It's better than "Valhalla Avenue" and at least as good as "Berties Brochures". It also contains two of their greatest songs, the wonderfully dulcet "On The Day I Lost Everything" and the extraordinary "Only Losers Take The Bus" where its paranoid protagonist screams abuse at the losers on public transport, but is terrified lest he become one of them.
After the suffocating demise of his previous band the , much maligned Micro Disney , Cathal Coughlan must have felt like a genie released from it's lamp or a demon raised from ancient slumber . Finally able to shake of the shiny MOR coat that formerly embraced him Coughlan turned into a demented almost evangelical preacher; chock full of spite, hate and bitter humour. Incidentally I must stick up for Microdisney here, who have received like many a ball playing striker, an unfair kicking. Criticised by Simon Reynolds in his book "Blissed Out" as misguided peddlers of cerebral social reason whose music wouldn't raise the pulse of a beached whale they were also wasted intellect he accused, but is intellect ever wasted? And I happen to think they wrote some stupendous songs. But songs aren't Reynolds strong point; so much as I enjoy his work I think we should ignore him on that point.
And if you want songs there are more corkers here. The compassionate rage of "You Won't Get Me Home" a diatribe on the witch hunt against AIDS victims set a tune dazzled with a blizzard of pop stardust. Most bizarrely there is the euphoric stomping disco of "13th Century Boy" which if it was covered by any mainstream act, Girls Aloud or The Sugababes say, would be a colossal hit. Coughlan, one of music's great under rated voices can do big ballads as well, as he proves with "Wilderness On Time" and closing track "Big Madness". Ponderous production slightly ballasts the zealous portentous "Bishop Of Babel" but the giddy gallop of "Valley Of The Dead Cars" compensates.
Perhaps the albums title alludes to the fact that previously Coughlan was acting against his conscience, bottling up his despair and fury. That Microdisney was holding him back and that indeed he agreed with Reynolds assessment of them as "aural semolina". Well with this album he started to get things off his chest and it made for thrilling uneasy listening. I concur with Jason Parkes on another thing. A box set is really rather essential. Like just about anything Coughlan is involved with really.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Lost in the Former West
Lost in the Former West by Fatima Mansions (Audio CD - 1994)
Add to wishlist See buying options
Only search this product's reviews