Shop now Shop now Shop now  Up to 50% Off Fashion  Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

4.6 out of 5 stars22
4.6 out of 5 stars
Format: Paperback|Change
Price:£9.98+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

TOP 500 REVIEWERon 25 December 2013
This is the first volume of the Hungarian classic, the "Transylvanian Trilogy", set in the years from 1904 to 1906. Transylvania was then a province of the Hungarian part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.

Part One opens with Count Balint Abady, a young member of the Hungarian Parliament, going to attend a large party held at the castle of a neighbouring member of the aristocracy - it will be beautifully described later - , and for the first two chapters we are swamped by the other people who attended it. I jotted down some 35 names before I gave up as new people kept on being named - a really forbidding beginning, and only the favourable reviews written by other readers on the Amazon site kept me going. At the beginning of Part Two there is a shooting party at another castle, and more than a dozen further new names are introduced. Many of these people belong to inter-related families; but, unless the reader is willing to skim over this, he will have to work out, bit by bit, even until quite late in the novel, in what way they are connected; and even then it is not always clear: family trees would have been very welcome. In my opinion the book would have been very much better if a large number of the lesser characters which throng its pages had been eliminated.

There are many passages about Hungarian politics - for example about the difficult relationship between the Hungarian and the Austrian halves of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Since 1867 the Hungarians were supposed to be equal partners, with separate governments but, to their resentment, there is a common army which they feel is controlled by the Austrians. In Part Two we learn about the scandalous events in the Hungarian Parliament on "the 18th November" (year not given, though it is 1904), which seem to be well known to Hungarian readers, but what exactly was at stake here or later in the book will not be at all clear to readers who are not familiar with Hungarian history in general and that of Transylvania in particular. There are, for example, references to a Memorandum Trial which is not otherwise explained. (It had in fact led to the imprisonment in 1892 of a number of Romanians for having published a Memorandum demanding of national representation for their people.) Banffy, who had himself been elected to the Hungarian Parliament in 1901, makes clear that he disapproved of the policy of the Hungarian Prime Minister, Count Tisza, positively detested the rabble of the opposition which secured a majority in 1905, and was opposed to the government imposed by the Crown later that year and to the temporary suspension the Hungarian Constitution early in 1906.

We are given a picture of the life-style and etiquette (at balls, at hunting parties, at card games, at duels) of this narrow and introverted aristocratic circle, their lives punctuated by one glittering party after another, with stiff footmen in attendance, where passions have to conveyed discreetly, where talk was shallow and where gossip was rife, where passions had to be conveyed discreetly, and where the men who did not dance gambled heavily at card tables. As in other novels of the period, financial ruin threatens some of these nobles. We meet various obsequious and not-to-be trusted hangers-on. Attitudes are feudal, hierarchical and snobbish. Balint alone has something of a social conscience and cares about the Romanian peasants on his estate. The other aristocrats are scarcely conscious of them. All this while Austria-Hungary is weakened by internal tensions between the two halves of the Empire (and also between the Hungarian ruling class and the Romanian population in Transylvania); and the Hungarian parliamentarians are so caught up in these internal disputes that they pay no attention the threats to the Empire from outside.

Eventually the book will revolve principally around only a small handful of the huge cast of characters: Balint Abady (in love with the unhappily married Adrienne Uzdy, - a subtle portrait); his cousin Laszlo Gyeroffi (in love with Klara Kollonich, whose father and step-mother intend her to marry someone of a more exalted social standing).

Their love stories, with their tortuous courses full of understandings and misunderstandings, will then sail along far more readably and indeed grippingly, though they will frequently be interrupted by politics, or by lyrical descriptions of Banffy's beloved Transylvanian landscapes at the different seasons of the year, and of the exteriors and interiors of the many manors which are the settings of the events in the book. A subplot about a scoundrel of an Austrian officer, Egon Wickwitz, will merge with that of Balint and Laszlo.

The characters of these two cousins diverge more and more: Balint remaining noble, idealistic and with a strong sense of patriarchal duty, while Laszlo drifted into reckless self-destruction. The ending of this first volume of the Trilogy leaves much in the air, and some readers will want to go immediately to the second volume (They Were Found Wanting) and to the third (They Were Divided). I may do this myself eventually; but for the moment I am rather exhausted by a novel which, for all its many qualities, is rather long drawn out and presents the other difficulties to which I have already referred.
11 comment|9 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 7 December 2006
This book is a fascinating insight into the social and political history of Hungary in the early years of the 20th century. It ranges from the intricacies of political life in Budapest to the equally challenging task of running an estate in Translyvania. Although the deeper aspects of politics and parliamentary life might not interest some readers, there is much, much more to the book than that. It would love to be able to read it in the original Hungarian, as I'm sure the writing is more elegant than this rather clunky translation. Nonetheless it is thoroughly enjoyable and very good for a long holiday read.
0Comment|23 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 21 January 2004
This book is exceptional in that it portrays a complete vision of Hungary; social, political and historical at the end of the 19th century leading to the first world war. While claiming to be a novel, it includes a detailed explanation of the historical context of the run up to the first world war and the problems that still beset the balkans, written by somebody who was in a position to witness these momentous times. A must-read for anyone interested in European history or affairs. Volumes 2 and 3 are equally powerful, albeit shorter.
Shame about the typographical errors though, but it did not spoil the read.
0Comment|41 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 13 December 1999
This is a major novel, the first of a trilogy, newly translated from Hungarian. The author's interests are Proustian but the style is lighter, and more straightforwardly romantic. However, the personal dramas are set against a detailed and vivid coverage of the lives and mores of the Hungarian aristocracy of Transylvania in 1906. The background meanwhile depicts the politics and strains of Austro-Hungary in what were to prove to be its final years. The author, a contemporary aristocrat, wrote the novel in the 1930s, and it has lain unnoticed during the communist era. The novel has had excellent reviews, for example in the Times Literary Supplement.
0Comment|37 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 25 November 2013
I bought this because my father gave me books two and three (he had bought them for a friend who already had them). The setting is apparantly vaguely autobiographical, the nobility of Hungary and Rumania at the beginning of the 20th Century before the implosion of the Austro-Hungarian Empire which was caused by the 1st World War.

We get through this book to live in a life of unbelievable splendour, huge palaces and castles, estates of thousands of hectares, affairs, unrequited love, parties where the dancing was frenetic and gave brief moments for unmarried romance, rarely ceasing before dawn. Fortunes made and lost in the Casino at cards. Duels, shooting, hunting, high politics, music. We meet glamorous countesses, princesses, even the Royal Family and learn about the world of the rich and privileged and the marriage market where, as was happening in Great Britain at this time, a long lineage and a title were traded for a handsome dowry if no marriage of equals could be found.

The cast list is quite long and the sub-plots are many which is why it is so difficult to put down because there is so much suspense and one just has to keep turning the pages to find out what is happening. The introductions by Paddy Fermor and the translators are fascinating in themselves. I considered myself fairly well read but I had no idea of quite what a magnificent lifestyle these aristocrats had. I assume that survived the First War and only came to an end with Soviet occupation but I am now absolutely hooked on the region and the wealth that existed there.

This really ranks as a superb novel, every bit as good as Tolstoy but more modern (and just as long).
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 17 December 2014
As others have said it takes a while to focus, but once I had finished it I immediately ordered the next episode I was so interested to see what would happen to the characters. There are many characters who weave in and out of the story. I found it easiest to not be over concerned with following all of the relationships but to let the story unfold. If you have the stamina and enjoy a book that slowly unrolls this will suit you.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 January 2015
A fascinating read.It was like being young again when you find a great and to oneself unknown author,and you becoem immersed in the bookI immediatley went on to volume 2.My only concern is when I have finished.I will miss the world of Miklos Banffy
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 16 June 2013
Trollope's Palliser novels meet Dostoevsky in the last days of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. the gilded bubble of the aristocracy reflects the wider world around them, of which they seem - in the main - to be blissfully unaware.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 12 August 2013
Utterly absorbing. Dramatic, funny, touching, poignant, anti-political historical drama, metaphor-drenched, realistic, character-rich, hopelessly romantic, sad. All that and more. Can't wait to read Books 2 and 3.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 July 2014
Miklos Banffy is the Lampedusa of Transylvania. If you want to understand what is going on East Europe today and what happened 100 years ago at Sarajevo, read the three books. Fascinating.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse