Top critical review
5 people found this helpful
Misleading Description- incomplete!!
on 5 November 2013
This basically ignores the 40 years of Doctor Who before 2005. It's fine if all you are interested in is the post-2005 stuff. If this was advertised as the Encyclopedia of Doctor Who From 2005 on, I wouldn't mind at all, but it is advertised above as "the ultimate guide to everything and everyone that's ever happened, un-happened and happened again in the worlds and times of the Doctor." This really grates, because it's just quite obviously untrue. It ignores nearly 40 years of Doctor Who!!
Again, it is advertised as being "your complete tour of time and space--from Abaddon and Inspector Abberline to Melody Zucker and the Zygons." But isn't 'complete' at all.
I would only consider getting this if you are not interested in the rich history of a Great British show, and only wish to know about the last 8 years of it.