Customer Reviews


5 Reviews
5 star:
 (1)
4 star:
 (3)
3 star:
 (1)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:    (0)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 

The most helpful favourable review
The most helpful critical review


9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A revisionist account
Easter Island or Rapa Nui, with its massive stone carvings (moai), has long been a place of fascination. The prevailing account of its prehistory, offered by Jared Diamond among others, has been that the island's first inhabitants wiped themselves out, committing 'ecocide' by cutting down all the island's trees, spending precious time and resources carving and...
Published on 24 Oct 2011 by Eleanor

versus
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Walking with statues
This book has something new to say about Easter Island and says it clearly and engrossingly. Written by two archaeologists with a scrupulous concern for evidence and documentation (which gets in the way of the narrative from time to time) this book starts with an account of the researchers’ team’s work that challenges a number of assumptions about Easter...
Published 4 months ago by barbicandy


Most Helpful First | Newest First

9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars A revisionist account, 24 Oct 2011
By 
Eleanor (Oxford, England) - See all my reviews
(TOP 500 REVIEWER)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
Easter Island or Rapa Nui, with its massive stone carvings (moai), has long been a place of fascination. The prevailing account of its prehistory, offered by Jared Diamond among others, has been that the island's first inhabitants wiped themselves out, committing 'ecocide' by cutting down all the island's trees, spending precious time and resources carving and transporting moai, and fighting wars among themselves.

Hunt and Lipo, an archaeologist and anthropologist respectively, challenge this narrative by using archaeological, anthropological, and documentary evidence to interrogate a number of assumptions. They argue instead that 'rather than a case of abject failure, Rapa Nui is an unlikely story of success'. Collapse, they argue, only came after European contact.

The archaeological evidence offered by the authors is compelling and they build a convincing case, although I was more doubtful about some of the arguments taken from sociobiology. As a layperson I found the book clear, readable, and enjoyable. Hunt and Lipo paint a fascinating picture of the island's prehistory, and I also enjoyed their descriptions of archaeological research and reasoning. Throughout the emphasis is on the collaborative nature of their findings and the contributions of past visitors to the island.

The kindle edition of the book contains a few formatting errors and the tables have been slightly mangled in the conversion; it does include the book's photographs and diagrams, although some of these aren't terribly clear.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars The mystery remains, 29 Nov 2011
By 
Max Blackston (Jerusalem, Israel) - See all my reviews
Rapa Nui (Easter Island) is a remote island in the eastern Pacific, scattered with the remains of huge monolithic statues; with a native population whose collective memory of their pre-historic culture has been virtually eliminated by the ravages of their contact with "civilization" over the last 200 years or so, it presents a mystery that many modern researchers have tried to solve. Why did they construct so many of the giant statues ? How did the inhabitants survive for hundreds of years in such a marginal ecological environment - the island has irregular rainfall, no sources of running water, and its volcanic soils are leached of important minerals, and consequently unproductive for many crops that are staple on other Polynesian islands ? Is there in fact a connection between the expenditure of the limited natural resources of the island on building the statues, the current exhausted state of the island's ecosystem, and the virtual collapse of the native population (down to 110 individuals in 1877) in historic times ?

It is this last hypothesis which has been most explicitly espoused by Jared Diamond in his 2005 book "Collapse: How societies choose to fail or succeed". Diamond describes how the reckless use of resources in the quarrying, transportation and erection of the giant statues first denuded the island of its trees, and led to the consequent erosion and mineral impoverishment of its soils; then how rivalry between different clans for the few remaining resources led to intercommunal violence, and the breakdown and final collapse of island society.

The research carried out personally by the present authors leads them to a completely different narrative. Yes, the arrival of the Polynesian colonists in about 1200 AD led to the destruction of the native palm forests. But this was not because they cut the trees down for fuel, or to create sleds to transport the statues and ramps to erect them; it was the Polynesian rats that accompanied the colonists on their canoes - who met no local predators, and whose population grew exponentially - that did the damage. Reflected in the book's title, the authors convincingly demonstrate how megalithic statues weighing many tons could be "walked" along specially prepared pathways without recourse to wooden sleds.

The assumption, that the state of the island's pristine volcanic soils prior to colonization would have made them suitable for producing the usual Polynesian crops, is shown to be mistaken; the volcanic activity that created Rapa Nui was so far in the past, that the island's soils had already been leached of minerals hundreds of thousands of years before any humans arrived on its shores. Although the disappearance of the palm forests did lead to a further deterioration in the soil, the natives were able to deal with that, as they had developed techniques of cultivation for getting the best out of this impoverished environment. All the evidence suggests that a stable population of about 4000 individuals was able to subsist on the island for about 500 years.

It was the arrival and contact with Europeans in the 18th century that led directly to the collapse of island society. Although largely undocumented, because of the sporadic nature of these arrivals, the usual ship born cargo of European diseases - smallpox, syphilis, plague, and other infections to which Europeans had over the centuries developed natural resistance - undoubtedly literally decimated the island's population. The effect of the first and brief contacts by European explorers with other island and New World populations has been well documented; it is estimated, for example, that the first contacts with North American natives resulted in the loss of up to 90% of that population even before the first permanent colony was set up on the eastern seaboard. In the case of Rapa Nui, the unintentional ravages of European diseases were further compounded by the virtual enslavement of this captive population on their own island by rapacious individuals and companies who indentured them into working on the gigantic sheep farm that the island became for about 80 years. It was only in the 1950's, when the Chilean government got rid of these exploiters, that the population had some relief and began to rebound numerically.

The authors' narrative of what happened is very clearly and convincingly presented. What is less successful is their analysis of why - why did the islanders spend so much time and effort in the construction of the gigantic statues. In general terms it is obvious that the statues played some role in Polynesian religion, probably related to ancestor worship; there is evidence of similar types of statuary - though neither so prolific nor so gigantic - on other islands. But the specific explanations they offer lack credibility. The authors have borrowed some textbook explanations from the field of evolutionary psychology, which they slot in here in an attempt to provide their answer to the mystery.

Building the statues was a form of "costly signaling"; like the peacock's tail, conspicuous consumption of resources communicates " better not mess with us, because we mean business; we'll do whatever it takes". According to the authors, this was a strategy used by the Rapanuans to avoid conflict between different groups - families, clans - on the island. Again, they convincingly demonstrate the "what" - that there is no evidence, either in weaponry or in skeletal remains - of large scale intercommunal violence; but their "why" leaves much to be desired.

An additional explanation offered is that "cultural elaboration" - which in this case means building bigger and bigger statues - diverts resources that might otherwise be used in having a greater number of offspring, during periods when the island's marginal and unreliable agriculture might not be able to support a growing population. Although they dutifully explain that individuals do not have to have a deliberate awareness of these strategies for them to have these effects, this explanation also lacks credibility. My understanding of the so-called "bet-hedging" reproductive strategy is that it applies to individuals, not to groups, and that it is essentially a biological response to variations in resources that increases the overall fitness of the individual. Arguing that it can also be a cultural response, which increases the fitness of a group, seems somewhat problematic.

Despite these drawbacks, the book is very worthwhile. Unlike Jared Diamond's a priori thesis, the authors' is based on very thorough empirical research. It certainly unravels at least part of the story of Easter Island even if it does not solve the whole mystery; but, absent the discovery of some Polynesian Rosetta Stone, that may remain a mystery for some time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars Walking with statues, 8 April 2014
This review is from: The Statues That Walked: Unraveling the Mystery of Easter Island (Paperback)
This book has something new to say about Easter Island and says it clearly and engrossingly. Written by two archaeologists with a scrupulous concern for evidence and documentation (which gets in the way of the narrative from time to time) this book starts with an account of the researchers’ team’s work that challenges a number of assumptions about Easter island, notably that overpopulation and wars on the island had led to the exhaustion of natural resources and the ending of its culture and evidence the suggestion that the depredations of the Polynesian rat that accompanied the first settlers and European diseases had been a more important factor. The story is told is a dispassionate and objective fashion that will alienate some readers but which encourages them to consider the evidence for themselves rather than accept a story told with the rhetorical and journalistic flourishes that have marred some previous accounts. One of the final chapters summarises the history of the island since its western discovery, which would have fitted arguably neater the start of the book. One of the most remarkable features of the book is the clarity with which the authors explain some concepts such as the idea of carbon dating in relation to the island. It really is a model of scientific demystification. If some other topics such as gender relations are not exemplified with the same clarity and some areas such as the fossil and other evidence for the extinct flora and fauna if the island then that is minor cavil. This is a demanding read that sits uneasily between scientific and general readerships but is well worth tackling.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Another point of view, 2 Mar 2013
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: The Statues That Walked: Unraveling the Mystery of Easter Island (Paperback)
Interesting theories - so much has been written on these mysterious statues but this book did have good reasoning - so all in all a good read
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Great Read, 27 Feb 2013
By 
Vincent Creelan "Vincebelfast" (Newtownards N Ireland) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
Okay.... can be a bit academic,at times, but that was partly what I was looking. A really clear examination of all research, history and theories relating to all aspects of life on Rapa Nui...... This is the most up to date and comprehensive volume to date, easily readable and very informative. I liked the style of presentation and the flow of information in the way a range of ideas etc were examined. If you are really interested in the Island... this is a must.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

The Statues That Walked: Unraveling the Mystery of Easter Island
10.22
In stock
Add to basket Add to wishlist
Only search this product's reviews