Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop All Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now DIYED Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Oasis Listen with Prime Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars19
4.3 out of 5 stars
Format: Mass Market Paperback|Change
Price:£6.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

With a change of authors, I expected this offering to be marked improvement on the previous outings. Unfortunately it was sadly yet another failure in the published world of the Winchester Brothers. The story was weak and I felt, after season five, that I'd heard it all before. The first couple of pages was ridiculous as the author seemed to have mixed Sam and Dean up, the tale then changed tack and you could see that this book had more than one writer as it wasn't a smooth transition. Again the characters didn't come across and had I read these novels prior to watching the TV series, I would never have bothered. The author's really don't seem to know the characters, the plot outline goes into a "where can I put them now that I have time travel available" scenario and the overall effect is a complete waste of time. As mentioned in the other review, give the fans a chance to write a tale or two even if its just a series of short stories, they'll be more successful, they'll have a better grasp of the characters and the tales presented will be something not only novel but more on the tack of the original concept.
11 comment|13 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
An original novel based on the tv show supernatural, about two brothers who hunt monsters and demons across the backroads of america. The book makes very few concessions for those who aren't familiar with the show or the ongoing plot of it's fifth season, during which it's set. But since the only people who are likely to read this are fans of the show, that shouldn't be a problem.

It runs for three hundred and thirty two pages and is divided into thirty three reasonably short chapters plus a prologue and an epilogue.

And the story it tells is all new and not one that has been seen or told in any other medium.

The story starts with Sam and Dean investigating signs of supernatural occurrences in a few small towns. As a result of which they meet an angel. Who has a proposition. A way to permanently deal with the escaped angel Lucifer. A method that has remained a secret.

But to find it Don has to send them somewhere. Where they'll have to rely on their wits, and might just make allies. Whilst all the time demons are watching. Not least someone who has been waiting a very long time to get back into the game.

I won't say too much about where he sends them because it's not revealed on the back cover and it does come as a surprise. Once there a typical supernatural tale follows.

These tie in books can't actually do anything to alter tv show continuity so you know that the story is something that will all be wrapped up by the end and never mentioned again. There are plenty of decent character moments along the way though and it does take the chance to do a few large set pieces of the kind that wouldn't be possible on a tv budget.

But the writing isn't quite as smooth as it could be. The notes at the end mention it was a collaboration as the first choice writer had constraints on their time. And the writing does initlally jump back and forth a lot, from short scene with one character to short scene with another. This means it takes a little while to get into.

So all in all it's a pretty good supernatural novel and fans of the show shouldn't have much complaint. It just probably needed another draft to become a very good one.
0Comment|2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 April 2012
Let me be clear about one essential thing first. If you are looking for some serious knowledge about the Dead Sea Scroll known as the War Scroll, to which this novel refers, you will be disappointed and proved totally wrong. That the final pages of the scroll are missing is maybe true but does not matter really. The Scroll is what it is and nothing else. And anyway we cannot know what the supposedly missing pages could contain, certainly not bloodlines with modern names since two thousand years ago they could not know in the Middle East the naming practices of modern states, among others the United States. You can easily find the names of ancestors, but it is a lot more difficult to know the names of descendants, especially two thousand years down the line. It would have been just as realistic if the list had contained the email addresses and mobile phone numbers of the concerned individuals.

We must also be clear that these Scrolls are NOT pre-biblical, which would mean at least three thousand years old. The War Scroll is dated today between 20 BCE and 20 CE. The Essenes are thus contemporary to the emergence of the movement around John the Baptist and Jesus, the emergence of the new prophet that is considered by some to be the Messiah announced in the Old Testament. It is also contemporary to the taking over of the Middle East and Judea by the Romans, hence with the resistance against this colonization that will end badly with the assassination of the elder brother of Jesus, James, in 62 CE or slightly later by the priests of the Temple. This event will cause great trouble among Jews and then the destruction of the temple in 70 CE by the Romans. It is considered James was close to the Essenes of the Dead Sea Scrolls.

This being said the novel here under consideration is not a piece of scientific work and cannot be believed in its assertions on the Essenes and the Dead Sea Scrolls. Even if you believe in God and Lucifer and all the angels and demons, the Essenes are not on any side at all. They are plain human beings and their Dead Sea Scrolls represent what they thought at the time of writing. In the War Scroll the final war that is envisaged is the final war against the northern empire of the Assyrians and probably the Roman Empire when it started trickling down into the region. It is a human war manual that integrates some Roman war techniques showing its date of writing. So all that is said in the novel is pure fantasy if not pure invention, though the two words are rather related.

