Customer Reviews


4 Reviews
5 star:
 (2)
4 star:
 (1)
3 star:
 (1)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


13 of 14 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A critical look of an integral part of Operation Little Saturn
Though the raid happened in the last week in December, 1942, Mr Forczyk begins his story on November 23rd when Zhukov's two forces meet at Kalach to encircle Paulus's 6th Army at Stalingrad. The significance of the encirclement for both sides is explained as well as the precarious position the Germans were facing. The Soviets have come back from the edge of destruction at...
Published on 20 April 2012 by Dave History Student

versus
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars A story well told
This book tells the story of one action in a titanic struggle. The struggle was known to the Soviets as the Great Patriotic War and the Tatsinskaya raid in late 1942 was the first Deep Operation by the Red Army that, if only partially, achieved its original objective. Lacking adequate communications equipment and logistical support the raiders achieved their goal of...
Published 24 months ago by B. C. Lowry


Most Helpful First | Newest First

13 of 14 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A critical look of an integral part of Operation Little Saturn, 20 April 2012
This review is from: Red Christmas - The Tatsinskaya Airfield Raid 1942 (Paperback)
Though the raid happened in the last week in December, 1942, Mr Forczyk begins his story on November 23rd when Zhukov's two forces meet at Kalach to encircle Paulus's 6th Army at Stalingrad. The significance of the encirclement for both sides is explained as well as the precarious position the Germans were facing. The Soviets have come back from the edge of destruction at Stalingrad and regained the initiative while the Germans have placed themselves in a potentially disastrous position with their shortsighted strategy in their attempt to capture Stalingrad at all costs.
Hitler sends Manstein to relieve Paulus while starting a logistic airlift the very next day to keep 6th Army in food, fuel and ammunition until Manstein relieves 6th Army. The airlift would be primarily flown from two airfields : Tatsinskaya and nearby Morozovsk.
Stavka's plans were much more ambitious than just to destroy 6th Army at Stalingrad. With the help of Vasilevsky and Voronov, Operation Little Saturn is developed to destroy AGS as well through a winter offensive using their strategic doctrine of "Deep Operations". Its the Soviet version of Blitzkrieg where the front line is penetrated and armor is quickly sent to the German rear to induce an encirclement.

The author spends five pages of Chapter Two describing the evolution of this "Deep Operations" theory which began in the early 20s after the Revolution and it was still evolving to this point in time. Though it wasn't expected in this small book, this chapter entitled "Origins" was very interesting and will give the reader good background info on Soviet strategic theory and the men who developed it as well as the how and why Operation Little Saturn and the Tatsinskaya Raid were initiated.
The next two chapters move out of doctrine and into the specifics of the planning, dispositions, preparations and objectives for the launch and execution of the Raid. The fifty page Raid then delivers a daily chronicle of Badanov's 24th Tank Corp (plus other units) penetrating the front line and driving toward the Tatsinskaya airfield. It also includes the German counter measures to prevent the loss of the airfields and when the airfields were captured, the German counter-attack and the subsequent encirclement and destruction of 24th TC is expertly provided.
While the Soviets have the lead in the story, the Germans are not ignored by any means. The attempted airlift of Stalingrad and the new defensive line along the Chir River are lightly discussed but the main German proponents in the defense of the airfields (11th PzD, 6th PzD and the 306th ID) are given considerably more attention as they try to prevent the airfields from falling into Soviet hands as well as preventing the Soviets from getting behind AG Don and AGS and destroying them.

Besides the concise, informative narrative four maps with crib notes, two action illustrations and many photos expand the reader's experience. The color maps show the key locations and events of the Soviet drive and the subsequent counter-attack by the Germans.

A six page Analysis and a two page Conclusions section completes and does justice to the daring Raid. Though Badanov of 24th TC made some important tactical mistakes in his drive to the airfields, his corps did destroy quite a few planes and captured the airfield for three days, preventing supplies from reaching 6th Army. The lost of planes also degrades the Luftwaffe's response to the airlift which weakens Paulus's ability to resist the onslaught at Stalingrad. The incursion, despite losing much of 24th TC, also caused further weakness in the German line on the Chir that will help Little Saturn be successful in the days ahead. Fiebig's poor defense of the Tatsinskaya field is also described. Costs for both sides are tallied as well as experiences gained by the Red Army in perfecting their strategic offensive theory.
A useful Bibliography and Index close out the book.

Mr Forczyk has done a very nice job in presenting the important features of this Raid and along with the quality maps, colorful illustrations and many photos makes this an easy recommendation to all enthusiasts of post Stalingrad encirclement history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars A story well told, 28 Dec 2012
By 
B. C. Lowry (Great Britain) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Red Christmas - The Tatsinskaya Airfield Raid 1942 (Paperback)
This book tells the story of one action in a titanic struggle. The struggle was known to the Soviets as the Great Patriotic War and the Tatsinskaya raid in late 1942 was the first Deep Operation by the Red Army that, if only partially, achieved its original objective. Lacking adequate communications equipment and logistical support the raiders achieved their goal of taking out the Tatsinskaya airfield and so denying the besieged German defenders of Stalingrad one of their key aerial supply bases.

The author, who has written a number of other books for Osprey on the GPW, relates the origins of Deep Operations; the less-than-rosy fates of the principal proponent (Isserson) and executor (Pavlov); the problems that beset the operation, and the lessons learnt. That the Red Army learnt the lessons is apparent from its crushing defeat of the Wehrmacht in the East and in the lightning expulsion of the Japanese from Manchuria in August 1945. Had the Cold War become hot, then similar tactics would have been used in any attack on NATO forces. All of these points are discussed in a clear and concise manner by the author, aided by explanatory maps and very dramatic reconstructions of key events in the raid.
A-20c light bomber.

So far, so good. However, I have to point out that the book is let down by the fact that a number of the many interesting photographs are incorrectly or misleadingly captioned. On page 15 a photograph of an Ilyushin Il-4 medium bomber is captioned as a US lend-lease A20C light bomber. The photograph on page 46 refers to bombs being stocked on the airfield (why send these to Stalingrad?), whilst it is clear that the 'bombs' are containers for ammunition for German lFH 18 howitzers (the information is chalked on the containers). On page 51 a corpse is described as being part of a German transport unit when it is apparent that it is dressed in a Red Army winter uniform, and in the rear of the US-supplied GMC truck is a musette of Soviet PTRD anti-tank rifle ammunition! On page 63 the aircraft should be referred to by its earlier designation of U-2 and not Po-2. This is a pity as the errors mar an otherwise excellent account of a daring venture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Me Too, 2 Oct 2012
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Red Christmas - The Tatsinskaya Airfield Raid 1942 (Paperback)
I have nothing much to add that Dave the history man has not said except to support his opinion. This must be the greatest tank raid in history, one hell of a Thunder Run, and the book does it justice.
Very Good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


4.0 out of 5 stars anyway I can recommend this book very much, 10 Dec 2014
I estimate the author's work very much . This is a very interesting account of a crucial episode of the battle for Stalingrad .
May be errors in some details as other reviewers have mentioned , anyway I can recommend this book very much .
Wigand Wüster ( Stalingrad veteran , author of "An artilleryman in Stalingrad" )
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Red Christmas - The Tatsinskaya Airfield Raid 1942
Red Christmas - The Tatsinskaya Airfield Raid 1942 by Robert Forczyk (Paperback - 20 April 2012)
£11.99
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews