Customer Reviews


3 Reviews
5 star:
 (3)
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 
Most Helpful First | Newest First

8 of 10 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The one Israel has been losing, 7 Oct 2005
By 
Pieter Uys "Toypom" (Johannesburg) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (HALL OF FAME REVIEWER)   
This review is from: The Other War: Israelis, Palestinians and the Struggle for Media Supremacy (Hardcover)
This highly readable book takes one behind the media scenes and agendas of the conflict in the Holy Land. In a most engaging fashion, the author explains how journalism works in practice whilst exposing the gross bias against the Israeli side. She names the worst culprits, both individuals and organisations. The latter include the BBC, National Public Radio, The Guardian, The Independent, CNN, Associated Press and that old grey harlot, The New York Times.

Using examples like the death of the 12 year old Palestinian boy Mohammed Ad-Dura, the gruesome lynching of two Israeli reservists in Ramallah and the so-called Jenin Massacre that was later debunked by a United Nations investigation, Gutmann provides plenty of detail on how the anti-Israel propagandists operate. Truth be told, some of the blame rests on the Israeli side where the media war was not handled correctly. For example, Israeli spokespeople have not always received adequate resources or been proficient enough in English. This situation is now being improved.

One of the most glaring examples of media hypocrisy is the way in which Israel's security fence has been portrayed, with false analogies to the Berlin Wall. This while the EU intends to erect a barrier on its eastern borders and there are similar fences or walls between Turkey and Syria, and between Yemen and Saudi Arabia, to mention just a few. Gutmann reports that the situation is improving but I think much damage has already been done if one considers recent opinion polls conducted in several countries of Old Europe where alarming percentages of the population see Israel as the greatest threat to world peace.

Then again, this might just be a resurgence of the old European Anti-Semitism now surfacing again under the guise of Anti-Zionism. In this regard, I refer the reader to Bat Ye'or's magisterial work Eurabia. There are also brave Arab reporters, like the Israeli citizen Khalid Abu Toameh of the Jerusalem Post. A whole chapter looks at his work, a refreshing example of objective journalism. Gutmann's revelations are indeed disturbing because not all news consumers are willing to think for themselves, let alone investigate other angles.

It seems that the real roots of the Anti-Israel bias derive from Israel's victory in the 1967 war when the old Soviet propaganda apparatus started the demonization campaign. It gained further momentum during the First and Second Intifadas. Now Israel is routinely scapegoated by the leftist media and by dominant sectors in academia. This ideologically based bias has reached alarming proportions in Europe and only a few principled voices are reacting against it, like Oriana Fallaci in her books The Rage And The Pride, and The Force of Reason.

The Other War is a brilliantly researched book, full of verifiable facts and expert analyses, and at the same time a gripping read. Highly recommended for those who are interested in the Middle East conflict or who would like to get an inside look at how the media function. I also recommend Israel: Life In The Shadow Of Terror by Nechemia Coopersmith, Unholy Alliance by David Horowitz and The New Anti-Semitism by Phyllis Chesler.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


6 of 8 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Controlling the public's perception. Required reading., 9 Feb 2006
By 
M. D Roberts (Gwent, United Kingdom) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)    (REAL NAME)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Other War: Israelis, Palestinians and the Struggle for Media Supremacy (Hardcover)
This extremely relevant and well written study subjects the media coverage of the Palestinian/Arab-Israeli conflict to a meticulous scrutiny.
Providing a behind the scenes perspective & an abundance of examples, the writer documents what she describes as the distorted, inaccurate and egregious bias against Israel throughout the realm of the mainstream media.
The book reveals how so many journalists, photographers and editors are sometimes guided by what is cited as a “hardened anti-Israel ideology” often selectively omitting pivotal factors thus portraying a false image of the reality on the ground.
The writer emphasising the public now need to become what she calls “experts at inspecting, analysing and demystifying the news product” with a need to know who/what is behind the source providing the news itself.
One of the reasons for writing this book being described as the fact that “pictures do lie” and that behind every picture is a long story & a list of people who decide how and in what manner that particular picture is presented, as the full background is rarely depicted.
Throughout the book the reader is confronted with the fact that the news media is the world’s spokesman and through controlling the information provided to the public and the manner in which it is presented, subsequently controls the public’s judgement and perception.
The writer strives to underscore how those within media are very much aware of their enormous power to manipulate and use their power & platform to their full advantage, with most of the world, allegedly having yet to learn that the media is NOT a non-profit organisation working for the betterment of the human race. To the contrary, the book reveals how the media competes fiercely for elite positions, career making scoops and headline supremacy.
Many instances are shown which reveal that, purportedly, the media will readily falsify, fake and fabricate news to achieve it’s own ends, staging events for the benefit of the ever present cameras.
The cover of the book itself displayed scores of media photographers lined to obtain a controlled/staged photograph of a Palestinian throwing a missile.
The writer illustrates how that in the early years of the Palestinian intifada about 95% of the TV pictures on satellite were supplied by Palestinian film crews and that many journalists have shown themselves unwilling to attribute any blame to the Palestinian side as such would allegedly endanger their physical welfare and prevent future access to essential sources/areas upon which the news entities utterly rely for their coverage.
Other issues examined include Jenin, the Ramallah lynching of Israeli soldiers and Palestinian celebrations after the September 11th attacks on the US where some 3,000 Palestinians were filmed rejoicing in the streets in the wake of the murders of so many innocent people. The study describes how the footage of such events was destroyed due to the fact that a photographer was then allegedly held in the office of the Governor of Nablus with gunmen holding the barrels of their weapons held against his skull. A demand then being made that if the video of the celebrations was not destroyed, the photographer would be executed. The film was subsequently destroyed. (Page 152)
Another issue studied is the visit of Ariel Sharon to Jerusalem’s Temple Mount which media sources have blamed for the outbreak of the second intifada. Detailed analysis in the study reveals that this was anything but the case and that the Palestinian violence had already been pre-planned. The book’s evaluation disclosing that Sharon’s visit to Judaism’s most holy site was agreed beforehand with the Palestinian authorities and that Sharon made no attempt to even enter Islamic holy sites.
The writer pulls no punches in apportioning considerable blame on the part of the Israeli government for not making their own case known on innumerable occasions.
The book also includes a case study on the killing of Mohammed al-Dura, aged 12 years, allegedly by Israeli troops at the Netzarim junction in Gaza.
The reader is shown the media’s haste to utterly condemn the Israelis for an apparent act of cold blooded murder. The book analyses the evidence in considerable detail and confronts the reader with a very different reality.
For example the sole footage of the incident is shown to have been provided by a Palestinian freelance photographer located close to, and directly opposite the child at the time of the shooting & that on the day of the incident a plethora of film crews arrived before any demonstrators and the Israelis are cited as knowing that something big was being prepared. (Page 45).
The book cites how subsequent Israeli and independent investigations revealed that the shots that killed the boy could not have been fired by Israeli troops due to obstacles, angles of fire & that even the bullets that hit the child and the surrounding barricades were purportedly not of the kind used by the Israeli Defence Forces but instead the type used by the Palestinians on scene & and having allegedly been fired from the direction where the Palestinian photographer had filmed the incident.
No forensic, autopsy or medical evidence is shown to have been supplied by the Palestinian police or medical services who had sole possession of the child’s body, with Palestinian opinion instead being reported as fact.
An independent report cited in the book also reveals that Mohammed al Dura’s mother stated that a few days before his death, he had asked her “If you’re killed in Netzarim, do you die as a martyr?”. The alleged involvement of Mohammed’s father as an Israeli collaborator out to purportedly redeem himself is also studied. However perverse this may seem, the information needs to be read.
Despite such evidence being available the reader is shown how the media itself showed little if any interest in following up their original portrayal of events or re-examining any such data or testimonies that may absolve Israel of responsibility in this tragic event. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4 of 6 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars The one Israel has been losing, 5 Oct 2005
By 
Pieter Uys "Toypom" (Johannesburg) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (HALL OF FAME REVIEWER)   
This review is from: The Other War: Israelis, Palestinians and the Struggle for Media Supremacy (Hardcover)
This highly readable book takes one behind the media scenes and agendas of the conflict in the Holy Land. In a most engaging fashion, the author explains how journalism works in practice whilst exposing the gross bias against the Israeli side. She names the worst culprits, both individuals and organisations. The latter include the BBC, National Public Radio, The Guardian, The Independent, CNN, Associated Press and that old grey harlot, The New York Times.

Using examples like the death of the 12 year old Palestinian boy Mohammed Ad-Dura, the gruesome lynching of two Israeli reservists in Ramallah and the so-called Jenin Massacre that was later debunked by a United Nations investigation, Gutmann provides plenty of detail on how the anti-Israel propagandists operate. Truth be told, some of the blame rests on the Israeli side where the media war was not handled correctly. For example, Israeli spokespeople have not always received adequate resources or been proficient enough in English. This situation is now being improved.

One of the most glaring examples of media hypocrisy is the way in which Israel's security fence has been portrayed, with false analogies to the Berlin Wall. This while the EU intends to erect a barrier on its eastern borders and there are similar fences or walls between Turkey and Syria, and between Yemen and Saudi Arabia, to mention just a few. Gutmann reports that the situation is improving but I think much damage has already been done if one considers recent opinion polls conducted in several countries of Old Europe where alarming percentages of the population see Israel as the greatest threat to world peace.

Then again, this might just be a resurgence of the old European Anti-Semitism now surfacing again under the guise of Anti-Zionism. In this regard, I refer the reader to Bat Ye'or's magisterial work Eurabia. There are also brave Arab reporters, like the Israeli citizen Khalid Abu Toameh of the Jerusalem Post. A whole chapter looks at his work, a refreshing example of objective journalism. Gutmann's revelations are indeed disturbing because not all news consumers are willing to think for themselves, let alone investigate other angles.

It seems that the real roots of the Anti-Israel bias derive from Israel's victory in the 1967 war when the old Soviet propaganda apparatus started the demonization campaign. It gained further momentum during the First and Second Intifadas. Now Israel is routinely scapegoated by the leftist media and by dominant sectors in academia. This ideologically based bias has reached alarming proportions in Europe and only a few principled voices are reacting against it, like Oriana Fallaci in her books The Rage and Pride, and The Force Of Reason.

The Other War is a brilliantly researched book, full of verifiable facts and expert analyses, and at the same time a gripping read. Highly recommended for those who are interested in the Middle East conflict or who would like to get an inside look at how the media function. I also recommend Israel: Life In The Shadow Of Terror by Nechemia Coopersmith, Unholy Alliance by David Horowitz and The New Antisemitism by Phyllis Chesler.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

The Other War: Israelis, Palestinians and the Struggle for Media Supremacy
14.99
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews