Shop now Shop now Shop now  Up to 50% Off Fashion  Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Shop now Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

4.1 out of 5 stars48
4.1 out of 5 stars
Format: Hardcover|Change
Price:£19.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 8 October 2013
I ordered this book in advance after seeing some of the pre-publicity material. I have to admit when it dropped though the letterbox I was initially a bit disappointed. I had been led to believe - or perhaps presumed - that this would be a large-format colour glossy coffee table style book. It was not, It was a smaller but substantially thicker (than I thought) book. So was I ultimately disappointed? No, not at all.
Rather than a simple book with a picture of a view with an extended caption (as this book so easily might have been) you get a more detailed narrative, supported by, not dominated by, the imagery. We get to learn more about the context and history of each location, and a very circumspect review. I had also expected, with the National Trust connection that this book might have laboured on rural landscapes and the 'Lost' England but no, Simon Jenkins selection of 100 views includes both the expected rustic scenes and the imposing urban. In particular he highlights one of my favourite views, that from the Old Royal Observatory in Greenwich Park where the elegance of the Royal Naval College and Queens House are juxtaposed with the developments of Canary Wharf and produce a view that is more than the sum of its parts.
So it's a book you can read, rather than merely look at. Do I have any complaints? Only that some of the views are shown not as they are now but in paintings. No problem with that - and some of those paintings are very appropriate - but it would have great to see the contemporary view for all the locations. A small point though, that should not detract from this book overall. Recommended.
22 comments|48 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 31 July 2014
There are three people in our house who love the countryside and none enjoyed reading this book. Writing is too technical
and stiff and the photos too small to properly convey the beauty of englands landscapes.I generally find simon jenkins writing on the dull side.He has a grasp of facts but fails to make them stimulate our imagination.Quotes and poetry by famous people dont enhance the readers expwrience.Buy Coast instead.
0Comment|3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
After well-received books on England’s 1000 best churches and 1000 best houses, Simon Jenkins now gives us his 100 best views, chosen (he writes in his introduction) by “an ever-changing blend of geology and climate, seasons of the year, time of day, even my own mood at the time.” He asserts a measure of objectivity in his choice. But one man’s beauty is another’s ugliness or indifference, isn’t it? Surely the moors and mountains that were seen as forbidding and barren to the eyes of the sixteenth-century, but which now feature as sites of scenic glory, proves this.

But not according to Jenkins who defends “the concept of best, contesting the idea that beauty of any sort, especially of landscape is subjective.” He supports this statement by the equally strange assertion that, “If visual beauty were purely subjective, conversation about art would cease.” How odd!

He later contradicts himself by appreciating that, “I am acutely aware that what we find beautiful today, those in the past found terrifying, ugly or boring.” Indeed contradictions abound, so that one wonders what Jenkins thinks. One minute he quotes Constable, who, “when criticised for including workaday scenes in his pictures, … declared loftily: ‘I never saw an ugly thing in my life.’” Yet Jenkins rails against the modern workaday – “prairie fields, silos, power stations and … wind turbines.”

At last he can be honest with us, and confess to bias (for which, read ‘subjectivity’): “In gazing on a view I cannot rejoice at grim spruce plantations, intrusive warehouses, waving turbines or random city towers … I delight in natural materials and the patina of age. I apologise to those who disagree and find these biases irritating. They will have theirs.” For instance, of Ribblehead, “I am often asked why, if old viaducts and bridges can be said to add to a landscape, later intruders such as wind turbines and power stations should detract from it. The answer lies partly in materials.”

He concedes that his criteria means that his choice is “skewed towards the west and north” where contours abound (East Anglia, for instance, has only six of the hundred), and that his bias is against the urban – “Future generations may come to see today’s Bristol, Birmingham, Manchester and Sheffield as beautiful. I can only doubt it.” Shame. He does not deny a chocolate-box approach, “because chocolate-box makers know what is popular, and popular for a reason.” What a crass argument!

Looking at the geography of Jenkins’s choice, top is the West Country (seventeen views, but actually sixteen because one of the Exmoor views is in Devon, not Somerset). Then comes the West Midlands (fourteen views, but actually fifteen because the Roaches are in Staffordshire, as Jenkins’s own text makes clear). The South has thirteen, followed by the North West with twelve, nine of which are in the Lake District. Devon and Cornwall have eleven (but actually twelve), and Yorkshire ten. East Anglia, the North East, and London each have six, whilst bottom of the pile is the East Midlands with five (actually four, all of which are in the Peak District). The following counties have no entries: Bedfordshire, Essex, Hertfordshire, Leicestershire, Lincolnshire, Northamptonshire, Nottinghamshire, Rutland, Surrey, and Warwickshire.

The errors in geography bring me on to errors in the text. In the very first entry (Botallack in Cornwall) we are told of words written by John Norden in 1539, but Norden was not yet born at this date. No monks of Glastonbury fled to Strata Florida. It was not a Somerset accent that voiced the Hovis advert. Is it the Earl of March or the Duke of Richmond at Goodwood? Britain was not made an island 400,000 years ago. The Cuckmere is not “the last undeveloped river mouth on England’s south coast” (there’s the Erme, amongst others). The Cavendishes of Chatsworth were not “a local family that married Bess of Hardwick” (what, all of them?!), but came originally from Suffolk. Scarborough is not in the East Riding of Yorkshire. Scandinavia was pagan in 664, not Christian. And Jenkins has problems with his compass points at the top of Dunkery Beacon and on the Roaches. And these are just a selection of those that I spotted.

So is there nothing to praise? Yes, there are two: the illustrations and Jenkins’s way with words. As for the former, they are not all wonderful contemporary photographs: I counted fourteen paintings (new and old), two engravings, an archive photo, a GWR poster, and a Hovis advert.

As for the latter, take your choice! Here are a few marvels from just the very first entry: “The landscape of St Just [in Cornwall] is … as if County Durham had come south to die”; “an impenetrable nomenclature of metapelite hornfels and pegmatite dykes”; whilst alluding to the view’s geology, “The writer Wilkie Collins admitted to being petrified.” Was it Jenkins or Collins who suggested that apt final word? Other ingenious metaphors in this part of the world include the sea’s violence at Hartland making it “an X-certificate coast”, but the soothing surf at Kynance is “perpetually posing for a photograph.”

I could go on with other examples of Jenkins’s felicity with language, but I finish my review by reminding myself of the words he also uses to claim a false objectivity. With this in mind, this book comprises only Simon Jenkins’s 100 best views of England. They are not my 100 best views. And they will not – should not – be yours.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 25 November 2013
The author and National Trust chairman chooses his one hundred favourite views in what he calls his "celebration of the hills, valleys, rivers, woods and fields that compose the landscape of England".

His choices range from iconic ones like the White Cliffs of Dover and Hadrian's Wall to those which are less well known, such as the cricket field at Little Bredy in Dorset. He discovers the fascinating stories behind these locations, and shows how many of them have inspired artists and writers. He also considers our emotional responses to the landscape, "the impact it makes on the eye and the imagation".

A consistently readable and often thought-provoking survey of the English landscape.

NOTE:
Since there seems to be some confusion as to the size of the book, it is approximately 9" by 6", or a similar size to his 'England's Thousand Best Churches' and 'England's Thousand Best Houses'; so it's not a large coffee-table size
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 4 September 2014
Information scant, photos not up to much, too wordy!
0Comment|3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 27 February 2015
I would retitle this book 'Some of Englands 100 best views' or 'Simon Jenkins 100 best views in England'. The reason being that I could show you many more and much more impresive, however I am aware that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Non the less there are some beautiful views in the book but I personally feel there are many better that could have been in this book but I don't supose for example that Mr Jenkins has stood on top of Great Gable for example and looked down on Wasdale head and Wastwater. Another thing that put me off was that for Durham City with it's magnificent Norman Cathedral ( once voted the worlds most beautiful building ) and the Norman Castle that sits beside it , high above the city on a hill dominating the surrounding area, the book did not have a photograph but rather an old painting which does not really give the reader an idea of the magnificence of this actual view. Its a decent view but lacking if you know your onions.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 11 November 2013
Although I have only flicked through this publication its quality is obvious. The primary reason for the purchase is the desire it has stirred in my retired parents to visit each area and breathe it in.
The book was delivered quickly and in perfect condition.
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 November 2013
The beautiful photographs included in this book have been a promotional feature in Country Life magazine for some months as full A3 spread views prior to publication and to find that this is an A4 volume with even smaller versions of these gorgeous views was more than disappointing to me. However it was a present to my wife who is aware of other works by this author and accepted the volume with no regrets at all. So I recommend it but castigate the magazine for not making the fact that their views were enlargements of those to be found in the book.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 4 December 2013
This book got an excellent pre-publication review & I bought it on the strength of that. Given the title, I expected a lot of photographs & was very disappointed when the book arrived. The photographs are lovely, there are just not that many of them.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 24 June 2014
Already owning the beat churches and houses of Britain by simon Jenkins i knew what i was expecting and this has lived up to expectations. A wonderful book to read and even better you then get to go and see these places
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)