Customer Reviews


3 Reviews
5 star:
 (2)
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:
 (1)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Very very insightful
I don't give 5 stars that often but I found this book was very informative, entertaining and exciting.

Hirschfeld was a communications NCO on various German submarines and the book provides a good first person perspective on serving on an U-boat. Since he was a radio man he had access to a wealth of information making his story even better. This book is...
Published on 14 May 2008 by Gisli Jokull Gislason

versus
1.0 out of 5 stars Buyer beware
I purchased an earlier version of this book primarily because of my interest in U-234 and her cargo. These matters are covered in some detail in the final two chapters of this book which has been put together by Geoffrey Brooks, allegedly from conversations and correspondence with Hirschfeld, plus his 'secret diary', of which more later.

U-234 sailed from Japan...
Published 14 months ago by Ubootfahrer


Most Helpful First | Newest First

1.0 out of 5 stars Buyer beware, 13 May 2013
By 
Ubootfahrer (Portsmouth, UK) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Hirschfeld: The Story of a U-Boat NCO, 1940-1946 (Paperback)
I purchased an earlier version of this book primarily because of my interest in U-234 and her cargo. These matters are covered in some detail in the final two chapters of this book which has been put together by Geoffrey Brooks, allegedly from conversations and correspondence with Hirschfeld, plus his 'secret diary', of which more later.

U-234 sailed from Japan in mid-April 1945 carrying a number of important passengers, some of whom were to help the Japanese produce the Me 262 jet aircraft. The boat also carried some 240 tons of cargo that mainly consisted of spares and general supplies for U-boats, U-boat bases and other German naval stations in East Asia, but also included 93 tons of various items for the Japanese armed forces. For many years, stories about the latter have centred primarily on 560 kgs of uranium oxide and claims that at least one complete example of an Me 262 jet aircraft was aboard. While it is true that U-234 was indeed carrying uranium oxide for the Japanese Army, prompting lurid speculation about its purpose, exactly why it was being sent to Japan is still not known.

The Hirschfeld/Brooks account of the loading of the uranium oxide is fanciful and absurd, to say the least. According to the book, Hirschfeld apparently stood on the bridge watching two Japanese senior officers on their hands and knees on the foredeck yet was able to see them writing "U-235" on ten 9-inch square containers that were then put into one of the vertical mine shaft containers. That Hirschfeld's eyesight was so good is beyond belief, but the episode is complete invention. Ten 9-inch containers would obviously not have accommodated 560 kgs of uranium oxide, nor was it ever in any of the vertical bow containers; it was in fact stored in containers located in horizontal compartments on either side of the U-boat.

As for the claim that an Me 262 was aboard, this is also completely false. I have obtained a number of authentic documents relating to U-234, and where aircraft types are mentioned at all, the documents are perfectly clear in stating that only aircraft drawings - I repeat, drawings - were being carried to Japan, plus tooling for a few components known to be difficult to manufacture. Nowhere in the archives of the UK, US or Germany is there a shred of evidence to support the authors' claims that 'an Me 262 jet fighter in its component parts [was] stowed in the hold amidships'.

Finally, what of that 'secret diary' that Hirschfeld is supposed to have maintained? In his introduction, Brooks writes, 'I have based this book on Hirschfeld's private war diaries...' However, in Chapters 9 and 10, we find that when Hirschfeld was taken prisoner by the Americans in May 1945, most of his personal possessions, including the diaries, were stolen! 'My diaries, U-Boat leathers and fur outfit were gone,' we are told.

It is clear, therefore, that contrary to Brooks' and Hirschfeld's claims, such diaries - if they ever existed at all - could not have formed the basis of this book. Thus, in view of the misinformation and false allegations presented with regard to the uranium oxide and the Me 262, doubt is naturally cast over the accuracy of the rest of the work considering that it is largely based on this non-existent diary. Anyone buying this book is therefore warned to treat what they read with extreme caution and should disregard entirely anything about the Me 262. This is just a myth initiated and repeated by sensational publications such as this so often that it is erroneously accepted as fact. For the reasons given, readers of this book, and any researcher tempted to quote from it, would indeed be naive if, like the other reviewers, they regard it as a reliable source of information.

You any have to look at the ridiculous cover to see the book is flawed. It shows a Type XXI boat marked 235 whereas Hirschfeld served aboard U 234, a Type X, and in any case, wartime U-boats never displayed their number. Like much of the book, one suspects, that's pure Hollywood.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Very very insightful, 14 May 2008
By 
Gisli Jokull Gislason "Jokull" (Iceland) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)    (REAL NAME)   
I don't give 5 stars that often but I found this book was very informative, entertaining and exciting.

Hirschfeld was a communications NCO on various German submarines and the book provides a good first person perspective on serving on an U-boat. Since he was a radio man he had access to a wealth of information making his story even better. This book is surprising in detail, everything from lice to being captured and well treated by the US Navy. And the action is described in such a way that you want the U-boat to succeed.

For anyone who enjoyed Das Boot or has the slightest interest in the War of the Atlantic I heartly recommend this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


2 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A fascinating look through the eyes of the 'enemy', 12 May 1999
By A Customer
Anyone with the slightest interest in World War II submarine warfare will be unable to put this book down. It gives a graphic account of what these true heroes really went through each time they put to sea. Enjoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

Hirschfeld: The Story of a U-Boat NCO, 1940-1946
Hirschfeld: The Story of a U-Boat NCO, 1940-1946 by Geoffrey Brooks (Paperback - 16 Jun 2011)
10.09
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews