Most helpful positive review
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful
The Lucky Locket hangs around your precious neck.
on 15 August 2003
Elton’s first album has been called naive and under produced, and that the only half-decent song on it is ‘Skyline Pigeon’. I disagree with this thinking. The opening track ‘Empty Sky’ offers the listener a wonderful example of the partnership between Bernie and Elton. The lyrics show the genesis of Bernie’s awareness of emotional situations and his interest in isolation and loss, a theme that runs through the band’s early work. The Album also shows Elton’s roots in music with some wonderful riffs and use of instruments. I don’t disagree that he went on to make much better work, however I like subject matter of these songs and I like the composition.
If you pick up the classic year’s version, you will also be treated to ‘Lady Samantha’ Elton first single. Hard to believe it never charted in 1969.