Now the novel is funny because it is a merchandizing byproduct of the series Supernatural. It is positioned right after the freeing of Lucifer by Sam when he killed Lilith, the 66th seal. A bad double agent Abaddon, supposedly an angel looking after Lucifer in his cage, is trying to make the two brothers cheat with supernatural history and is trying to pull the blanket to his side. They are forcefully sent to 1954 in New York, to seize the last pages of the War Scroll to be sold in this city then and to more or less keep Lucifer on the surface of the earth and hence Abaddon enjoying Mexico and other exotic places instead of hell. In fact it is a trick and he hopes the two brothers fall in the trap: get confronted to an organized coven of hunters who want to prevent the Apocalypse by getting the names of the blood lines and killing all those who would be vessels of angels or fallen angels at the time of Armageddon, the Winchester brothers among others. But at the same time the Hellhound pet of Lilith is freed from the amphorae and the second wife of Lucifer, Eisheth, is freed from the same amphorae. And this Eisheth wants all the angelic and fallen-angelic vessels killed except one, Sam who is her future "husband" when she reunites with Lucifer.

If you understand that complicated polygamous family business you can enjoy the adventures and especially the total incompetence of the two brothers, who only succeed on one point: to trick Eisheth into invading Sam (using him as a vessel) so that she makes them be transported back to 2010 by Abaddon, her included with her intention to reunite with Lucifer. That will cause some damage at the arrival in modern times when she in Sam is confronted to Abaddon, but that is an easy situation to be solved by angels of good faith, if there is one.

The novel is a little bit simple at the beginning and it takes quite some time for the rhythm to be found, at least some rhythm. But if everything had just been normal, the two brothers should have been killed at least twenty times by the Waldorf Hotel's security people, by the New York Police, not to speak of the FBI, the secret services, the railroad security guards and a few other bands of armed people of that type, not to count the hunters, the demons and the angels, and just plain angry bystanders and civilians.

The main problem with such a novel is that the original is a TV series, hence a visual universe and to translate it into words is quite not easy at all. And that difficulty is obvious here. The book lacks a style of its own and the two brothers are quite skeletal as for psychology and personality, especially the sex-crazed Dean. And Sam tries to be realistic when he admits he cannot learn ancient Aramaic in two days, how it was written and how to read it and translate it into plain English. And the helper they find does not seem to be much better. Even in 1954 Aramaic was known since it was the language of Jesus and its writing system was also well known since most of the gospels are written in that language originally. There might even be some dictionaries and grammars available by then, and once again it was not more than 2000 years old, so not at all in old Semitic languages like the hieroglyphs of old Egyptian as is insinuated a couple of times.

The main problem is probably that the novel was written too fast and by two authors, the main author acknowledging the fact that she was pressed by her pending marriage and that she had to use the services of some assistant. Two people on a novel necessarily produce a pith-less language, hence a style-less novel. Rebecca Dessertine should have chosen between a good novel or a good marriage (a marriage can always be postpone a couple of months), or just worked slightly harder.

But the book is altogether funny if you are in for a rather not too heady and too mental piece of reading.

Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 December 2011
Okay, I admit it, I love all things Supernatural and especially the unbreakable bond between Sam and Dean. I didn't like this book however. I didn't think it particularly well written, I would even go so far as saying I've read better on a Fanfiction Site although I was interested in finding out what was the secret in the scrolls. The main characters of Sam and Dean are at best two dimensional, the authors don't appear to have captured their 'voices' at all. I'm surprised that one of the authors has a close link with the TV show because it certainly isn't clear from the way Dean's character is portrayed, which is at best misogynistic towards a female within the story. Sam fairs a little better but we are left with no real insight of the brothers and it is only a familiarity with the show that makes the book readable. I doubt a new reader reading this book would be enticed into watching the series or dipping their toes into another Supernatural book. :(
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 28 November 2011
Bought it for my daughter as she is supernatural mad but she says this is not as good as some of the others she has read, but she says it is not how it is wrote rather when on the timeline which makes it dull!!

Unfortunately I cannot give any more information as I personally do not read them!
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 24 May 2013
Was everything that you could imagine it to be, a good back story to that fits in nicely with Lucifer Rising and the Angels of season 5. Definitely recommended for any SPN fan.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 31 May 2012
It's a very enjoyable read, continuing the ongoing story of the two brother who fight evil while, dealingh with family business and heartache.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 June 2011
I Love this book no matter what happens to them they always stick together and make sure each other are ok after all they are Winchester's =)
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 15 February 2013
if your a supernatural fan you love this, very easy read highly recomended from a supernatual addict as dean would say awesome
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 12 March 2016
The story is another one for the Winchester brothers and goes along side the TV show Supernatural providing a different story.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.